Who is the most overrated player in the NFL?

miktoxic

donovan mcnabb. ultimate choker.

The Gipper

Some possibles:

Reggie Bush

Elvis Dumervil

Jeff Feagles

mopaji

This is gonna sound terrible but........

Jerome Harrison or Tony Romo

BUNSofSTEEL08

@erie-dawg said:
Heinz Ward
Then that guy that Rapes chicks.

yet 4 Super Bowl Rings between the two of them... LOL, Yes you have a Clue !!! Not !

sisky fringo

@browns57 said:
Tomlinson.

kosar_win

Brady Quinn and Jay Cutler - both have been hyped but neither has produced much yet. And still the ad naseum reports about how they will improve a team.

Most hyped in the draft: Jimmy Clausen and Sam Bradford - I wouldn't pick either in the top ten. Too much money. Too much risk.

Canton Mike

In my opinion, it's Cutler.

Mike

Vagitron

@dawgsresurrected64 said:
Vince Young
Carson Palmer

Hines Ward

Jay Cutler

Terrel Owens

Hines Ward is overrated? It's okay to hate the guy, but lets not be dumb. Elaborate on how he's overrated, I'd love to hear it from you and anyone else claiming he is....

ClevelandRocks

Everybody that plays for the cowboys

ClevelandFanForLife

He's not playing right now but I've always thought that Marvin Harrison was vey overrated. He was a possession receiver with decent speed and rarely made great catches. He also mighT be a murderer.

medicineman

FREAKofSTEEL08 said:
yet 4 Super Bowl Rings between the two of them... LOL, Yes you have a Clue !!! Not !

No we get it. If you keep winning you don't care what he does. Way to support your QB. You will change after he rapes another girl in 3 weeks.

Tim Couch Pulls Out

In the NFL- Cutler.

On this forum- Harrison.

ClevelandRocks

Good one. Too bad mopaji already beat you to it. You guys are almost trolls at this point

sisky fringo

thinking Harrison's overrated isn't being a troll, it's just being realistic. he's not the biggest but he should be on everyone's top 1,000 list. he just hasn't proven it for a season yet--it's a fair criticism.

Pumpkin Eater

Apparently Queen is because his band of gay, loyal followers insist he is going to be a good QB some day.

DawgsResurrected64

Rorbotron said:
Hines Ward is overrated? It's okay to hate the guy, but lets not be dumb. Elaborate on how he's overrated, I'd love to hear it from you and anyone else claiming he is....

Because many fans still consider him one of the best WR in the league, hands down. The guy was a great player for a long time but he's lost a step and no longer belongs with the elite. He plays his role with Pittsburgh well, can still pull in a hell of a catch once in a while, and is still a hell of a blocker, possibly still the best blocking receiver in the NFL, but an elite receiver overall? No more. I'm aware I could have put other players on my list, but maybe the fact that he still resorts to blindsiding rookies pushed me to toss him up there. Let's not be dumb and get upset over messageboard opinions.

ruban

Carson Palmer

Thomas5737

I know this won't be a popular choice, but I think it is Darrelle Revis. If he is the greatest corner to ever play the game, then he is just a little overhyped. I, however, believe he is not and won't be remembered as a top 10 CB when his career is done. The media exploded on him for some reason, and the fans soon followed. I am not saying he isn't good. From the handful of games I watched him play I just wouldn't say he played at an elite level, just good.

If he turns out to be Jesus, i'll admit he was worth the hype, otherwise I'll stick to believing what what I see more than what I hear.

-Thomas

The Gipper

@thomas5737 said:
I know this won't be a popular choice, but I think it is Darrelle Revis. If he is the greatest corner to ever play the game, then he is just a little overhyped. I, however, believe he is not and won't be remembered as a top 10 CB when his career is done. The media exploded on him for some reason, and the fans soon followed. I am not saying he isn't good. From the handful of games I watched him play I just wouldn't say he played at an elite level, just good.
If he turns out to be Jesus, i'll admit he was worth the hype, otherwise I'll stick to believing what what I see more than what I hear.

-Thomas

Uh, I think he is a very good corner, but because he plays in New York, naturally there is going to be an overhype factor. Could you imagine if someone like Antoine Winfield had played in NY? They would have already had him in the Hall of Fame

Tim Couch Pulls Out

@clevelandrocks said:
Good one. Too bad mopaji already beat you to it. You guys are almost trolls at this point

Ah, I see how this works. I don't agree with you about a runningback who's had 4 good games in 4 years, so that automatically makes me a troll. Completely disregard the fact that I contribute much more to this forum in terms of actual conversation; I'm simply a troll because I'm not proclaiming Harrison to be Jesus like everybody else.