which qbs
-
I believe Stanton has the edge
because he isn't going to make mistakes, reading defenses and fancy crap defenses will throw at the Browns.
But in a big game, everybody knows Stanton has seen pretty much everything, knows how to run the offense. Gilbert was really impressive...
But experience counts hugely, and I think it's Baker, Stanton/Gilbert. Blough on the practice squad. He needs time there.
My argument against Stanton is that, while he may have experience, the record indicates that he totally bites when he playss....year after year....at least he is consistent.
He has a lifetime QB rating of 66....53% completion rate....more int's than TD's....Baker threw more TDs in his one partial rookie season than Stanton has thrown in 11 seasons....etc, etc, etc
In 11 years, Stanton has exactly 2 games that he has earned a 100 + QB rating.....Gilbert has done it everytime he has played an NFL game....which is only 3 times.....so 3 times in 3 games VS 2 times in 11 seasons....
So.....not sure what skills or talent Stanton has that earns him the position over someone who has out performed him at every opportunity.....
If it's leadership....knowing how to prepare....etc.....all that can just as easily be done from the #3 position
Seriously....even Johnny Manziel had better #'s....across the board......
My argument against Stanton is that, while he may have experience, the record indicates that he totally bites when he playss....year after year....at least he is consistent.
He has a lifetime QB rating of 66....53% completion rate....more int's than TD's....Baker threw more TDs in his one partial rookie season than Stanton has thrown in 11 seasons....etc, etc, etc
In 11 years, Stanton has exactly 2 games that he has earned a 100 + QB rating.....Gilbert has done it everytime he has played an NFL game....which is only 3 times.....so 3 times in 3 games VS 2 times in 11 seasons....
So.....not sure what skills or talent Stanton has that earns him the position over someone who has out performed him at every opportunity.....
If it's leadership....knowing how to prepare....etc.....all that can just as easily be done from the #3 position
Seriously....even Johnny Manziel had better #'s....across the board......
I agree basically. Stanton should be the #3 and Gilbert Grape should be #2. Like you said, he can perform his "coach on the field" duties from the #2 spot.
-
IMO....the QB roster depends on what they wind up thinking of Blough after game 4.
If they view him as PS material at best.....then they'll keep Stanton & Gilbert.
If he winds up impressing them, then Stanton would be let go. (I would not bet heavily on this scenario)
Unless Gilbert's play goes straight into the shitter over the next two weeks, he'll be on the team.
-
My argument against Stanton is that, while he may have experience, the record indicates that he totally bites when he playss....year after year....at least he is consistent.
He has a lifetime QB rating of 66....53% completion rate....more int's than TD's....Baker threw more TDs in his one partial rookie season than Stanton has thrown in 11 seasons....etc, etc, etc
In 11 years, Stanton has exactly 2 games that he has earned a 100 + QB rating.....Gilbert has done it everytime he has played an NFL game....which is only 3 times.....so 3 times in 3 games VS 2 times in 11 seasons....
So.....not sure what skills or talent Stanton has that earns him the position over someone who has out performed him at every opportunity.....
If it's leadership....knowing how to prepare....etc.....all that can just as easily be done from the #3 position
Seriously....even Johnny Manziel had better #'s....across the board......
I agree basically. Stanton should be the #3 and Gilbert Grape should be #2. Like you said, he can perform his "coach on the field" duties from the #2 spot.
I agree basically. Stanton should be the #3 and Gilbert Grape should be #2. Like you said, he can perform his "coach on the field" duties from the #3 spot.
Fixed your "coach on the field" part of the post to #3 spot-I know what you meant.
No argument here from me Gip. LOL!?
Gilbert has played very well this go-round in the NFL.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login