dirt devil said:

Hello! McNabb ain't going anywhere that he doesn't think he could compete for a championship, and he sure as hell doesn't think that Cleveland is ready to compete for a championship!

@reginabrownsfan said:

I agree to some extent and you make a good point.

However, if we do trade for McNabb, how much $ is he going to want? His time in this league is almost up I think and I don't want us to put too much bank into a player that may only give us a couple years of service.

@next2nothing said:

The thing is if there is no one else out there of any talent available it at least buys us some time until we can find a guy we like.

dirt devil said:

But he's 33 so how many good years does he have left? He's also been recently plagued by injury year in and year out. He'd be another Jamal Lewis except at the most important position on the field.

dirt devil said:

I think that Mcnabb is horribly overrated but I have to agree with this.

@the-gipper said:

McNabb, I am sure, does not want to go to a Not Ready For Prime Time Team, which, I am afraid, is what the Browns still are.

I tend to think along the same lines as well...

@the-gipper said:

McNabb, I am sure, does not want to go to a Not Ready For Prime Time Team, which, I am afraid, is what the Browns still are.

Yes, but imagine if you will that the opening day roster in Cleveland does not include Quinn or Derek Anderson and has McNabb, Ratliff and a young draftee (One of three: McCoy, Pike or Lefevour). A trade is a trade. Does McNabb have a no-trade clause?

@the-gipper said:

McNabb, I am sure, does not want to go to a Not Ready For Prime Time Team, which, I am afraid, is what the Browns still are.

Ahhh, I like your cognition.

@playerjdd said:

I don't think the Browns need to take on a 35 year old QB at this point, unless it is in a backup mode, and McNabb ain't going to be a backup. It was different from say a team like the Vikings who were a Super Bowl potential team in need only of a quality veteran hand at QB. The Browns are by no means there.

McNabb, I am sure, does not want to go to a Not Ready For Prime Time Team, which, I am afraid, is what the Browns still are.

pass80yds said:

@mopaji said:

I think it is fair to mopaji. It would help both teams out a lot and make great sense for both teams. After what ive watched here for the past 10 years at QB theres not much that i wouldnt give up to get a good QB. I dont know after watching that crap for so long if i could ever be to picky about getting a proven winner, veteran pro bowl QB.

@playerjdd said:

i don't mcnabb either, i think he doesn't have the killer instinct or anger sometimes needed. too many timesi've seen him laughing at the end of important games when his team has no chance of coming back. give me a phillip rivers type guy who is ready to throw some punches. that being said he is head over heels better than anything we've got. but i would think mcnabb would do anything NOT to come here. he's close to the end and wants a ring now.

@playerjdd said:

i hear ya playerjdd if this is for real im not sure how i would feel about it myself. Mixed feelings on it.

@haydenfox said:

hm maybe because they need a QB and McNabb has said he would want to play for arizona?

its not cleveland i know your a homer but theres no chance its cleveland

@athensbuck26 said:

it could have Arizona who makes more sense

I dont know how Arizona makes more sense at all. But could be Arizona. Cleveland has extra 3rd round picks and could be acquiring more. Add to the fact that phillys most glaring need is at defensive line and shaun rogers is avaliable.

@haydenfox said:

no it really doesnt

@haydenfox said:

no it really doesnt

it could have Arizona who makes more sense

@mopaji said:

At this point, take what you can get for either of these two pin-heads. They can't both be here so you should just take the best offer.

I think they arleady have a plan in order. Philly radio station is reporting that there is a deal in place to ship mcnabb out and the whole eagle front office wants to do it but andy reid is blocking it right now. They didnt mention the team but they did say it was not the st. louis rams. Said it was for a 3rd rounder and a veteran player. That has cleveland written all over it.