Rolling Stone's 20 Greatest Songs of All Time

[rich4eagle]

Satisfaction................DONE

[hoorta]

@chicopee-john said:

FWIW, my opine:

Don't like: (But I do like a ton of Beatle's songs)

#3 Imagine

#8 Hey Jude

#20 Let It Be

Don't get it:

#6 Good Vibrations

#17 Purple Haze

VERY Weak:

#9 Smells Like Teen Spirit

#15 London Calling

IMHO the Beatles and Stones are over-represented. Looks like they picked a list of earthshaking songs that changed the course of music- well they missed a few. If you're going to pick one Hendrix song- Purple Haze is it- hell JH was so technically ahead of his time it took 15 years (Stevie Ray Vaughn) before anyone even dared to cover one of his songs- I really don't count Clapton doing "Little Wing' on Layla as a cover because it's so different. (BTW, Hendrix's live version of.......

&feature=related" rel="external nofollow">Johnny B.Good- YouTube ...... [[that made the list as the original from Chuck Berry]] shows how Chuck would have wanted to play guitar in his wet dreams). There's lots of Beach Boys songs I'd prefer over Good Vibrations. If you want to pick anthems- like Springsteen's "Born to Run", then where's Steppenwolf's "Born to be Wild"? Ditto, even though I personally can't stand him- um, where's Michael Jackson's "Thriller"? If you're going to give a nod to the Metal Crowd I'll vote for Metallica's "Enter Sandman". Glaring omissions in my book? No Pink Floyd, Eagles, or Fleetwood Mac. "Comfortably Numb", "Desperado", and "The Chain" could have easily rated. Oldies? "Unchained Melody" anyone?

The problem is 40's just way too small a number from the tens (or hundreds) of thousands of songs that have come out over the last 60 years. And a lot of it has to do with personal taste. Fer instance, I'm not overly fond of Bob Marley, The Clash, U2, or Linkin Park- to each their own.

[calfoxwc]

Only a minority of those songs can touch the current "Chicken Fried" or "Mud on the Tires"

GGG

[Pumpkin Eater]

Gimme Shelter should have at least been in the teens instead of #38.

Light My Fire should not be in there.

Yesterday should probably be in the top 5.

I would probably switch the positions of Yesterday and Like a Rolling Stone.

I'd probably add a few more Bob Marley songs, yes Steppenwolf's two big ones, also Sweet Child O' Mine by GNR, Desperado and Take it Easy by the Eagles.

[ballpeen]

@mr.-t said:

I agree with you Kosar, Cash should of been in the top. The man has recorded more songs than any other artist.

I agree.

[ClevelandFanForLife]

the rolling stones are THE MOST overrated band of all time. they are incredibly average in every way and their lyrics are lame and repetitive. satisfaction is the same guitar lick over and over with mediocre lyrics at best. in short: they blow.

[ballpeen]

I think this is a top 20 song.

[Kosar_For_President]

Growing up in England. This is my favorite song of all time (mind you 1992). If you think this song suck listen to the second link. Just give it a chance I love the shit you guys love. Don't take the piss. Just listen.

Mind John Squire is the best guitarist since Hendrix.

Or one of my favs. Just listen to the guitar. If anyone for me, listen to this song all the way though.

[The Gipper]

@chicopee-john said:

Always a matter of taste and opinion, but here it is.

Let the debates begin

http://www.courant.com/entertainment/sns-r...07.photogallery

I'm sorry, I thought this thread was about the 40 Greatest Rolling Stones songs of all time, not Rolling Stones 40 greatest hits of all time.

Now lets seem them come up with the 40 best by Mick and the boys.

[The Gipper]

@kosar_for_president said:

I disagree, but that is why we are here. The #6 ranking for the Beach Boys is a perfect spot. I think with this being subjective, Rolling Stone had to appease the Rock and Roll community.

I agree with the Elvis and Berry opinion. To be honest I think Elvis was over rated. Mr Cash should of been on the list for sure, switching out one of Berry's songs. I could think of 50 songs that I like better, but for what it's worth they did a great job. And this is coming from someone who lost any respect I had for Rolling Stone when they started putting Britney Spears on the cover.

Well, Rolling Stone Magazine always has been about Pop Music. So why shouldn't the Pop Tart be on its cover sometime?

[Pumpkin Eater]

yeah well they named Miley Cyrus' Party in the USA one of the best songs of the last decade or something.. tell me what credibility they have left?

[CLEVELandMILIDH]

@kosar_for_president said:

Growing up in England. This is my favorite song of all time (mind you 1992). If you think this song suck listen to the second link. Just give it a chance I love the shit you guys love. Don't take the piss. Just listen.

Mind John Squire is the best guitarist since Hendrix.

Or one of my favs. Just listen to the guitar. If anyone for me, listen to this song all the way though.

that first song sounds a little like hell yea just not as heavy

[Kosar_For_President]

@the-gipper said:

Well, Rolling Stone Magazine always has been about Pop Music. So why shouldn't the Pop Tart be on its cover sometime?

I think the definition of pop has changed over time there boss.

[Kosar_For_President]

nmills said:

that first song sounds a little like hell yea just not as heavy

No way. Complete different rhythm, timing and chord structure. At least for sure in the verse.

[The Gipper]

@kosar_for_president said:

I think the definition of pop has changed over time there boss.

Maybe, or maybe it is just your personal perception of what pop/rock is that has changed. The best Rock n' Roll Band at all times was the quintessential Pop act. (yes, I mean The Beatles).

[The Gipper]

@kosar_for_president said:

No way. Complete different rhythm, timing and chord structure. At least for sure in the verse.

Its a good rock song. Don't know that you have to categorize it, "sounds like Hendrix, sounds like X, sounds like Y, sounds like Z". It is what it is.

[CLEVELandMILIDH]

@kosar_for_president said:

No way. Complete different rhythm, timing and chord structure. At least for sure in the verse.

Im talking about the voice and the way they sing, not instrumentals. Listen to the beginning of both songs, sounds very similar.