Can of Worms
-
OK, how about this:
1) Identify who you think is the weakest player on the team, assuming everybody healthy (and nobody suspended)
2) Who would you pick to replace them from the league and why?
-
OK, how about this:
1) Identify who you think is the weakest player on the team, assuming everybody healthy (and nobody suspended)
2) Who would you pick to replace them from the league and why?
-
I'd make that the weakest actual starter.
WSS
I thought that was implied, otherwise you'd do what Zombo did and swap a 4th string TE for a starter from elsewhere.
-
Well possibly but I thought picking your weakest starter and swapping him out was kind of implied as well. Still trading an average starter for a great one at a more important position makes sense I mean we could trade our long snapper for the Pro Bowl snapper but it wouldn't improve the team as much as trading somebody for JJ Watt.
WSS
-
Yeah I wouldn't count special teams. But is JJ Watt as big of an upgrade from Desmond Bryant as, say, Patrick Peterson from Buster Skrine? Or Justin Houston over Mingo? Kuechly over Kirksey? Megatron over Gabriel? Gronk over Cameron?
-
give me the cowbows left tackle in exchange for mitchell schwartz
-
OK, how about this:
1) Identify who you think is the weakest player on the team, assuming everybody healthy (and nobody suspended)
2) Who would you pick to replace them from the league and why?
-
Tough call ....either Ben Tate for West or Trent Richardson for Crowell ...on the other hand that back up QB at Dallas looked quite good the other week
-
Luck for hoyer no brainer
-
Zombo said:
Let's replace Ben Tate with Josh Gordon.
Z
+1
-
Yeah... has to be starter swap... also should be same position otherwise....
Offensive Starter: Nick McDonald for the youngest "elite" QB, Luck...
Defensive Starter: Robertson for Watt.
But if impose same position then...
O: Hoyer for Luck.
Robertson for Khalil Mack. -
Luck for McDonald?
Uhh brilliant. Let's see how long it takes before defenses kill Andrew Luck behind whatever practice squad center we have that's backing up big Nick.

WSS
-
fuck some of you are Retarded. The game has to be a position for position swap. Otherwise you can say some 4th string special teams player for Watt or Luck...fucking stupid. Stay within the rules asshats.

-
I think Id trade Miles Austin for Sammy Watkins, just to mess with some people.
Then Id have Sammy AND the Bills pick. Might not make the team better, but it sure would be funny.

-
Luck for McDonald?
Uhh brilliant. Let's see how long it takes before defenses kill Andrew Luck behind whatever practice squad center we have that's backing up big Nick.

WSS
Luck for McDonald?
Uhh brilliant. Let's see how long it takes before defenses kill Andrew Luck behind whatever practice squad center we have that's backing up big Nick.

Steve, if you'd been paying attention you'd know I "solved" the O-line's problems weeks ago...

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
