@stinkhole said:

You apparently don't know a thing about Joe Charboneau. His career was very short but sweet, and terminated by injury.

Again, the issue here is duration.

Quoting that Bryant holds some record over a 4 game period and saying how that proves how great he is is like crazy.

At least lets talk about a whole season or something.

Its like saying that Johnny Van Der Meer is greater than Dizzy Dean or Whitey Ford because over a two game stretch he threw no hitters.

@the-gipper said:

By that measure then Joe Charboneau was better than Mickey Mantle, Joe Dimaggio, Willie Mays and Hank Aaron...because in a few games at the beginning of his career he out produced those guys.

That's ridiculous. As Charboneau progressed through his career it became apparent he was no Mickey Mantle.

Bryant is just getting started.

@choco said:

Bryant is reinstated, conditionally.

I meant to say he is reinstated.

@vagitron said:

I didn't make up the record, look it up. Bryant isn't reinstated, Gordon isnt and may not even be a brown.

@choco said:

?

Now theres a record for most TDs by a rookie in their first 4 games?

?

Let's see...I believe it was Gordon who had back to back 200 yard games, and led the league in yardage in 14 games. On the browns. Without even an average QB. With no other weapons on the team.

You're fucking high dude...

I didn't make up the record, look it up. Bryant isn't reinstated, Gordon isnt and may not even be a brown.

Cannot fathom how an NFL factory like Ohio state is 2 hrs away, yet we draft Missedagain scrubs all day long. No buckeyes in sight unless they come to us years after they're drafted

@vagitron said:

Cool. Assuming he stays healthy and on the field I will check back with you at the end of the upcoming season.

Although he set a record for touchdowns his rookie year for the first four games. He caught 6 TD's.

Now theres a record for most TDs by a rookie in their first 4 games?

?

Let's see...I believe it was Gordon who had back to back 200 yard games, and led the league in yardage in 14 games. On the browns. Without even an average QB. With no other weapons on the team.

You're fucking high dude...

@vagitron said:

Nothing wrong with being a millennial. Are you a gen x or a baby boomer? If the latter you fucked everything up for everyone in the first place.

When Bryant is tearing up the league I'm coming for you, you little pom pom tosser

Yeah.. that remains to be seen .. Lets see how tainted his piss turns up in the next few months...

@vagitron said:

By that measure then Joe Charboneau was better than Mickey Mantle, Joe Dimaggio, Willie Mays and Hank Aaron...because in a few games at the beginning of his career he out produced those guys.

@vagitron said:

Your argument has no more validity than an argument that says that Gordon is better than Antonio Brown. (for like the one year they both played, perhaps Gordon was better) But no one would argue that Gordon has been a more productive WR than Brown.

You may as well argue that Bryant is better than Brown. Why don't you do that? Because it makes no sense, nor does it make sense to argue that Bryant is better than Gordon.

@stinkhole said:

Again, you are making the Gomer Pyle is a better soldier than Sgt York argument.

What can York do better than Gomer?

It not what he can do better...it is what he DID do better.

@vagitron said:

@nickers said:

whippy fizz.. your blowing more hot air Millenial...

When Bryant is tearing up the league I'm coming for you, you little pom pom tosser

@vagitron said:

Cool. Assuming he stays healthy and on the field I will check back with you at the end of the upcoming season.

Although he set a record for touchdowns his rookie year for the first four games. He caught 6 TD's.

whippy fizz.. your blowing more hot air Millenial...

@choco said:

Blah blah blah...

Homer says Inferior player is awesome...

Lemme know hen MB does anything of note...Like, etch his name in the Halls.

Franchise qb, nothing

Pathetic franchise, receive broke records. Come talk to me when he does some thing of note.

Cool. Assuming he stays healthy and on the field I will check back with you at the end of the upcoming season.

Although he set a record for touchdowns his rookie year for the first four games. He caught 6 TD's.

@vagitron said:

Bryant has never played a full season, nor did he play in games with a ton of garbage time. Gordon got a lot of yardage in his very good season in garbage time.

Blah blah blah...

Homer says Inferior player is awesome...

Lemme know hen MB does anything of note...Like, etch his name in the Halls.

Franchise qb, nothing

Pathetic franchise, receive broke records. Come talk to me when he does some thing of note.

@mudfly said:

How about 800 yards and 5 TD's in 4 games......with 3 different(shitty) QB's throwing him the ball?.

Has Bryant even done that with a whole season and future HOF QB?.....

(Just a rhetorical question....I already know the answer)....

Bryant is a freak of nature, really. His ability after the catch at his size is remarkable and he's insane fast. Antonio Brown is an animal but some of that is his relentless work ethic, if Bryant can channel any of that he's going to be damn near unstoppable and I'd say that if he were a Cleveland brown, watch some of his after the catch high lights. He moves like brown at 6'4 and he's faster.

@mudfly said:

How about 800 yards and 5 TD's in 4 games......with 3 different(shitty) QB's throwing him the ball?.

Has Bryant even done that with a whole season and future HOF QB?.....

(Just a rhetorical question....I already know the answer)....

Those are statistics.

I took Cameos statement to mean that Gordon has better tools or greater physical attributes.

Again, what can Gordon do that Bryant can't?

I never saw Gordon catch a ball behind his legs while doing a forward somersault!

Gordon played in more games,35... Bryant only 22 never playing a full season.. But Bryant had the better QB.

There is no argument there.

@stinkhole said:

How about 800 yards and 5 TD's in 4 games......with 3 different(shitty) QB's throwing him the ball?.

Has Bryant even done that with a whole season and future HOF QB?.....

(Just a rhetorical question....I already know the answer)....

@runyon27 said:

This statement is dumb. Who the hell cares if he is taller or faster or whatever. What counts is what you do on the field. From what has occurred on the field Gordon is a far better WR,

What counts is what you do on the field? Ok, then please elaborate.

A player theoretically needs only one game to prove what he can do on the field. What can Gordon do that Bryant cant?

@htownbrown said:

You stupid fucking Stooler trolls. Gordon has never had a decent QB. Gordon has never had anyone to pull coverage away from him. Everyone knew he was the offense and couldn't stop him.

If there was no Bell, no Brown, no Rapist who the fuck would Bryant be? Less than what his slightly above average ass is right now.

Notice how 'amazing' Wallace was when he left?

Um... I clearly stated that if Bryant were a Brown he would have compiled the same numbers as Gordon did that year.

To say Gordon is twice as good as Bryant is stupid.

@comeonman said:

Yes, but the majority of those yards came in "garbage time" lol

I've also heard that, but from Browns fans. Grossi was one of them I believe.

@comeonman said:

Yes, but the majority of those yards came in "garbage time" lol

They did when the browns were getting dusted and the opposing team was playing soft d. You can look it up.

@runyon27 said:

This statement is dumb. Who the hell cares if he is taller or faster or whatever. What counts is what you do on the field. From what has occurred on the field Gordon is a far better WR, maybe Bryant will show at some point he is equal or better. But as of right now Bryant's production is nothing compared to Gordon. Sad thing is Gordon may never play again because of self inflicted problems. Maybe Bryant has learned his lesson will see. BTW during 2013 I believe Gordon lead the NFL in receiving yards while only playing 14 games, when Bryant equals that then we can talk.