Brett Favre or Donovan McNabb
-
why would mangini go down the favre road again? i'd rather contract aids than have favre as our qb.
-
Guys I was just taking note of what they were saying on Sirius NFL Radio. Do what you will with it.
Personally id rather have McNabb than Favre. More in the tank.
-
Step away from the crack pipe sound. It's beginning to have a serious effect on your brain functioning.
-
Step away from the crack pipe sound. It's beginning to have a serious effect on your brain functioning.
-
I'd take McNabb, but wouldn't mind Favre either, however I think after the Vikings get deep into the playoffs, he'll resign with them. McNabb will probably resign as well.
-
why would mangini go down the favre road again? i'd rather contract aids than have favre as our qb.
why would mangini go down the favre road again? i'd rather contract aids than have favre as our qb.
LOL, I'm sure that would be Mangini's opinion, also. Bum shoulder Bret cost EM his job in NY, and sure as the sun comes up in the East, EM ain't walking down that road twice. Doubly, because of Bret's "I'll show up for training camp when I'm damn good and well ready to" attitude. Triply, because the primary reason Farve came back this year is he saw a legit shot to win another SB.
McNabb is a more interesting option, but I still would doubt that's gonna happen. EM is building with youth, and Donovan doesn't fit the profile. Plus, he'd cost a ton of money, uncapped year or no. If the FO is trying to lowball Cribbs, you think they'd be ready to spring for McNabbs huge salary?
-
It all depends on who Holmgren and Mangini and the new GM decide who the QB of this team should be. If it's Quinn or Anderson, I don't see a vet like that being brought in here. If the FO decides that we don't have a QB on this team at this point, I could see a veteran like McNabb or Favre or Bulger or Hasselback being brought in as a 1 or 2 year guy to hold the job until the QB that we draft this year (I don't mind McCoy if it's in the 2nd round or later, not in the first round though) is ready to play.
I just don't see them bringing a guy who's been a starter his whole career in here when we have two guys who want to be the starter. It all depends on Holmgrens opinion on Anderson and Quinn.
-
It makes logical sense since Favre has ties to both men but his deal is for two years in Minnesota. Even if he was available, I'm not certain that he'd want to come to a team that wasn't a contender at this point.
I have no fact basis for this opinion but I always felt like Mike Holmgren was sort of glad to be done with Brett when he went to Seattle. Life with Brett was a constant struggle to get him to stop freelancing and play smart. I don't know...perhaps that's simply my perception.
McNabb has more in the tank, I think and Heckert would know as well as anyone. Both Mangini and Holmgren are close to Andy Reid so I suspect that they'd have a decent idea of what Donovan's got. I don't believe that the fans in Philly have ever been really fair to McNabb. He's taken them deep into the playoffs several times and one Super Bowl. I think that he certainly isn't the QB that has you wondering if he can "play at this level" (see Anderson or Quinn).
-
I simply do not see FAvre moving out of Minnesota ! THey want him there, with FAvre the team is dangerous and the fans love that, the owner is not going to spoil their honeymoon !
McNabb is Eagles all throughout ! Kevin Kolb may be good, but is he that good ? There is no proof yet, and he may be Matt Casselesqe but would u want to replace Tom Brady (McNabb) with Mat Cassel (K Kolb) ?
-
McNabb...PLEASE NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!
-
why would mangini go down the favre road again? i'd rather contract aids than have favre as our qb.
why would mangini go down the favre road again? i'd rather contract aids than have favre as our qb.
nicely said... i like him and everything but c'mon retire for good already
-
After seeing tonights game, id much rather have Quinn start than McNabb.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login