Skip to content
The Browns Board
  1. Home
  2. The Browns Board
  3. Cribbs on block??

Cribbs on block??

The Browns Board
52 39 4.5k

  • regardless of the Browns reasonings; I watched the Monday Night football game and it seemed as though Miami already has a few too many WildDawg players that they can't even get into the game. They spent a first round draft pick on a P/K returner in Ted Ginn Jr.

    I can't believe this would be the team to deal Cribbs too, unless the Browns were getting a WR or RB out of the deal in a sign and trade. I think someone watch the same game i did and thought of the idea of using Cribbs in that set and here we are today caught up in yet another trade rumor. Geez, the Brady Quinn thing hasn't even gotten cold yet.

  • no way this deal gets done. it would be terrible for many reasons: the first being that we would be getting rid of the only player who can get us into scoring position. the second being that he is the leader of the team on and off the field. the third, and the biggest, reason being that he is by far the fan's favorite and mankok knows that if they get rid of him they won't sell out a game for two seasons. he stays put and hopefully gets a better contract this offseason. i can't think of anyone who deserves it more.

    once a fan, always a fan. married to a steeler fan. aaaaaaaaah! --andy
  • ballpeenB ballpeen

    No problem.

    Seeing as we don't use the guy for much other than kicks, and Miami would, I think we may trade him.

    It won't be popular, but if this is the boat we are on, then a trade might be our best move.

    I would think Cribbs would bring considerable value to the Fins. They may really want to go spread/option type football, and Cribbs would be a great addition...that said, I would seek qb level compensation....2 fairly high...like 2nd this year and a potential 1st the following based on his accumulated numbers over the rest of this season and next.

    @ballpeen said:

    ...that said, I would seek qb level compensation....2 fairly high...like 2nd this year and a potential 1st the following based on his accumulated numbers over the rest of this season and next.

    'Peen, you been sippin' this morning??

    "God is great. Beer is good. People are crazy."
    ballpeenB 1 Reply

  • OH HELL NO!!!!!!! 😠

  • C Chicopee John

    @ballpeen said:

    ...that said, I would seek qb level compensation....2 fairly high...like 2nd this year and a potential 1st the following based on his accumulated numbers over the rest of this season and next.

    'Peen, you been sippin' this morning??

    @chicopee-john said:

    'Peen, you been sippin' this morning??

    LOL.....no, never before 4pm during the week unless it is a after round beer or 2 when I play a early round of golf.

    I know it seems high, but i have to take a look at what they may gain. Cribbs was a qb. If that is their intent, my intent is to get compensated.

    Really...a 2nd would be about it, but hey, might as well try.

    If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.
  • GipsG Gips

    Cheap seems to be the law of the mankok regime..and if cribbs hasnt proven he is worth much more than he is getting paid to mangini yet...he isnt going too..i consider cribbs a staple and the only true star that this team has..daboll doesnt use him enough due to a lack of football knowledge and creativity in this clubs offensive sets and at miami he would be used in the WildDawg scheme a whole bunch...it would make a lot of sense for miami to pursue him and unfortunately it would make a lot of sense for cribbs to be interested..

    Man we cant afford to lose him...

    Thanks peen!

    @gips said:

    Cheap seems to be the law of the mankok regime..and if cribbs hasnt proven he is worth much more than he is getting paid to mangini yet...he isnt going too..i consider cribbs a staple and the only true star that this team has..daboll doesnt use him enough due to a lack of football knowledge and creativity in this clubs offensive sets and at miami he would be used in the WildDawg scheme a whole bunch...it would make a lot of sense for miami to pursue him and unfortunately it would make a lot of sense for cribbs to be interested..

    Man we cant afford to lose him...

    Thanks peen!

    I really don't know if I could keep rooting for this team if they traded cribbs... Its already getting hard to even care.

    L 1 Reply

  • Horrible idea.

    Flies right in the face of that whole "gives us the best chance to win" line Manginer has been coughing up.

    Cribbs didn't prove to be a successful WR in this system (20 second timeout: do we have someone in the skilled positions that could considered 'a success'? No.)

    So for a return guy, Cribbs is making bank. As for the value he brings to the Browns, he's getting seriously ripped off. Like, Ponzi scheme status.

    Sure, luck means a lot in football. Not having a good quarterback is bad luck. -Don Shula

  • if cribbs is traded I will have completly lost all faith in this organization. Hes the one "playmaker" on this team. the field position he provides for our pathetic offense is the only hope they have at scoring. Plus I just got the wife an authentic Cribbs jersey for her Bday. That will be 3 in a row. mother effer.

    ❤

  • I do not buy it guys...

    Cribbs is a playmaker..and while he was a bit bitchy in the offseason has shut up and done his job thus far..i expect he will get rewarded based on this season...he is doing more than ever...and hes back to gunning on special teams as well...would be a sad day if they traded him...unless of course the trade was too good to be true..like a 1st and a player or 2...and i mean like a good player or 2..haha...

    Packers fans keep stirring up that we are trading Joe Thomas to them as well...good luck with THAT!

    If they traded JT poop will hit the ceiling fan...and sling all over the room.

    ~Silence is boring!

  • Who was the kid we had returning punts in the preseason? He looked pretty good as a Cribbs replacement. Is he still on the roster?

    I think when Cribbs didn't make it as a receiver that it blew up any contract talks. Teams knocking on the door may spend big bucks for a P/K returner to get them to the promise land. Do we really need to have our best player be a P/K returner though? Seems kind of like bragging that at the entrepreneur convention that your compact car gets great gas mileage.

  • ? Guest

    Who was the kid we had returning punts in the preseason? He looked pretty good as a Cribbs replacement. Is he still on the roster?

    I think when Cribbs didn't make it as a receiver that it blew up any contract talks. Teams knocking on the door may spend big bucks for a P/K returner to get them to the promise land. Do we really need to have our best player be a P/K returner though? Seems kind of like bragging that at the entrepreneur convention that your compact car gets great gas mileage.

    @carddawg said:

    Who was the kid we had returning punts in the preseason? He looked pretty good as a Cribbs replacement. Is he still on the roster?

    I think when Cribbs didn't make it as a receiver that it blew up any contract talks. Teams knocking on the door may spend big bucks for a P/K returner to get them to the promise land. Do we really need to have our best player be a P/K returner though? Seems kind of like bragging that at the entrepreneur convention that your compact car gets great gas mileage.

    Gerard Lawson

  • gerard lawson......

    i guess im the only one that doesn't mind this. yes, he's a playmaker, and my opinion has no bearing on his ability. the sad reality is that we need as many picks as we can get to get this shitbox turned around.

  • The Dolphins just drafted Pat White in the SECOND ROUND - 44th overall.

    They aren't trading for Cribbs...

    CHANGE IS GOOD
  • S Squintz

    The Dolphins just drafted Pat White in the SECOND ROUND - 44th overall.

    They aren't trading for Cribbs...

    @squintz said:

    The Dolphins just drafted Pat White in the SECOND ROUND - 44th overall.

    They aren't trading for Cribbs...

    thanks.gif

    2009-10 Browns Prediction: 8-8

  • If we traded Cribbs I would stop being a fan for the rest of the season. Take from that what you will, but he is our best (and my favorite) player on the team, outside of Joe Thomas

    "The purpose of the military is to kill people and break things " - mike huckabee

  • Can you seriously imagine a 2nd round pick adding as much value to this team as Cribbs?

    I think the odds of that are not in our favor.

    Imagine if we'd done this deal in the offseason: we would have traded Cribbs for Robiske.

    Cough up the big money, and sign Cribbs to a long term deal. This isn't the same as dealing Winslow, Edwards, or even Quinn.

  • ? Guest

    @gips said:

    Cheap seems to be the law of the mankok regime..and if cribbs hasnt proven he is worth much more than he is getting paid to mangini yet...he isnt going too..i consider cribbs a staple and the only true star that this team has..daboll doesnt use him enough due to a lack of football knowledge and creativity in this clubs offensive sets and at miami he would be used in the WildDawg scheme a whole bunch...it would make a lot of sense for miami to pursue him and unfortunately it would make a lot of sense for cribbs to be interested..

    Man we cant afford to lose him...

    Thanks peen!

    I really don't know if I could keep rooting for this team if they traded cribbs... Its already getting hard to even care.

    AdaM said:

    I really don't know if I could keep rooting for this team if they traded cribbs... Its already getting hard to even care.

    Then hurry up and jump on the Steeler bandwagon. Its about full so you better hurry douche.

  • Josh Cribbs is a kick and punt returner. As you guys have seen he is nothing other than that.

    I love Josh Cribbs but he signed a deal and took bonus money up front and now wants a new deal. If he likes it or not we don't have to pay him shit. He can hold out all he wants and lose out on money (I think they get fined every day that they hold out) and come back on opening day and return kicks.

  • Isn't running the WildDawg offense too much like playing in a dome stadium? I couldn't imagine it on the shores of Lake Erie or even anywhere near the AFC North division.

  • Cribbs' value to this team goes beyond returning punts/kicks. He's a force on coverage units. He has a 31 yard run from scrimmage. He's a hedge should we look to include WildDawg packages. Finally, and maybe most valuable, is he's a consummate professional. I think that last point is highly valued by EM.

    I've told the stories before, but here's two on Cribbs that make me a fan for life:

    - Cribbs was the marquee player to come to the autograph tent at training camp 2 years ago when I had my kids with me. At the time they were 4, 6, and 8. Josh greeted each kid personally with a "Hey little man" or "Hi sweetie" (sons and daughter). Looked them in the eye, and signed their minature footballs. Cribbs just oozed "real".

    - Mike and Mike had Speilman on their show after the Brandon Marshall drama broke. Speilman had been vocal about how offended he was by Marshall's antics. On Mike and Mike he said somthing to the effect of (paraphrased): "There's a way to go about maximizing your contract and Marshall is not doing it. Look at a guy like Joshua Cribbs in Cleveland. Here's a guy who is clearly underpaid and yet he goes to work every day, plays hard, is an example for his teammates and negotiates in private with the ball club."

    Cribbs is a keeper.

Log in to reply