Niners Have Big Decision To Make On Alex Smith

miktoxic

@xanthros said:

I for one hope that we bring in a coach that knows how to use what he has rather then forcing his system down everyones throat ala PS style.

your feelings and reasoning are displaced. the blame sets squarely on mike holmgren period.

he hired a guy that would run HIS system.

thank god that fat fuck is 'officially' gone. what a waste of time that piece of shit was.

any tean that goes near him as a rebuild guy beware.

Nw220

Ill take Alex Smith over Weeden and McCoy, if we put a good team around him i think he can excel in the right system...I just dont ever see McCoy or Weeden being able to win us playoff games....If you have some doubt on Smith i suggest you go back and watch the playoff game between the Saints and 49ers last year, that was one of the best playoff games ive seen a QB play...He was phenomenal

Tim Couch Pulls Out

So let's bring in a 28 year old because our 29 year old is too old.

Zombo

Weeden has started 11 games as a rookie. After an 0-5 start, we are 3-3 in the last six.

His last ten games (we all agree his first was abysmal) he has a 78.0 rating and averages 233 yards per game, a pace of 3,728. His running back, #1 receiver and right tackle are rookies.

Alex Smith didn't achieve a 78 rating until his fourth season as a starter. He has thrown for 3,000 yards once ... 3,144 last year.

Are we really going to blow this up for someone else's leftovers?

No, we're not.

The BEST thing about this season is the seasoning that our talented first and second year players are getting.

We don't need Alex Smith. He'll be good on a good team and bad on a bad team. We need PROGRESS.

Zombo

Pumpkin Eater

Alex Smith is a homo. Didn't anyone else see him smiling after losing the NFC championship game last year? He should have been pissed and came out swinging this season wanting to get to that SB.

D Bone

@pumpkin-eater said:

Alex Smith is a homo. Didn't anyone else see him smiling after losing the NFC championship game last year? He should have been pissed and came out swinging this season wanting to get to that SB.

He's 5th in the NFL with a 104.1 QB rating, he did come out swinging. It's too bad he has a whinny, douchebag for a head coach.

Pumpkin Eater

OK, I didn't know that. I'm not really sure why he got benched then. I just figured it was because he was sucking.

Mark O

@d-bone said:

He's 5th in the NFL with a 104.1 QB rating, he did come out swinging. It's too bad he has a whinny, douchebag for a head coach.

I'd take his head coach every day of the week and twice on Sundays.

All the guy does is win games no matter where he's coached.

Horn of Lake Erie

The Browns have a tendency to grab QBs on the downhill slope of the Edgewater Park hill. Getting him would be a huge setback IMO.

runyon27

So people are ready to give up on a rookie QB after 11 games, and rush to Alex Smith who took years to be even a decent QB. Anyone see the hypocrisy in that? Might want to give Weeden a little more time than 11 games folks.

miktoxic

@mark-o said:

I'd take his head coach every day of the week and twice on Sundays.

oh hell yeah.

just wondering if there's another harbaugh brother out there? cuz i don't care if he's coaching pee wee and working at the car wash on the weekends. bring that mother forker in for an interview.

D Bone

@mark-o said:

I'd take his head coach every day of the week and twice on Sundays.All the guy does is win games no matter where he's coached.

Good coach yes, never said he wasn't. He's still a whinny douchebag on the sidelines.

tampadawgs

I heard that Charlie Batch we could get as well, come on man!!!!!