@miktoxic said:

Not in the NFL .........you illetrate Dickhead.

@the-gipper said:

Nice post there Gipper. Going back 50 years there appears not to be a lot of "great QB's". OHio State at least sent a lot to the pro's.

@browns149 said:

I would bet he will take a snap at QB, They will run some gadget trick WildDawg stuff with him. But they better not let him throw. As he's an awful thrower of the ball.

It will take some serious injuries for him to start an NFL game. No matter what team he plays for

He has taken a few WildDawg snaps, but usually the Jags fuck it up and blocking immediately disappears. Those were all last year. I think he attempted one this year but had no time to throw. He's a HB now though. Their starter.

He's not a terrible thrower, he had his moments in college. He us by no means an NFL QB though

Yes, the Jags would have to have every active QB in one gm get hurt. Very unlikely (though I'd love to see it, even I it will 98% go poorly)

@the-cysko-kid said:

Denard Robinson will never play a snap as a qb in the nfl. For as much as you suck that guys balls he's terrible

..... I never said he'd play as a QB. Look at Gippers OSU list.bit included a guy that was basically a HB. That's why I mentioned. Calm down

@the-cysko-kid said:

I would bet he will take a snap at QB, They will run some gadget trick WildDawg stuff with him. But they better not let him throw. As he's an awful thrower of the ball.

It will take some serious injuries for him to start an NFL game. No matter what team he plays for

@mld-woody said:

You forgot Jim harbaugh, 78.

Also, maybe we'll get to add Denard to that list in a season or two...

Anyway, (removing the guy that played HB), that would mean Michigans top 4 QBs are higher than OSUs highest.

But, all of this aside, the point I was making was I felt your assertion that OSU doesn't have alot of hugh producing QBs on that list because they "are not trained in the NFL fashion" is not really legitimate. Unless OSU has been a run spread for a lot longer than I thought.... But even then, we get NFL QBs from those systems.

Denard Robinson will never play a snap as a qb in the nfl. For as much as you suck that guys balls he's terrible

Drew Brees 134

Len Dawson 110

Bob Griese 104

Jim Everett 87

Jeff George 65

Gary Danielson 48

Mike Phipps 40

Kyle Orton 34

Mark Hermann 11

Scott Campbell 8

Curtis Painter 2

Mark Stevens 1

No, the Jags would have to have some crazy shit happen at QB for Denard to play. There was a much better chance of something like that happening decades ago.

@mld-woody said:

While Matte was primarily a HB, he did occasionally start at QB. ( I doubt that Robinson will ever start an NFL game at QB) In fact, Matte famously started at QB in a post season game for the Colts. Johnny Unitas was hurt, backup Gary Cuozzo was hurt, so Matte had to start at QB for the Colts vs. the Packers. Here is the famous wristband that he wore that day which can be seen in the PFHOF:

Also, I mentioned Denard as a "what if" because of the first guy you listed that was mostly a HB

The fact is, that sort of QB has not had as much success for them as the more running QBs. And those guys did not translate into successful pros....with the limited exception of Tomscak.

In the early 70s Michigan had their better success with "option" type QBs with Dennis Franklin and Rick Leach. But then they went to the "pro style" guys for a long long time with the likes of Steve Smith, John Wangler, Harbaugh, Michael Taylor, Harbaugh, Collins, Griese, Brady, Henson, Navarre, and Henne. Recently with Robinson and Gardner they have gone back to a more running/option/spread type of game.

@mld-woody said:

You expect to make the HOF, eh? Cute.

@mld-woody said:

@larryfine said:

The Big Ten has done as well or better than any other conference historically at producing QBs. Just not OSU. Here are the Hall of Famers ....and almost certain HOFers produced by the current lineup of Power 5 conferences:

Big Ten

Len Dawson Purdue

Bob Griese Purdue

Drew Brees Purdue

Otto Graham Northwestern

Tom Brady Michigan

SEC

George Blanda Kentucky

Joe Namath Alabama

Bart Starr Alabama

Fran Tarkenton Georgia

YA Tittle LSU

Peyton Manning Tennessee

Pac-12

Troy Aikman UCLA

Bob Waterfield UCLA

John Elway Stanford

Dan Fouts Oregon

Norm Van Brocklin Oregon

Warren Moon Washington

ACC:

Sonny Jurgenson Duke

Jim Kelly Miami

Dan Marino Pitt

Johnny Unitas Louisville

....big maybe: Rivers NC St.?

Big 12

Bobby Layne Texas

Independents and smaller schools:

Joe Montana Notre Dame

Terry Bradshaw La. Tech

Roger Staubach Navy

Steve Young BYU

Ben Roethlisberger Miami Oh.

Brett Favre So. Miss.

Also, maybe we'll get to add Denard to that list in a season or two...

Anyway, (removing the guy that played HB), that would mean Michigans top 4 QBs are higher than OSUs highest.

But, all of this aside, the point I was making was I felt your assertion that OSU doesn't have alot of hugh producing QBs on that list because they "are not trained in the NFL fashion" is not really legitimate. Unless OSU has been a run spread for a lot longer than I thought.... But even then, we get NFL QBs from those systems.

@mld-woody said:

Here is the list of QBs that both OSU and Michigan have sent to the Pros. Here I am listing anyone that posted even as low as a 1 on the PFR Career Production Average stat:

Michigan

Tom Brady 145

Brian Griese 53

Elvis Grbac 46

Chad Henne 26

Todd Collins 11

Larry Cipa 1

Ohio St.

Tom Matte 67 (While listed as a QB/RB....nearly all his production came as an RB)

Mike Tomscak 43

Tom Tupa 29 (his production was split between QB and Punter)

Kent Graham 20

Terrelle Pryor 7

Troy Smith 6

Art Schlichter 4

Bobby Hoying 3

Joe Germaine 1

@larryfine said:

How much cum guzzles out of your moms asshole on a weekly basis?

Idc about the schools success in college, or with other positions. We're just talking QB. You also made the assertion it was because they weren't trained for the NFL. I think that's BS honestly. Plenty of not pro style college offenses have produced NFL QBs. Also, you have always been a spread