@stillmotion said:

but would you rather have a Baker Mayfield that wants to be in Cleveland, or a Josh Rosen who refuses to play in Cleveland?

Jim Kelly wanted nothing to do with playing for the Buffalo Bills. He's practically "Mr. Buffalo".

I have serious doubts about Mayfield being successful in the NFL.

@dutch-oven said:

There's probably not a player I'm more intrigued about seeing play in the NFL, but I don't want to see him wearing the brown and orange to do it.

but would you rather have a Baker Mayfield that wants to be in Cleveland, or a Josh Rosen who refuses to play in Cleveland?

@jiggins7919 said:

I know, I know. Believe me I know. Lol. 

But like I've said before, the guy that finally raises our team from the ashes is going to be a special personality. A no-fear, worked for everything, grind it out type kid with a ton of heart. Obviously this is just my absurd opinion, but I've felt this way for a long time. 

I still believe Rosen is the smart pick, and also the one we'll go with in the end. But if Mayfield turns out to be a very good player, it wouldn't surprise me at all. 

Baker Mayfield is the Johnny Manziel of the 2018 NFL Draft for me...

There's probably not a player I'm more intrigued about seeing play in the NFL, but I don't want to see him wearing the brown and orange to do it.

@dutch-oven said:

I'm not real keen on Mayfield being a Cleveland Brown, but I agree with you jiggins on that.

Baker Mayfield strikes me as the type of guy that would gladly take the challenge of being the QB for the worst team in the NFL.

Then again, Manziel also adamantly wanted to be drafted by the Browns, so.... 

I know, I know. Believe me I know. Lol. 

But like I've said before, the guy that finally raises our team from the ashes is going to be a special personality. A no-fear, worked for everything, grind it out type kid with a ton of heart. Obviously this is just my absurd opinion, but I've felt this way for a long time. 

I still believe Rosen is the smart pick, and also the one we'll go with in the end. But if Mayfield turns out to be a very good player, it wouldn't surprise me at all. 

@jiggins7919 said:

It's a fair question but one that won't really be an issue in my opinion. It's very rare for a QB to refuse to play somewhere, and I don't believe it's ever happened twice in one draft, has it? If it DOES somehow happen, we trade the pick and take Baker Mayfield or Lamar Jackson. Either of them would be delighted to play for us in my twisted brain. Baker Mayfield seems like the kind of guy who WANTS a challenge like leading our team. Why I think that....not totally sure. Just a hunch. 

I'm not real keen on Mayfield being a Cleveland Brown, but I agree with you jiggins on that.

Baker Mayfield strikes me as the type of guy that would gladly take the challenge of being the QB for the worst team in the NFL.

Then again, Manziel also adamantly wanted to be drafted by the Browns, so....