@dab7291993 said:

Anthony Henry, Joe Thomas, and Tim Couch.

Henry was pretty good, I shoulda picked him over McCutcheon, but his career was pretty short here, unfortunately. Corey Fulller was another guy I thought of. It is amazing how ordinary all of our safeties have been (at best). None of the WRs stood out, I took KJ and Cutt because they had the best career numbers. I put Verba at guard even though he played tackle most years because, well, the rest of guards have pretty much sucked.

Punter was a strong position with Gardocki, Hodges and Zasty.

Pretty bad when our best standout players are special teamers and a tackle.

Zombo

@chicopee-john said:

Ok, we've seen and heard about the All-Time Browns team and just about any other professional team's All Time Team. The Red Sox just announced their's, for example.

Who, in your opinion, are the 3 best players to wear a Browns uniform since the new Cleveland Browns were born?

With som many draft picks, FA signings, etc., there have been - perhaps as many as 500+ players to wear the uniform.

It might be a touch question to separate any wheat from the chaff but, give it a shot.

Joe Thomas would be one. Who else. Any difference-makers?

Terry Kirby?

Joe Jervicius. If not for the staph infection he would have had a nice career here.

FB Lawrence Vickers

RB Jamal Lewis

WR Kevin Johnson

WR Dennis Northcutt

TE Kellen Winslow

T Joe Thomas

G Eric Steinbach

C Alex Mack

G Ross Verba

T Ryan Tucker

DT Ahtyba Rubin

DT Shaun Rogers

DE Orpheus Roye

DE Kenard Lang

MLB DQ Jackson

OLB Jamir Miller

OLB Kam Wimbley

S TJ Ward

S Sean Jones

CB Joe Haden

CB Daylon McCutcheon

K Phil Dawson

P Dave Zastudil

KR Josh Cribbs

PR Josh Cribbs

LS Ryan Pointbriand

@chicopee-john said:

It's all relative any way.

No, its all relativity!

@the-gipper said:

No, his best years were 2000, 01, 02. Last time I looked those were 21st century.

It's all relative any way.

@clevelandmilidh said:

Joe Thomas, Phil Dawson, Josh Cribbs

Oh, hell yes. You have to include Dawson. My oversight.

@chicopee-john said:

Couch's best days were in the 20th Century, Gipp, but your point is well taken. No difference makers.

No, his best years were 2000, 01, 02. Last time I looked those were 21st century.

@the-gipper said:

I know you are trying to be sarcastic, but the fact is, Tim Couch HAS been one of the Browns best players in the 21st Century.

Couch's best days were in the 20th Century, Gipp, but your point is well taken. No difference makers.

@the-gipper said:

I know you are trying to be sarcastic, but the fact is, Tim Couch HAS been one of the Browns best players in the 21st Century.

I agree. The other two however.....

@diehardbrownsfan said:

Gerard Warren (aka Big Money), Courtney Brown, Tim Couch.

I know you are trying to be sarcastic, but the fact is, Tim Couch HAS been one of the Browns best players in the 21st Century.

@chicopee-john said:

Ok, we've seen and heard about the All-Time Browns team and just about any other professional team's All Time Team. The Red Sox just announced their's, for example.

Who, in your opinion, are the 3 best players to wear a Browns uniform since the new Cleveland Browns were born?

With som many draft picks, FA signings, etc., there have been - perhaps as many as 500+ players to wear the uniform.

It might be a touch question to separate any wheat from the chaff but, give it a shot.

Joe Thomas would be one. Who else. Any difference-makers?

Terry Kirby?

Jim Brown, Otto Graham, and Lou Groza. I do not recognize a concept of "the New Browns" or "Old Browns".

However, if you say...who are the best Browns players of the 21st Century, I will go along with that idea:

Joe Thomas

Josh Cribbs

Alex Mack

Honorable mention to Ryan Pontbriand (long snappers....even if they make multiple Pro Bowls can't really get more than that)