Inequality Video
-
Wait, who is the messenger? Al Sharpton did this? Or you found a link to it from MSNBC? Those are two different things. I didn't find a link to it from MSNBC. I saw it on Andrew Sullivan's site.
And comparing the highest paid musicians is a bit apples and oranges. But I guess I didn't think you'd care. I thought you'd at least say it's not all that healthy, and then move on to how we shouldn't do anything about it.
How about tax policy? Does it inform you at all about tax policy? When we're looking to find revenue, does this make you think any differently about where you might get it?
-
Sorry. Since there was no link the first time I did a Google search for inequality video and that's the 1 that came up, the one starring Al Sharpton.
Ok. I admit I was surprised you would post that.
So you have only one, correct?
And that is the 1 with the United States map and piles of money?
I did watch that 1 too.
Did you watch the 1 I linked ?
WSS
-
No, I didn't. I thought it was the same one.
-
But yes it does say something about tax policy albeit something we already knew.
And that is that the top bracket pays for nearly everything.
So let me ask you, how much equality is good, complete equality?
Do you support a graduated tax plan that would bring the numbers to what this video suggested people thought should be fair?
Should we have a cap on wealth, say 5,000,000 dollars?
Take the rest and divided equally to the 98 percent of us.
Why would that be bad? It would be much more fair.
WSS
-
No, I didn't. I thought it was the same one.
No, I didn't. I thought it was the same one.
No sorry, it was at Al Sharpton rant. Nevermind.
WSS
-
So no thoughts in growing levels of income inequality? Wealth disparities? Shrinking middle class? Not a concern at all?
-
You are correct.
I guess I consider myself middle class although I don't wear it as a badge of honor.
I did ask you if you wanted to redistribute everything to the tune of where Americans say they think it should be.
If that is indeed your position great!
I'd guess you'll find little support except for maybe the bleeding edge of the fringe left but...
Mostly I think preaching egalitarianism is a wedge designed to grab more power.
But if you choose to fight for that cause more power to you.
WSS
-
But yes it does say something about tax policy albeit something we already knew.
And that is that the top bracket pays for nearly everything.
So let me ask you, how much equality is good, complete equality?
Do you support a graduated tax plan that would bring the numbers to what this video suggested people thought should be fair?
Should we have a cap on wealth, say 5,000,000 dollars?
Take the rest and divided equally to the 98 percent of us.
Why would that be bad? It would be much more fair.
WSS
But yes it does say something about tax policy albeit something we already knew.
And that is that the top bracket pays for nearly everything.
So let me ask you, how much equality is good, complete equality?
Do you support a graduated tax plan that would bring the numbers to what this video suggested people thought should be fair?
Should we have a cap on wealth, say 5,000,000 dollars?
Take the rest and divided equally to the 98 percent of us.
Why would that be bad? It would be much more fair.
WSS
Sorry, I missed this post.
So let me ask you, how much equality is good, complete equality? Of course not, don't be ridiculous.
Do you support a graduated tax plan that would bring the numbers to what this video suggested people thought should be fair? Of course not. Don't be ridiculous.
Should we have a cap on wealth, say 5,000,000 dollars? Take the rest and divided equally to the 98 percent of us. Of course not, don't be ridiculous.
If this really is where you think the debate is, or what liberals or Democrats advocate for, I guess we should just move on.
-
You are correct.
I guess I consider myself middle class although I don't wear it as a badge of honor.
I did ask you if you wanted to redistribute everything to the tune of where Americans say they think it should be.
If that is indeed your position great!
I'd guess you'll find little support except for maybe the bleeding edge of the fringe left but...
Mostly I think preaching egalitarianism is a wedge designed to grab more power.
But if you choose to fight for that cause more power to you.
WSS
You are correct.
I guess I consider myself middle class although I don't wear it as a badge of honor.
I did ask you if you wanted to redistribute everything to the tune of where Americans say they think it should be.
If that is indeed your position great!
I'd guess you'll find little support except for maybe the bleeding edge of the fringe left but...
Mostly I think preaching egalitarianism is a wedge designed to grab more power.
But if you choose to fight for that cause more power to you.
WSS
Oh my God.
-
You are correct.
I guess I consider myself middle class although I don't wear it as a badge of honor.
I did ask you if you wanted to redistribute everything to the tune of where Americans say they think it should be.
If that is indeed your position great!
I'd guess you'll find little support except for maybe the bleeding edge of the fringe left but...
Mostly I think preaching egalitarianism is a wedge designed to grab more power.
But if you choose to fight for that cause more power to you.
WSS
Oh my God.
Oh my God.
Oh cripes Heck who cares?
I know I know there's nothing in the world you like more than the idea of raising taxes on somebody, anybody.
I don't know how much better you'd feel if the top 1 and a half percent had everything instead of the top 1 percent. You've already admitted you don't want people to be equal, not even close, not even close to close.
So I don't know why you are badgering me about it.
If resentment politics is that successful, stay with it, it worked this time.
Give me a number that would make you happy and the world a better place.
There's nobody I know who can't improve their lot in life just a little bit by trying a bit harder at whatever the hell it might be.
And if you buy into the fact that you have to be miserable because somebody else has more, I can't help you.
You won't make them successful or happy by pinching of the top 1, 5, 10, 20 percent of Americans but it must make you happy to think about it.
I'd be all for some sort of tax hike but nobody's going to hand out any real cuts, you know what, I know it.
I would, however, want those taxes to be spent to reduce the debt.
But that ain't happening either so it's hard for me to get all worked up.
I'm just not very bitter, and I don't really care, sorry.
WSS
-
You're hopeless.
-
So no thoughts in growing levels of income inequality? Wealth disparities? Shrinking middle class? Not a concern at all?
So no thoughts in growing levels of income inequality? Wealth disparities? Shrinking middle class? Not a concern at all?
Not sure what would change this short of a Bastille reunion.
-
Come on bud, give me a number.
How much makes it okay?
How much makes everybody happy?
You tell me.
WSS
-
That's not the conversation I want to have. That's not the conversation anyone over the age of 16 wants to have. It's not where the debate is. It's cartoonish and sophomoric.
I should stop trying to get blood from a stone.
-
So no thoughts in growing levels of income inequality? Wealth disparities? Shrinking middle class? Not a concern at all?
Not sure what would change this short of a Bastille reunion.
Not sure what would change this short of a Bastille reunion.
When people talk about the need for the Republican Party to have more ideas that "government bad" and "cut taxes" this is what they're talking about.
-
That's not the conversation I want to have. That's not the conversation anyone over the age of 16 wants to have. It's not where the debate is. It's cartoonish and sophomoric.
I should stop trying to get blood from a stone.
That's not the conversation I want to have. That's not the conversation anyone over the age of 16 wants to have. It's not where the debate is. It's cartoonish and sophomoric.
I should stop trying to get blood from a stone.
Actually you could try not being sophomoric and cartoonish. (Maybe not...)
And you could try out an idea other than government is God and the answer to every question is more tax money.
WSS
-
Oh, that was nice. Another "I know you are, but what am I?"
I really think you want to have these conversations with someone else. The person you describe is so far away from me that it just makes me laugh. You're not even talking to me, or about what I'm talking about. You can't get away from the cartoon of a bitter liberal who wants to take your money and give it to poor people, full stop. I don't say a word. I just raise a topic that has a 100 different ways to go, and you keep ...bringing ...it ...back. It's your sweet spot. It's all you can do.
Seriously, go back and read this thread from the beginning. It's me shaking my head while you go off on your own personal bogeyman.
I think he looks somewhat like this. And he died in 1983.
-
Not sure what would change this short of a Bastille reunion.
When people talk about the need for the Republican Party to have more ideas that "government bad" and "cut taxes" this is what they're talking about.
When people talk about the need for the Republican Party to have more ideas that "government bad" and "cut taxes" this is what they're talking about.
And this is exclusive to the Republican Party?
-
What?
The personal boogie man here is your vision of the evil Republican Party.
Frankly I'm not sure what it is you want to say here.
You seem upset with what you perceive as an unfair distribution of wealth.
I asked you for some numbers that might make the situation better.
And you got mad. Sorry.
But you did post some funny pictures. Congratulations.
Other then some vague Occupy Wall Street carping I guess I don't see your point.
A small section at the top have most of the nation's wealth and pay most of the nations bills. Shocking.
I'm assuming you think this situation is bad. I also guess you think it would be better if we would just take more of it away from them, am I wrong here?
Just so we are clear, I'd hate to miss something surprisingly different coming from you.
WSS
-
So no thoughts in growing levels of income inequality? Wealth disparities? Shrinking middle class? Not a concern at all?
Not sure what would change this short of a Bastille reunion.
Not sure what would change this short of a Bastille reunion.
And that would only change it for a matter of months before heck and the people's Revolutionary Party took over and kept all the wealth for themselves.
" Same as it ever was"
WSS
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login