Weaponry
-
QB- I remember your rankings and didn't agree. Overall team success played a larger role than individual stats in your rankings. I'd argue individual stats are more telling but that's a different discussion for a different day.
RB- One good year puts Lacy in the top 5? I could see substituting Gore but I'd argue Murray has more overall talent than Gore but then again they have different styles. Needless to say Murray is top 10, near top 5.
TE- Finley would be lucky to be top 10-15. He can't stay healthy and his production has constantly disappointed. Witten has consistently produced more than Davis (who based on talent should be putting up Graham or Gronk numbers) and while I'm a big Cameron fan, he's had a single year of production. I think we can agree that hopefully Cameron keeps it up.
WR- I'd take Dez over Marshall and potentially Gordon and Thomas. Trust me it pains me to say that with being a Browns and GT fan but I'm also a Poke fan. Either way my affiliations have some badass WR's. If only Blackmon could get his shit straight and Hill would finally live up to his potential.
-
Dammit Gipper your going to make me defend the Cowboys. I just threw up a little in my mouth.
All better, here we go:
Romo is well within that second tier of QB's behind the top 4. Let's say top 10 at worst.
When I ranked all the QBs in a recent thread, I definitely did not have Romo in the Top 10. I think he was lucky to make the Top half.
Murray is a top 10, if not top 5, back when healthy.
Definitely not Top 5: Lynch, AP, Forte, Lacy, mcCoy from Philly
Witten is still in a top 5 TE. Their backup, Hanna, had shown some flashes too.
Jimmy Graham, Vernon Davis, Cameron, Julius Thomas, Jermichael Finley.
Witten in a lesser group with say Heath Miller, Tyler Eifert
Dez is a top 5 WR. Williams was impressive last year and should only get more looks as the clear cut #2 this year.
He may make the Top 5 cut, maybe not. Calvin Johnson, AJ Green, Demarius Thomas, Gordon, Brandon Marshall may beat him out.....but he is arguable.
This lineup came a late Romo pick from beating the Broncos, in the midst of their offensive explosion to being the year, in a shootout last year.
Gipper please don't make me defend the Cowboys more. I'm already mad at you for making me do it to begin with.
Just accept my evaluation and you won't have to.
Dammit Gipper your going to make me defend the Cowboys. I just threw up a little in my mouth.
All better, here we go:
Romo is well within that second tier of QB's behind the top 4. Let's say top 10 at worst.
When I ranked all the QBs in a recent thread, I definitely did not have Romo in the Top 10. I think he was lucky to make the Top half.
Murray is a top 10, if not top 5, back when healthy.
Definitely not Top 5: Lynch, AP, Forte, Lacy, mcCoy from Philly
Witten is still in a top 5 TE. Their backup, Hanna, had shown some flashes too.
Jimmy Graham, Vernon Davis, Cameron, Julius Thomas, Jermichael Finley.
Witten in a lesser group with say Heath Miller, Tyler Eifert
Dez is a top 5 WR. Williams was impressive last year and should only get more looks as the clear cut #2 this year.
He may make the Top 5 cut, maybe not. Calvin Johnson, AJ Green, Demarius Thomas, Gordon, Brandon Marshall may beat him out.....but he is arguable.
This lineup came a late Romo pick from beating the Broncos, in the midst of their offensive explosion to being the year, in a shootout last year.
Gipper please don't make me defend the Cowboys more. I'm already mad at you for making me do it to begin with.
Just accept my evaluation and you won't have to.
Not sure how you left Jamaal Charles out of the top 5 RB list. Replace Lacy with Charles, and I think you got it right there.
With that said, Murray isn't nearly as good as any of those 5 guys. I'll give him top 10, though, as long as he stays healthy.
-
Dammit Gipper your going to make me defend the Cowboys. I just threw up a little in my mouth.
All better, here we go:
Romo is well within that second tier of QB's behind the top 4. Let's say top 10 at worst.
When I ranked all the QBs in a recent thread, I definitely did not have Romo in the Top 10. I think he was lucky to make the Top half.
Murray is a top 10, if not top 5, back when healthy.
Definitely not Top 5: Lynch, AP, Forte, Lacy, mcCoy from Philly
Witten is still in a top 5 TE. Their backup, Hanna, had shown some flashes too.
Jimmy Graham, Vernon Davis, Cameron, Julius Thomas, Jermichael Finley.
Witten in a lesser group with say Heath Miller, Tyler Eifert
Dez is a top 5 WR. Williams was impressive last year and should only get more looks as the clear cut #2 this year.
He may make the Top 5 cut, maybe not. Calvin Johnson, AJ Green, Demarius Thomas, Gordon, Brandon Marshall may beat him out.....but he is arguable.
This lineup came a late Romo pick from beating the Broncos, in the midst of their offensive explosion to being the year, in a shootout last year.
Gipper please don't make me defend the Cowboys more. I'm already mad at you for making me do it to begin with.
Just accept my evaluation and you won't have to.
Not sure how you left Jamaal Charles out of the top 5 RB list. Replace Lacy with Charles, and I think you got it right there.
With that said, Murray isn't nearly as good as any of those 5 guys. I'll give him top 10, though, as long as he stays healthy.
Not sure how you left Jamaal Charles out of the top 5 RB list. Replace Lacy with Charles, and I think you got it right there.
With that said, Murray isn't nearly as good as any of those 5 guys. I'll give him top 10, though, as long as he stays healthy.
I missed Charles too. Not sure how I pulled that off.
-
QB- I remember your rankings and didn't agree. Overall team success played a larger role than individual stats in your rankings. I'd argue individual stats are more telling but that's a different discussion for a different day.
RB- One good year puts Lacy in the top 5? I could see substituting Gore but I'd argue Murray has more overall talent than Gore but then again they have different styles. Needless to say Murray is top 10, near top 5.
TE- Finley would be lucky to be top 10-15. He can't stay healthy and his production has constantly disappointed. Witten has consistently produced more than Davis (who based on talent should be putting up Graham or Gronk numbers) and while I'm a big Cameron fan, he's had a single year of production. I think we can agree that hopefully Cameron keeps it up.
WR- I'd take Dez over Marshall and potentially Gordon and Thomas. Trust me it pains me to say that with being a Browns and GT fan but I'm also a Poke fan. Either way my affiliations have some badass WR's. If only Blackmon could get his shit straight and Hill would finally live up to his potential.
QB- I remember your rankings and didn't agree. Overall team success played a larger role than individual stats in your rankings. I'd argue individual stats are more telling but that's a different discussion for a different day.
I don't think that individual stats constitutes what most people feel goes into being the best QBs. Lists of the greatest of all time include the biggest winners of all time: Montana/Brady/Graham/Starr etc. With the rare exception of Marino I would say that the most highly thought of QBs of all time were the winners.
Romo has won what? One single playoff game his entire career. I mean, you are approaching like Jay Fiedler and Shaun King country there. Active QBs that have won more than him include the likes of Vick, Rex Grossman, Mark Sanchez, Matt Hassleback
RB- One good year puts Lacy in the top 5? I could see substituting Gore but I'd argue Murray has more overall talent than Gore but then again they have different styles. Needless to say Murray is top 10, near top 5.
a big maybe. arguable at best
TE- Finley would be lucky to be top 10-15. He can't stay healthy and his production has constantly disappointed. Witten has consistently produced more than Davis (who based on talent should be putting up Graham or Gronk numbers) and while I'm a big Cameron fan, he's had a single year of production. I think we can agree that hopefully Cameron keeps it up.
And I thin that a lot of your opinion about Witten is based on what he used to be, like Heath Miller. Can they both catch some passes? Sure. But then maybe so can Ben Watson....and that is where Witten can be considered to be.
WR- I'd take Dez over Marshall and potentially Gordon and Thomas. Trust me it pains me to say that with being a Browns and GT fan but I'm also a Poke fan. Either way my affiliations have some badass WR's. If only Blackmon could get his shit straight and Hill would finally live up to his potential.
Another big maybe.
Someone mentioned the 49ers....I believe they far exceed the Cowboys.
-
Dammit Gipper your going to make me defend the Cowboys. I just threw up a little in my mouth.
All better, here we go:
Romo is well within that second tier of QB's behind the top 4. Let's say top 10 at worst.
When I ranked all the QBs in a recent thread, I definitely did not have Romo in the Top 10. I think he was lucky to make the Top half.
Murray is a top 10, if not top 5, back when healthy.
Definitely not Top 5: Lynch, AP, Forte, Lacy, mcCoy from Philly
Witten is still in a top 5 TE. Their backup, Hanna, had shown some flashes too.
Jimmy Graham, Vernon Davis, Cameron, Julius Thomas, Jermichael Finley.
Witten in a lesser group with say Heath Miller, Tyler Eifert
Dez is a top 5 WR. Williams was impressive last year and should only get more looks as the clear cut #2 this year.
He may make the Top 5 cut, maybe not. Calvin Johnson, AJ Green, Demarius Thomas, Gordon, Brandon Marshall may beat him out.....but he is arguable.
This lineup came a late Romo pick from beating the Broncos, in the midst of their offensive explosion to being the year, in a shootout last year.
Gipper please don't make me defend the Cowboys more. I'm already mad at you for making me do it to begin with.
Just accept my evaluation and you won't have to.
Not sure how you left Jamaal Charles out of the top 5 RB list. Replace Lacy with Charles, and I think you got it right there.
With that said, Murray isn't nearly as good as any of those 5 guys. I'll give him top 10, though, as long as he stays healthy.
Not sure how you left Jamaal Charles out of the top 5 RB list. Replace Lacy with Charles, and I think you got it right there.
With that said, Murray isn't nearly as good as any of those 5 guys. I'll give him top 10, though, as long as he stays healthy.
OK, I agree about Charles. Just an oversight....going off the top of my head.
-
Kaep and Wilson may have won more in their much shorter careers than Romo but neither is asked to do nearly as much as Romo and are on much better overall teams. The Cowboys are bottom feeders without Romo. The 49ers are still a playoff team without Kaep, as they were with Smith. Seahawks are boarder line depending on who replaces Wilson. You put Kaep or Wilson on the Cowboys, they struggle for 8-8, less so with Wilson.
Those great QB's you named also put up impressive stats during their time.
You severely underrate Witten. Last year was one of his worst and he still put up top 5 numbers. To rank him any where other than top 5 is asinine at best.
-
Kaep and Wilson may have won more in their much shorter careers than Romo but neither is asked to do nearly as much as Romo and are on much better overall teams. The Cowboys are bottom feeders without Romo. The 49ers are still a playoff team without Kaep, as they were with Smith. Seahawks are boarder line depending on who replaces Wilson. You put Kaep or Wilson on the Cowboys, they struggle for 8-8, less so with Wilson.
Those great QB's you named also put up impressive stats during their time.
You severely underrate Witten. Last year was one of his worst and he still put up top 5 numbers. To rank him any where other than top 5 is asinine at best.
Kaep and Wilson may have won more in their much shorter careers than Romo but neither is asked to do nearly as much as Romo and are on much better overall teams. The Cowboys are bottom feeders without Romo. The 49ers are still a playoff team without Kaep, as they were with Smith. Seahawks are boarder line depending on who replaces Wilson. You put Kaep or Wilson on the Cowboys, they struggle for 8-8, less so with Wilson.
Those great QB's you named also put up impressive stats during their time.
You severely underrate Witten. Last year was one of his worst and he still put up top 5 numbers. To rank him any where other than top 5 is asinine at best.
Sorry, I will stick to my guns. Romo is middle of the road. There are at least a dozen QBs better if not more.
Witten, OK, top ten, I guess.
-
Kaep and Wilson may have won more in their much shorter careers than Romo but neither is asked to do nearly as much as Romo and are on much better overall teams. The Cowboys are bottom feeders without Romo. The 49ers are still a playoff team without Kaep, as they were with Smith. Seahawks are boarder line depending on who replaces Wilson. You put Kaep or Wilson on the Cowboys, they struggle for 8-8, less so with Wilson.
Those great QB's you named also put up impressive stats during their time.
You severely underrate Witten. Last year was one of his worst and he still put up top 5 numbers. To rank him any where other than top 5 is asinine at best.
Sorry, I will stick to my guns. Romo is middle of the road. There are at least a dozen QBs better if not more.
Witten, OK, top ten, I guess.
Sorry, I will stick to my guns. Romo is middle of the road. There are at least a dozen QBs better if not more.
Witten, OK, top ten, I guess.
I agree. Romo is done. And I get it if you switch QB blah blah blah. Romo has had squads where he should of been deep in the playoffs for years. Witten is also pretty much done. But I'll give him top 10.
-
Dammit Gipper your going to make me defend the Cowboys. I just threw up a little in my mouth.
All better, here we go:
Romo is well within that second tier of QB's behind the top 4. Let's say top 10 at worst.
Murray is a top 10, if not top 5, back when healthy.
Witten is still in a top 5 TE. Their backup, Hanna, had shown some flashes too.
Dez is a top 5 WR. Williams was impressive last year and should only get more looks as the clear cut #2 this year.
This lineup came a late Romo pick from beating the Broncos, in the midst of their offensive explosion to being the year, in a shootout last year.
Gipper please don't make me defend the Cowboys more. I'm already mad at you for making me do it to begin with.
I would have said a couple years ago Romo was top ten. Now I would say Manning Manning Rogers Brady Brees Ryan Luck Kap Newton and Rivers. Romo is pretty much doneDammit Gipper your going to make me defend the Cowboys. I just threw up a little in my mouth.
All better, here we go:
Romo is well within that second tier of QB's behind the top 4. Let's say top 10 at worst.
Murray is a top 10, if not top 5, back when healthy.
Witten is still in a top 5 TE. Their backup, Hanna, had shown some flashes too.
Dez is a top 5 WR. Williams was impressive last year and should only get more looks as the clear cut #2 this year.
This lineup came a late Romo pick from beating the Broncos, in the midst of their offensive explosion to being the year, in a shootout last year.
Gipper please don't make me defend the Cowboys more. I'm already mad at you for making me do it to begin with.
-
-
Anybody see the 'division' superbowl thing going around? Basically picking an all-division team and having a knockout competition based on voters.
http://nflspinzone.com/2014/07/25/nfl-division-super-bowl-afc-north-vs-nfc-north/
Not sure who picked the teams, but they ended up with:
QB Ben Roethlisberger RB Gio Bernard TE Jordan Cameron WR Josh Gordon WR A.J. Green WR Torrey Smith LT Joe Thomas LG Andrew Whitworth C Alex Mack RG Marshal Yanda RT
Andre Smith
DE Geno Atkins NT Haloti Ngata DE Cam Heyward LB Terrell Suggs LB Vontaze Burfict LB Lawrence Timmons LB Jason Worilds CB Joe Haden CB Jimmy Smith S Donte Whitner S Troy Polamalu
6 players out of 22, all pro-bowlers. It's bit obvious to pick those players. But I'd question Worilds over some of the other backers in the division (not specifically ours). Also cam heyward over rubin/bryant? Close one.
-
Anybody see the 'division' superbowl thing going around? Basically picking an all-division team and having a knockout competition based on voters.
http://nflspinzone.com/2014/07/25/nfl-division-super-bowl-afc-north-vs-nfc-north/
Not sure who picked the teams, but they ended up with:
QB Ben Roethlisberger RB Gio Bernard TE Jordan Cameron WR Josh Gordon WR A.J. Green WR Torrey Smith LT Joe Thomas LG Andrew Whitworth C Alex Mack RG Marshal Yanda RT
Andre Smith
DE Geno Atkins NT Haloti Ngata DE Cam Heyward LB Terrell Suggs LB Vontaze Burfict LB Lawrence Timmons LB Jason Worilds CB Joe Haden CB Jimmy Smith S Donte Whitner S Troy Polamalu
6 players out of 22, all pro-bowlers. It's bit obvious to pick those players. But I'd question Worilds over some of the other backers in the division (not specifically ours). Also cam heyward over rubin/bryant? Close one.
Anybody see the 'division' superbowl thing going around? Basically picking an all-division team and having a knockout competition based on voters.
http://nflspinzone.com/2014/07/25/nfl-division-super-bowl-afc-north-vs-nfc-north/
Not sure who picked the teams, but they ended up with:
QB Ben Roethlisberger RB Gio Bernard TE Jordan Cameron WR Josh Gordon WR A.J. Green WR Torrey Smith LT Joe Thomas LG Andrew Whitworth C Alex Mack RG Marshal Yanda RTAndre Smith
DE Geno Atkins NT Haloti Ngata DE Cam Heyward LB Terrell Suggs LB Vontaze Burfict LB Lawrence Timmons LB Jason Worilds CB Joe Haden CB Jimmy Smith S Donte Whitner S Troy PolamaluHaving 6/22 top positions in the division is pretty nice.
Also, without looking at the rosters, I'd find it hard to believe that any division team made up would beat the NFC West team. The Seahawks, 49ers, Rams and Cardinals are too talented on both sides of the ball, especially defensively.
-
Anybody see the 'division' superbowl thing going around? Basically picking an all-division team and having a knockout competition based on voters.
http://nflspinzone.com/2014/07/25/nfl-division-super-bowl-afc-north-vs-nfc-north/
Not sure who picked the teams, but they ended up with:
QB Ben Roethlisberger RB Gio Bernard TE Jordan Cameron WR Josh Gordon WR A.J. Green WR Torrey Smith LT Joe Thomas LG Andrew Whitworth C Alex Mack RG Marshal Yanda RTAndre Smith
DE Geno Atkins NT Haloti Ngata DE Cam Heyward LB Terrell Suggs LB Vontaze Burfict LB Lawrence Timmons LB Jason Worilds CB Joe Haden CB Jimmy Smith S Donte Whitner S Troy PolamaluHaving 6/22 top positions in the division is pretty nice.
Also, without looking at the rosters, I'd find it hard to believe that any division team made up would beat the NFC West team. The Seahawks, 49ers, Rams and Cardinals are too talented on both sides of the ball, especially defensively.
Having 6/22 top positions in the division is pretty nice.
Also, without looking at the rosters, I'd find it hard to believe that any division team made up would be the NFC West team. The Seahawks, 49ers, Rams and Cardinals are too talented on both sides of the ball, especially defensively.
6/22 is very marginally over 1/4. Which is actually nice, to for once be at least on par with the rest of the division, and not really have too many complaints about those 6.
Maybe Daryl Smith over Timmons?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login