Skip to content

What We Should Have Drafted In The First Round Since 05

The Browns Board
18 14 1.2k
  • Yeah but if you had a cyrstal ball you would be able to stack your team..

    That said, we have the worst drafting of all time. Im pretty sure i could draft better drunk

  • Ummmm.... what was the name of the guy who limped off this site bleeding from the rectum after being anally raped here for pimping, pimping and pimping Aaron Rodgers every which way but loose in 2005?

    Oh yeah Shep?????

    I miss hearing that guy's opinions on this board.

  • Yeah he was dead on....

  • He also pimped Leinart. And Alex Smith.

    Edit: Hope you don't mind Cal- add Joey Harrington, Shep was still pimping him after it was proven by every knowledgeable Lions fan who knew for a couple seasons the guy sucked swampwater. And he was all over Brady Quinn too. If you pimp every first round potential qb every year, eventually you get one right. Hoorta.

    Usually, every first round top rated college qb was Shep's pimping focus.

    Big freakin stupid deal.

    No qb can be successul behind this oline with injuries and failure to draft a few of them.

  • that was the only pick of note that shep actually got right. you should have seen what he thought of haden.

  • I would go out on a limb and say all 4 of those guys wouldn't of shined here in Cleveland.

  • nightmare of a season? Really? Did I miss something, were the Browns forced to forfeit their wins? A nightmare season would be 0-5. 2-3 is pretty much where a team with the talent of the Browns should be. Maybe even 1-4.

    Give me a break.

  • that was the only pick of note that shep actually got right. you should have seen what he thought of haden.

    @choco said:

    that was the only pick of note that shep actually got right. you should have seen what he thought of haden.

    I'll agree with you here. He actually came back on here to post some crap about Haden underperforming in his training camp. Kind of a told-you-so. But he hasn't been back since.

  • I know there is alot that goes in to a draft each year, but if the Browns just took the Best player Avl at the time this is what we would have

    2005

    we took Braylon Edwards

    What we should have taken Aaron Rodgers!!!!!

    in the Second we took Brodney Pool, should have taken Vincent Jackson

    2006

    We took Kameron Wimbley, if we do not switch pics with the Ravens, we keep a draft pic and should have taken Haloti Ngata

    2007

    Took Joe Thomas, really do not mind the pi now, but at the time I was pissed beyond belief, because we should have taken AP..NO QUISTIONS ASKED BEST PLAYER IN DRAFT!!!!! since we traded back up in the first instead of taking Quinn(because we would have Rodgers if we drafted right) we take Dawyne Bowe

    no pic 2008

    2009

    Alex Mack like the pick, but could have taken Clay Matthews

    If we take Clay Matthew, we then had three 2nd round picks we could have got all out o-line in that round. There was some pro-bowl lineman in the second..instead Momass, Robo, and Venklukeuihe..

    2010

    Joe Haden, I think we nailed this. He was they best player Avl!!!!

    2011

    Tradeing down to to take Phil Taylor, have no problem with because we would have already had playmakers everywhere....

    So this is a team that I think we all could have fell in love with

    QB-Aaron Rodgers

    WR-Jackson

    WR-Bowe

    RB-AP

    Cribbs for whatever u needed

    CB-Haden

    DL-Ngata

    DL-Talyor

    LB-Matthews

    LB-Jackson

    LB-Maualuga

    I Love dreaming, it keeps me sain thru this nightmare season

    S-Ward

    @tampadawgs said:

    I know there is alot that goes in to a draft each year, but if the Browns just took the Best player Avl at the time this is what we would have

    2005

    we took Braylon Edwards

    What we should have taken Aaron Rodgers!!!!!

    in the Second we took Brodney Pool, should have taken Vincent Jackson

    2006

    We took Kameron Wimbley, if we do not switch pics with the Ravens, we keep a draft pic and should have taken Haloti Ngata

    2007

    Took Joe Thomas, really do not mind the pi now, but at the time I was pissed beyond belief, because we should have taken AP..NO QUISTIONS ASKED BEST PLAYER IN DRAFT!!!!! since we traded back up in the first instead of taking Quinn(because we would have Rodgers if we drafted right) we take Dawyne Bowe

    no pic 2008

    2009

    Alex Mack like the pick, but could have taken Clay Matthews

    If we take Clay Matthew, we then had three 2nd round picks we could have got all out o-line in that round. There was some pro-bowl lineman in the second..instead Momass, Robo, and Venklukeuihe..

    2010

    Joe Haden, I think we nailed this. He was they best player Avl!!!!

    2011

    Tradeing down to to take Phil Taylor, have no problem with because we would have already had playmakers everywhere....

    So this is a team that I think we all could have fell in love with

    QB-Aaron Rodgers

    WR-Jackson

    WR-Bowe

    RB-AP

    Cribbs for whatever u needed

    CB-Haden

    DL-Ngata

    DL-Talyor

    LB-Matthews

    LB-Jackson

    LB-Maualuga

    I Love dreaming, it keeps me sain thru this nightmare season

    S-Ward

    Hindsight is 20/20!

  • Don't forget that the pickle was a can't miss pick either. What's more amusing that now in year 7...after 6 horrible seasons....shepherd is virndicated as being right about Smith. Its quite amusing watching him spin his "logic"

  • Don't forget that the pickle was a can't miss pick either. What's more amusing that now in year 7...after 6 horrible seasons....shepherd is virndicated as being right about Smith. Its quite amusing watching him spin his "logic"

    @choco said:

    Don't forget that the pickle was a can't miss pick either. What's more amusing that now in year 7...after 6 horrible seasons....shepherd is virndicated as being right about Smith. Its quite amusing watching him spin his "logic"

    "The Pickle"? I guess I don't know who that is.

  • You missed one thing- Take a look at what the Browns could have had with the first round pick they gave to Dallas in 2008 to get Quinn. It will make you ill. Rashard Mendenhall or Chris Johnson. Peterson isn't that much better than those two.

    @hoorta said:

    You missed one thing- Take a look at what the Browns could have had with the first round pick they gave to Dallas in 2008 to get Quinn. It will make you ill. Rashard Mendenhall or Chris Johnson. Peterson isn't that much better than those two.

    I cannot believe you just said AP is not that much better than mendenhall LMFAO! seriously??

  • @choco said:

    Don't forget that the pickle was a can't miss pick either. What's more amusing that now in year 7...after 6 horrible seasons....shepherd is virndicated as being right about Smith. Its quite amusing watching him spin his "logic"

    "The Pickle"? I guess I don't know who that is.

    @the-gipper said:

    "The Pickle"? I guess I don't know who that is.

    My guess is jimmy claussen, only thing I could think of