Trade Rumors: Shaun Rogers Could Be Traded By Oct. 19 Deadline

Donald Dawg

I'd take Lee Evans for Rodgers.

I don't believe it's giving up a lot for a solid weapon for Colt (if he's left in). Add in AJ Green/Julio Jones and we have a much better receiving corp.

Maybe Buffolo could throw in a late pick, or a DB.

7moses7

Rogers for a draft pick,at least a 3rd. rounder.

cribbs is the man

@7moses7 said:
Rogers for a draft pick,at least a 3rd. rounder.

I think a 3rd rounder is wishful thinking. I might trade him for a 4th, i think thats the best we're gonna get for him, but considering our lack of depth at D-line im not sure it would be worth it... how much longer is his contract?

ballpeen

@rich4eagle said:
I find it funny justifying we got a good deal for Quinn......we gave up a first and second for him..............AND I HATED IT AND GOT CRUCIFIED FOR HATING IT................and now we got a two year journeyman and this years wonder for a first and second round pick..................Think folks think
Hillis is a temporary solution..........at best...........we gave a one and two pick for him

I understand what you are thinking, but you can't hold it to that standard Rich.

Each trade is in and of itself.

Once Quinn arrived, the picks were gone. Done deal.

We got Hillis and a pick for Quinn....good deal any way you cut it.....and I think Hillis is more than a 1-2 year fill in.

medicineman

Ill take Eavens for him. Hell the way rogers been playing I would take Braylon back Well maybe not but ahh xxxx it just win

ATENEARS

The Plain Dealer is reporting that: "Any possible trade for Shaun Rogers seems to be off after an injury to Robaire Smith."

The Gipper

@atenears said:
The Plain Dealer is reporting that: "Any possible trade for Shaun Rogers seems to be off after an injury to Robaire Smith."

I would think so. Our D-line is thin enough.

Mr. T

We need fatboy to get healthy fast and start playing like he did last season.

Earl34

Message to Big Baby from a Texas alum:

Hawgdawg

@4browns said:
Good point on Hillis, but I don't think anybody expected him to be this good, but it's not like we traded Quinn for a proven commodity. DA was made available for trade after he had no real value.
Was it ever confirmed that we tried to trade Harrison during the last off season? We have to trade Rogers by tomorrow or he remains a Brown the rest of the season.

I think Mangini had some idea about the worth of Hillis. When Mangini was coaching the Jets (2008), his team was third in rushing defense and no one had rushed for 100 yards against them. Denver came to town with Hillis as their starting rb and he went for more than 120 yards against NYJ -- most of it between the tackles. Mangini has said that he rememberred Hillis from that experience and when he was made available in the trade, Mangini wanted him. Since McDaniels (Denver HC) was letting Hillis sit, he was more than happy to let Hillis go in the trade.

rich4eagle

So as I surmised for two years running.............Shaun Rogers was worth a third two years ago and fifth one year ago..........and NOW NOTHING

cut the bum..............move on