Skip to content
The Browns Board
  1. Home
  2. The Browns Board
  3. Cleveland Browns increasingly sure they've found their star QB in Colt McCoy

Cleveland Browns increasingly sure they've found their star QB in Colt McCoy

The Browns Board
20 14 3.2k

  • The ultimate exception: Aaron Rodgers. Not many starts or wins, graduated at only 20 and skinny... and is a known flake who recently dressed in Civil War garb for a team flight.

    But that dude can just flat out throw and he got a 38 on the Wonderlic. Fastest release in the history of pro football, legit 4.6 wheels.

  • Great post Earl34. The fact the veterans respect him says a lot. How can you not be impressed by that last post game interview? Is just me or did he mature like 5 years? Remember the "Golly Geewhiz" interviews? I saw a man put squarely on his shoulders, the loss of the game. In his opening statement you could see the disappointment on his face and in his voice. "We play to win". That's the guy I want running our locker room, coach.

    ❤

  • Ok, folks, it's question time.

    We all know that much ado was made about the size -- particularly the height -- of the quarterbacks in the last draft.

    Here's the question: How big is Michael Vick?

    Second question: How big is Colt McCoy?

    Answers:

    Vick is 6'0" 207 pounds (I have to admit, I thought he was much larger than this)

    Colt is 6'1" 216 pounds (I can't believe McCoy is actually larger than Vick)

    Nobody mentioned Vick when they were looking for quality qb's who were "exceptions to the height rule."

    NOTE: I am not comparing quarterbacking styles, abilities, or any other aspects of playing the position of quarterback.

  • Drew Brees is 6', 209.

    Brian Sipe played at 6'1", 195.

    Seneca Wallace is 5' 11"....

    no problem. Wired is wired.

  • Zombo said:

    When I think of an NFL model for Colt McCoy, I go back ... way back ... to Bob Griese.

    Griese was mobile, accurate, poised, patient and clutch. Didn't have a big arm but knew how to play off the running game, find the open receiver, utilize tight ends, play-action fake etc.

    Griese was 6'1, 190 lbs. and resides in the Hall of Fame with his two rings and three SB appearances.

    Zombo

    Let's add a few more to the "shorty" resume....

    Joe Montana 6' 2" (and no one ever accused Super Joe of having a rocket launcher arm)

    Bret Favre 6' 2"

    Like an extra inch in height is going to make that much difference.

    E 1 Reply

  • Never had a problem with Colt's height, even when I wasn't digging his chili as a prospect. It was all about his arm for me... and I'm more than cool with that now.

  • Well at least for the season he might be sitting again. I'm not reading to much into this, but the guy who does the AFC North huddle on ESPN is saying it is more likely that Mangini will go with Wallace at QB. Their saying he will go with someone who has experience over the rookie because Mangini is coaching to save his job.

    http://espn.go.com/blog/afcnorth/post/_/id...fc-north-huddle

    I personally think that if Mangini goes this route he will burn what bridges he has built this year with players and fans and his head will be on the chopping block. The only way for him to keep his job is to keep in Colt.

    Ruining threads since 1897.
  • Harry BuffaloH Harry Buffalo

    Well at least for the season he might be sitting again. I'm not reading to much into this, but the guy who does the AFC North huddle on ESPN is saying it is more likely that Mangini will go with Wallace at QB. Their saying he will go with someone who has experience over the rookie because Mangini is coaching to save his job.

    http://espn.go.com/blog/afcnorth/post/_/id...fc-north-huddle

    I personally think that if Mangini goes this route he will burn what bridges he has built this year with players and fans and his head will be on the chopping block. The only way for him to keep his job is to keep in Colt.

    Hillis-iz-Boss said:

    Well at least for the season he might be sitting again. I'm not reading to much into this, but the guy who does the AFC North huddle on ESPN is saying it is more likely that Mangini will go with Wallace at QB. Their saying he will go with someone who has experience over the rookie because Mangini is coaching to save his job.

    http://espn.go.com/blog/afcnorth/post/_/id...fc-north-huddle

    I personally think that if Mangini goes this route he will burn what bridges he has built this year with players and fans and his head will be on the chopping block. The only way for him to keep his job is to keep in Colt.

    That would be beyond insane. McCoy's QBR is now over 85, amazing for a rookie who just faced murderer's row and lived to tell. What in Wallace's career as a backup suggests we have a better chance to win with him?

    I don't buy it. If it smells fishy, it probably is. I really do think Mangini would be stamping his ticket straight out of town.

    hoortaH 1 Reply

  • I have liked mccoy and expected him to go in the top 10-20 i was elated that holmgren made the no brainer call and yet stunned that mccoy fell to the 3rd rd merely because of height and questionable arm strength..

    In my mind Colt "The Cowboy" McCoy is beyond the real deal and likely our franchise QB sometime in the future...

    The kid brings it on against the best of the best and i cant wait for sunday!

    We have been rebuilding since 1964, Why stop now? GO BROWNS!
    ❤
  • GipsG Gips

    I have liked mccoy and expected him to go in the top 10-20 i was elated that holmgren made the no brainer call and yet stunned that mccoy fell to the 3rd rd merely because of height and questionable arm strength..

    In my mind Colt "The Cowboy" McCoy is beyond the real deal and likely our franchise QB sometime in the future...

    The kid brings it on against the best of the best and i cant wait for sunday!

    @gips said:

    I have liked mccoy and expected him to go in the top 10-20 i was elated that holmgren made the no brainer call and yet stunned that mccoy fell to the 3rd rd merely because of height and questionable arm strength..

    In my mind Colt "The Cowboy" McCoy is beyond the real deal and likely our franchise QB sometime in the future...

    The kid brings it on against the best of the best and i cant wait for sunday!

    I actually preferred McCoy over ANY of the other QBs in the draft. Too often in college ball the QBs are blessed with WRs so good that they just play "catch" with them. One of my criteria has been a QB who can hit receivers in stride. Colt is just a total package & HANG the height. But NO....WAIT...Height IS important! What would DA do were he just 6'1"???

    Obviously the kid is the real deal & the kind of person any young child would do well to emulate.

    Mike

    IN DORSEY I TRUST
    ❤
  • hoortaH hoorta

    Zombo said:

    When I think of an NFL model for Colt McCoy, I go back ... way back ... to Bob Griese.

    Griese was mobile, accurate, poised, patient and clutch. Didn't have a big arm but knew how to play off the running game, find the open receiver, utilize tight ends, play-action fake etc.

    Griese was 6'1, 190 lbs. and resides in the Hall of Fame with his two rings and three SB appearances.

    Zombo

    Let's add a few more to the "shorty" resume....

    Joe Montana 6' 2" (and no one ever accused Super Joe of having a rocket launcher arm)

    Bret Favre 6' 2"

    Like an extra inch in height is going to make that much difference.

    @hoorta said:

    Let's add a few more to the "shorty" resume....

    Joe Montana 6' 2" (and no one ever accused Super Joe of having a rocket launcher arm)

    Bret Favre 6' 2"

    Like an extra inch in height is going to make that much difference.

    I've stood shoulder-to-shoulder with Brett Favre and he's not 6'2". I'd say 6'1" max.

  • E Earl34

    @hoorta said:

    Let's add a few more to the "shorty" resume....

    Joe Montana 6' 2" (and no one ever accused Super Joe of having a rocket launcher arm)

    Bret Favre 6' 2"

    Like an extra inch in height is going to make that much difference.

    I've stood shoulder-to-shoulder with Brett Favre and he's not 6'2". I'd say 6'1" max.

    @earl34 said:

    I've stood shoulder-to-shoulder with Brett Favre and he's not 6'2". I'd say 6'1" max.

    This made me laugh. For all the wrong reasons.

  • S shepwrite

    Hillis-iz-Boss said:

    Well at least for the season he might be sitting again. I'm not reading to much into this, but the guy who does the AFC North huddle on ESPN is saying it is more likely that Mangini will go with Wallace at QB. Their saying he will go with someone who has experience over the rookie because Mangini is coaching to save his job.

    http://espn.go.com/blog/afcnorth/post/_/id...fc-north-huddle

    I personally think that if Mangini goes this route he will burn what bridges he has built this year with players and fans and his head will be on the chopping block. The only way for him to keep his job is to keep in Colt.

    That would be beyond insane. McCoy's QBR is now over 85, amazing for a rookie who just faced murderer's row and lived to tell. What in Wallace's career as a backup suggests we have a better chance to win with him?

    I don't buy it. If it smells fishy, it probably is. I really do think Mangini would be stamping his ticket straight out of town.

    @shepwrite said:

    That would be beyond insane. McCoy's QBR is now over 85, amazing for a rookie who just faced murderer's row and lived to tell. What in Wallace's career as a backup suggests we have a better chance to win with him?

    I don't buy it. If it smells fishy, it probably is. I really do think Mangini would be stamping his ticket straight out of town.

    Not just rookie Shep- first four games as a rookie. I can honestly say I don't believe what I'm seeing out of Colt so far. Better than Kosar's rookie year? Yup. If Stukey steps out of bounds instead of fumbling- and Dawson kicks the game winner- the kid would already be a legend in C-town after his first four games.

    IMHO that's just some ESPN talking head stirring the pot.

    You can bet the ranch whatever Mangini does with Colt, he's talked it over with Big Mike, and has his full blessing to proceed. At this point- barring a miraculous running the table, the Browns aren't making the playoffs- so you may as well see what you have in Colt- we already know what we have in Wallace. And unless McCoy AND Wallace are both hurt, that's the last we've seen of Jake.

    And some interesting stats about the Jags defense. 27th overall, 27th in points allowed, and 29 in passing yards. NO reason not to play Colt on Sunday.

    ❤
Log in to reply