Skip to content

Who do you think our starting QB will be?

The Browns Board
213 23 7.9k 1
  • @korsou-dawg said:

    Joe Milton released by Dallas. Would probably be an improvement over any of the four QBs on our roster. Do we take a swing?

    I would've said yes, until this past April's draft when we drafted one of those QB's.

    So, here we go into another season with major concerns at the QB position. The main question being, will we be drafting one at the top of next year's draft. Here's my take: Yes (short answer)

    Why: Sanders couldn't beat out Watson for the starting job. Monken is well aware that Watson's odds of being on the team next year are quite low. And that he's hated by the fans. If Sanders were anywhere near close to Watson's perceived abilities, he'd be the starter. So I'm assuming that Sanders isn't even close. Which means that we want to improve upon him next April by trying to settle the QB position once and for all.

    Korsou DawgK Korsou Dawg wrote on last edited by

    @orion said:

    The main question being, will we be drafting one at the top of next year's draft. Here's my take: Yes (short answer)

    I agree, but with a slightly different version of your take on QB1.

    Watson starting is confirmation to me that we are tanking. The fan base hates him already, so the FO can blame the lost season on him, while getting the early picks they want. Maybe Sanders gets a few games towards the end of the season, when all is already lost (as intended). Thereby taking away any counter to drafting a QB and revamping the room.

  • @orion said:

    The main question being, will we be drafting one at the top of next year's draft. Here's my take: Yes (short answer)

    I agree, but with a slightly different version of your take on QB1.

    Watson starting is confirmation to me that we are tanking. The fan base hates him already, so the FO can blame the lost season on him, while getting the early picks they want. Maybe Sanders gets a few games towards the end of the season, when all is already lost (as intended). Thereby taking away any counter to drafting a QB and revamping the room.

    OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by

    @korsou-dawg said:

    I agree, but with a slightly different version of your take on QB1.

    Watson starting is confirmation to me that we are tanking. The fan base hates him already, so the FO can blame the lost season on him, while getting the early picks they want. Maybe Sanders gets a few games towards the end of the season, when all is already lost (as intended). Thereby taking away any counter to drafting a QB and revamping the room.

    I see Monken as having too much character to be party to that sort of thing. I'm going with Occom's Razor on this. Monken simply doesn't think Sanders is as good as Watson.

    And if we wanted to tank, we were 2 games away from Fernando Mendoza last year. Everyone's Mom loves him. Instead we won our final 2 games and fell to 6th pick.

    There is however, a certain couple of facts. Arch Manning will be in this draft. And Haslem wants to be associated with the Mannings in the worst way,

  • OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by

    image.png

    Is this informant the Limo driver? It would be quite sad if true. With Haslam at the winter meetings saying out loud that the Watson thing was a swing and a miss....I find it odd that now he wants to go up to the plate yet again, with the same bat.

  • image.png

    Is this informant the Limo driver? It would be quite sad if true. With Haslam at the winter meetings saying out loud that the Watson thing was a swing and a miss....I find it odd that now he wants to go up to the plate yet again, with the same bat.

    nickersN nickers wrote on last edited by

    @orion said:

    image.png

    Is this informant the Limo driver? It would be quite sad if true. With Haslam at the winter meetings saying out loud that the Watson thing was a swing and a miss....I find it odd that now he wants to go up to the plate yet again, with the same bat.

    It has to be Jimmy.. He went to his wedding for Christ sake!.. jimmy is a dumb asshole... And now Moken is a big asshole for going along with this shit... jimmy doesn't give a fuck and neither does Monken.... And we know Deshaun doesn't give a shit.... They all got their money... And like always.. The fans pay for it.. Why in hell did I think it would be different this year?

  • @orion said:

    image.png

    Is this informant the Limo driver? It would be quite sad if true. With Haslam at the winter meetings saying out loud that the Watson thing was a swing and a miss....I find it odd that now he wants to go up to the plate yet again, with the same bat.

    It has to be Jimmy.. He went to his wedding for Christ sake!.. jimmy is a dumb asshole... And now Moken is a big asshole for going along with this shit... jimmy doesn't give a fuck and neither does Monken.... And we know Deshaun doesn't give a shit.... They all got their money... And like always.. The fans pay for it.. Why in hell did I think it would be different this year?

    OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by Orion

    @nickers said:

    Why in hell did I think it would be different this year?

    Probably because of DePo's departure.

    I'm going to hope that starting Watson was Monken's decision and that he didn't put any weight into Haslam's opinions.

  • sydS syd wrote on last edited by syd

    the o-line did not play together at all in pre season , are these first two games just trying to see if they gel ? maybe just let #4 get beat up and hopefully they play well for #2 ?

    edit : Barber is starting for the rest of the year

  • @nickers said:

    Why in hell did I think it would be different this year?

    Probably because of DePo's departure.

    I'm going to hope that starting Watson was Monken's decision and that he didn't put any weight into Haslam's opinions.

    M Marvin the Martian wrote on last edited by

    @orion said:

    Probably because of DePo's departure.

    I'm going to hope that starting Watson was Monken's decision and that he didn't put any weight into Haslam's opinions.

    You should attend Optimist's Anonymous. As badly as Watson has played, how could Sanders do any worse

  • @orion said:

    Probably because of DePo's departure.

    I'm going to hope that starting Watson was Monken's decision and that he didn't put any weight into Haslam's opinions.

    You should attend Optimist's Anonymous. As badly as Watson has played, how could Sanders do any worse

    OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by

    @marvin-the-martian said:

    You should attend Optimist's Anonymous. As badly as Watson has played, how could Sanders do any worse

    My name is Orion. And I'm an Optimist. WELCOME ORION!!! πŸ™‚

    ...actually, I'm usually a pessimist...that way I'm not as disappointed.

    If Monken actually chose Watson because he was the best of his QB Crop, then the question actually is: As badly as Watson has played, how bad must Sanders be to not get the call to start? He'd have to be pretty bad.

    Haslam has always struck me as the guy that wants Glitz! He wants the Glitzy guy. I would argue that Watson is not the glitzy guy in comparison to Sanders. Sanders is far more popular with the fans. Heck, his father is Prime Time! I would've thought that Haslam would've liked nothing better than for Watson to be mostly invisible on the bench this season and then put the Watson deal to bed next June.

  • @marvin-the-martian said:

    You should attend Optimist's Anonymous. As badly as Watson has played, how could Sanders do any worse

    My name is Orion. And I'm an Optimist. WELCOME ORION!!! πŸ™‚

    ...actually, I'm usually a pessimist...that way I'm not as disappointed.

    If Monken actually chose Watson because he was the best of his QB Crop, then the question actually is: As badly as Watson has played, how bad must Sanders be to not get the call to start? He'd have to be pretty bad.

    Haslam has always struck me as the guy that wants Glitz! He wants the Glitzy guy. I would argue that Watson is not the glitzy guy in comparison to Sanders. Sanders is far more popular with the fans. Heck, his father is Prime Time! I would've thought that Haslam would've liked nothing better than for Watson to be mostly invisible on the bench this season and then put the Watson deal to bed next June.

    M Marvin the Martian wrote on last edited by

    @orion said:

    My name is Orion. And I'm an Optimist. WELCOME ORION!!! πŸ™‚

    ...actually, I'm usually a pessimist...that way I'm not as disappointed.

    If Monken actually chose Watson because he was the best of his QB Crop, then the question actually is: As badly as Watson has played, how bad must Sanders be to not get the call to start? He'd have to be pretty bad.

    Haslam has always struck me as the guy that wants Glitz! He wants the Glitzy guy. I would argue that Watson is not the glitzy guy in comparison to Sanders. Sanders is far more popular with the fans. Heck, his father is Prime Time! I would've thought that Haslam would've liked nothing better than for Watson to be mostly invisible on the bench this season and then put the Watson deal to bed next June.

    I suspect Haslam will resign Watson and not draft a highly rated QB

  • @orion said:

    My name is Orion. And I'm an Optimist. WELCOME ORION!!! πŸ™‚

    ...actually, I'm usually a pessimist...that way I'm not as disappointed.

    If Monken actually chose Watson because he was the best of his QB Crop, then the question actually is: As badly as Watson has played, how bad must Sanders be to not get the call to start? He'd have to be pretty bad.

    Haslam has always struck me as the guy that wants Glitz! He wants the Glitzy guy. I would argue that Watson is not the glitzy guy in comparison to Sanders. Sanders is far more popular with the fans. Heck, his father is Prime Time! I would've thought that Haslam would've liked nothing better than for Watson to be mostly invisible on the bench this season and then put the Watson deal to bed next June.

    I suspect Haslam will resign Watson and not draft a highly rated QB

    OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by

    @marvin-the-martian said:

    I suspect Haslam will resign Watson and not draft a highly rated QB

    I think the Martian 'air' is starting to get to ya. That wouldn't be at all glitzy. No, the draft is where one can get maximum glitz.

  • @marvin-the-martian said:

    I suspect Haslam will resign Watson and not draft a highly rated QB

    I think the Martian 'air' is starting to get to ya. That wouldn't be at all glitzy. No, the draft is where one can get maximum glitz.

    T TexasAg1969 wrote on last edited by

    @orion said:

    I think the Martian 'air' is starting to get to ya. That wouldn't be at all glitzy. No, the draft is where one can get maximum glitz.

    It'll be Arch (Max Glitz) Manning.

  • OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by Orion

    β€œDee and Jimmy Haslam really want a winning football team for that city. It is no doubt about it. I know there’s questions about whether they are too hands-on and they need to back away, or whatever it is, but at the same time with some of these circumstances, I would never say that it’s just black and white,” Landry said. (Jarvis)

  • sydS syd wrote on last edited by
  • @orion said:

    My name is Orion. And I'm an Optimist. WELCOME ORION!!! πŸ™‚

    ...actually, I'm usually a pessimist...that way I'm not as disappointed.

    If Monken actually chose Watson because he was the best of his QB Crop, then the question actually is: As badly as Watson has played, how bad must Sanders be to not get the call to start? He'd have to be pretty bad.

    Haslam has always struck me as the guy that wants Glitz! He wants the Glitzy guy. I would argue that Watson is not the glitzy guy in comparison to Sanders. Sanders is far more popular with the fans. Heck, his father is Prime Time! I would've thought that Haslam would've liked nothing better than for Watson to be mostly invisible on the bench this season and then put the Watson deal to bed next June.

    I suspect Haslam will resign Watson and not draft a highly rated QB

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by

    @marvin-the-martian said:

    I suspect Haslam will resign Watson and not draft a highly rated QB

    I suspect that you will obsessively post about Watson for as long as this board lasts

  • @marvin-the-martian said:

    I suspect Haslam will resign Watson and not draft a highly rated QB

    I suspect that you will obsessively post about Watson for as long as this board lasts

    Korsou DawgK Korsou Dawg wrote on last edited by

    @Dutch-Oven re-signing Watson is no longer a troll though. It's a legit option πŸ˜…

  • @Dutch-Oven re-signing Watson is no longer a troll though. It's a legit option πŸ˜…

    OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by
    @Korsou-Dawg said:
    @Dutch-Oven re-signing Watson is no longer a troll though. It's a legit option πŸ˜…


    I've given only a little thought as to Watson's future with us since being named the starter because there's still 3/4 of the season to play. I've always felt that he'd be a June 1st cut. I still feel that way...but not as strongly as before. I still feel that with two 1st round picks, we try to move into position to take our future QB in next April's draft. But the season has to play out, both for Watson, and the potential QB's of the draft.

  • OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by

    Sanders had better be prepared to win games when he gets his shot. Watson and his somewhat fragile body is overdue for his season ending injury. But by winning 3 straight to vault us into 1st place he has raised the bar for Shedeur. Sanders has to prove that he's the better option than Watson...AND that he's the better option than using draft assets to get one of the top QB's in the '27 draft.
    Also on the horizon is Gabriel and his coming off of IR. I'm assuming that that decision about carrying 4 QB's is not far off.

  • Sanders had better be prepared to win games when he gets his shot. Watson and his somewhat fragile body is overdue for his season ending injury. But by winning 3 straight to vault us into 1st place he has raised the bar for Shedeur. Sanders has to prove that he's the better option than Watson...AND that he's the better option than using draft assets to get one of the top QB's in the '27 draft.
    Also on the horizon is Gabriel and his coming off of IR. I'm assuming that that decision about carrying 4 QB's is not far off.

    bbedwardB bbedward wrote on last edited by
    @Orion said:
    Sanders had better be prepared to win games when he gets his shot. Watson and his somewhat fragile body is overdue for his season ending injury. But by winning 3 straight to vault us into 1st place he has raised the bar for Shedeur. Sanders has to prove that he's the better option than Watson...AND that he's the better option than using draft assets to get one of the top QB's in the '27 draft.
    Also on the horizon is Gabriel and his coming off of IR. I'm assuming that that decision about carrying 4 QB's is not far off.


    I have no idea why people are so hopeful for Sanders. I get that people wanted him over Watson because of Watson's past and sexual assault accusations and all - but Sanders has shown absolutely nothing that should lead anything to believe that he's even a capable backup.

    I'd feel a lot better if our backup QB was someone like Keenum.

    Also with the trajectory and how weak our schedule is feels like top prospects in 27' are going to be out of the Browns reach.

    I'm not optimistic about any of the Browns (3) QB prospects theyre carrying, although Taylen Green has the most potential albeit by far the most rough around the edges.

  • @Orion said:
    Sanders had better be prepared to win games when he gets his shot. Watson and his somewhat fragile body is overdue for his season ending injury. But by winning 3 straight to vault us into 1st place he has raised the bar for Shedeur. Sanders has to prove that he's the better option than Watson...AND that he's the better option than using draft assets to get one of the top QB's in the '27 draft.
    Also on the horizon is Gabriel and his coming off of IR. I'm assuming that that decision about carrying 4 QB's is not far off.


    I have no idea why people are so hopeful for Sanders. I get that people wanted him over Watson because of Watson's past and sexual assault accusations and all - but Sanders has shown absolutely nothing that should lead anything to believe that he's even a capable backup.

    I'd feel a lot better if our backup QB was someone like Keenum.

    Also with the trajectory and how weak our schedule is feels like top prospects in 27' are going to be out of the Browns reach.

    I'm not optimistic about any of the Browns (3) QB prospects theyre carrying, although Taylen Green has the most potential albeit by far the most rough around the edges.

    nickersN nickers wrote on last edited by
    @bbedward said:
    I have no idea why people are so hopeful for Sanders. I get that people wanted him over Watson because of Watson's past and sexual assault accusations and all - but Sanders has shown absolutely nothing that should lead anything to believe that he's even a capable backup.

    I'd feel a lot better if our backup QB was someone like Keenum.

    Also with the trajectory and how weak our schedule is feels like top prospects in 27' are going to be out of the Browns reach.

    I'm not optimistic about any of the Browns (3) QB prospects theyre carrying, although Taylen Green has the most potential albeit by far the most rough around the edges.


    To be fair... The jury is still out on Sanders... He's young in his career... His day will come... Rodgers sat behind Favre a few years as did Love behind Rodgers..

  • @bbedward said:
    I have no idea why people are so hopeful for Sanders. I get that people wanted him over Watson because of Watson's past and sexual assault accusations and all - but Sanders has shown absolutely nothing that should lead anything to believe that he's even a capable backup.

    I'd feel a lot better if our backup QB was someone like Keenum.

    Also with the trajectory and how weak our schedule is feels like top prospects in 27' are going to be out of the Browns reach.

    I'm not optimistic about any of the Browns (3) QB prospects theyre carrying, although Taylen Green has the most potential albeit by far the most rough around the edges.


    To be fair... The jury is still out on Sanders... He's young in his career... His day will come... Rodgers sat behind Favre a few years as did Love behind Rodgers..

    OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by Orion
    @nickers said:
    To be fair... The jury is still out on Sanders...


    Right. None of our QB's could really be properly evaluated last year. The QB's had nothing to work with. No OLine. No Denzel Boston, no KC Concepcion, It was a shit show.

    @nickers said: (was actually bbedward that said that)
    I have no idea why people are so hopeful for Sanders.


    Because he's on the team and his college QB stats were right up there with the best in the draft.

    @nickers said: (was actually bbedward that said that)
    I'd feel a lot better if our backup QB was someone like Keenum.


    Absolutely. But that assumes that you've got your franchise QB in place. We didn't even know who our starter was until just before the season started.

    @nickers said: (was actually bbedward that said that)
    Also with the trajectory and how weak our schedule is feels like top prospects in 27' are going to be out of the Browns reach.


    We have two 1st round picks. That alone brings a lot of the draft board within reach.