Cardale Jones Is Better Than Jameis Winston
-
Much better thrower than Newton. Just as good a competitor. Not as good a runner.
My exact feelings.
Jameis works up the pocket, Cam works out. Equal arm strength. Both strong competitors with large frames. Jameis with no off-field issues is the closest thing to Andrew Luck we have seen.
-
Should be... they showed a AKA a highlight package. But interceptions tend to discount a QB, and rightly so.
Cardale is TBD, but he had one helluva an intro.
Should be... they showed a AKA a highlight package. But interceptions tend to discount a QB, and rightly so.
Cardale is TBD, but he had one helluva an intro.
To be fair, a pretty good amount of the INT's Jameis threw were because his guys weren't in the right place, didn't make an NFL level play, etc. A good portion of the skill players other than Greene were freshmen last year on the FSU team. I think the guy will excel in the NFL as long as his personal life doesn't haunt him.
-
Winston have one of the slowest throwing motion coming out i've seen in recent years. You just can't change throwing motion this late in the process. You can teach footwork, where you hold the ball, balance and follow-thru but not the motion. When you look at every aspect of his game, he's no where near Andrew Luck. I know most disagree but Mariota is as close to Andrew Luck as they come. He's going to win ROY.
-
Winston have one of the slowest throwing motion coming out i've seen in recent years. You just can't change throwing motion this late in the process. You can teach footwork, where you hold the ball, balance and follow-thru but not the motion. When you look at every aspect of his game, he's no where near Andrew Luck. I know most disagree but Mariota is as close to Andrew Luck as they come. He's going to win ROY.
Winston have one of the slowest throwing motion coming out i've seen in recent years. You just can't change throwing motion this late in the process. You can teach footwork, where you hold the ball, balance and follow-thru but not the motion. When you look at every aspect of his game, he's no where near Andrew Luck. I know most disagree but Mariota is as close to Andrew Luck as they come. He's going to win ROY.
Nope.....The DUKE is going to be ROY>.....
-
Winston have one of the slowest throwing motion coming out i've seen in recent years. You just can't change throwing motion this late in the process. You can teach footwork, where you hold the ball, balance and follow-thru but not the motion. When you look at every aspect of his game, he's no where near Andrew Luck. I know most disagree but Mariota is as close to Andrew Luck as they come. He's going to win ROY.
Winston have one of the slowest throwing motion coming out i've seen in recent years. You just can't change throwing motion this late in the process. You can teach footwork, where you hold the ball, balance and follow-thru but not the motion. When you look at every aspect of his game, he's no where near Andrew Luck. I know most disagree but Mariota is as close to Andrew Luck as they come. He's going to win ROY.
Ha.
-
Should be... they showed a AKA a highlight package. But interceptions tend to discount a QB, and rightly so.
Cardale is TBD, but he had one helluva an intro.
To be fair, a pretty good amount of the INT's Jameis threw were because his guys weren't in the right place, didn't make an NFL level play, etc. A good portion of the skill players other than Greene were freshmen last year on the FSU team. I think the guy will excel in the NFL as long as his personal life doesn't haunt him.
To be fair, a pretty good amount of the INT's Jameis threw were because his guys weren't in the right place...
Which guys? His or the Defense's?
Winston have one of the slowest throwing motion coming out i've seen in recent years.
He had baseball wind up in his delivery, much as Wheezy did, but unlike Wheezy's it was gone by his Pro Day. Might he revert under pressure? Possibly for a time, but ultimately it will be gone and what will be left is plenty fast enough.
-
-
Winston have one of the slowest throwing motion coming out i've seen in recent years. You just can't change throwing motion this late in the process. You can teach footwork, where you hold the ball, balance and follow-thru but not the motion. When you look at every aspect of his game, he's no where near Andrew Luck. I know most disagree but Mariota is as close to Andrew Luck as they come. He's going to win ROY.
Winston have one of the slowest throwing motion coming out i've seen in recent years. You just can't change throwing motion this late in the process. You can teach footwork, where you hold the ball, balance and follow-thru but not the motion. When you look at every aspect of his game, he's no where near Andrew Luck. I know most disagree but Mariota is as close to Andrew Luck as they come. He's going to win ROY.
I'll take that bet all day.
-
Something tells me WINSTON will get in trouble fast in nfl do something stupid.
Marcus i think will be the better QB but think will take him several years.
CARDALE lol yes he had great 3 games but lets be real hes being over hyped as the next saviour of the browns heck he might not even start for buckeyes this year.
-
Jacob Eason is better than Tom Brady
Jacob Eason is better than Tom Brady
Is he related to Tony Eason? First Pats QB to take them to the SB?
-
Something tells me WINSTON will get in trouble fast in nfl do something stupid.
Marcus i think will be the better QB but think will take him several years.
CARDALE lol yes he had great 3 games but lets be real hes being over hyped as the next saviour of the browns heck he might not even start for buckeyes this year.
CARDALE lol yes he had great 3 games but lets be real hes being over hyped as the next saviour of the browns heck he might not even start for buckeyes this year.
true. rewatched championship game last night. cardale is no one to 'fail' for.
-
true. rewatched championship game last night. cardale is no one to 'fail' for.
We've failed for much less.
I'm awesome, and I fuck dolphins. Ghoolie 12/2/2012: I have absolutely no skills, training or pride -
In SI today, we learned that the Titans never considered ANY trade package for Mariota -- they wanted him, period.
Many people on this board and at other draft grading websites knocked us down because we "didn't" trade for Mariota... even though we never had a chance!
-
In SI today, we learned that the Titans never considered ANY trade package for Mariota -- they wanted him, period.
Many people on this board and at other draft grading websites knocked us down because we "didn't" trade for Mariota... even though we never had a chance!
In SI today, we learned that the Titans never considered ANY trade package for Mariota -- they wanted him, period.
Many people on this board and at other draft grading websites knocked us down because we "didn't" trade for Mariota... even though we never had a chance!
Well, some of those knocked the Browns for not taking a QB in like the 5th/6th round......as if they knew that another Tom Brady was just waiting there
(though I was thinking perhaps they could take Shane Carden....who some say remind them of Brett Favre). But, honestly, those guys are not truly any better prospects than JFF and Connor Shaw. If Shaw were in this year's draft, he may have been taken by someone.
-
I think people are under valuing Urban Meyers genius system. He made Alex Smith the number 1 pick in the draft, and made Tebow a first round pick. The whole team around Cardale was playing lights out. He may not even be the best QB on Ohio States roster. He still has a lot to prove, but he does throw one helluva deep ball.
-
We've failed for much less.
have the browns really ever failed on purpose or just failed?
-
We've failed for much less.
have the browns really ever failed on purpose or just failed?
-
Jacob Eason is better than Tom Brady
Is he related to Tony Eason? First Pats QB to take them to the SB?
Is he related to Tony Eason? First Pats QB to take them to the SB?
Leading QB in 2017 freshman college QB rankings
-
Jacob Eason is better than Tom Brady
Is he related to Tony Eason? First Pats QB to take them to the SB?
Is he related to Tony Eason? First Pats QB to take them to the SB?
Leading QB in 2017 freshman college QB rankings
I repeat....is he related to Tony Eason? -
Why was this thread made? Nobody who's actually evaluating QB's thinks this.
Winston is accurate in all parts of the field.. Cardale only has an ungodly deep ball. Cardale never had a full-field pass play actually called due to his limitations of accuracy and experience.. it was always front-side only with a deep option, and if all those are taken away, stiff-arm the nearest DT.
Yes, CJ12 probably will win the battle this spring, but he's not the most accurate passer on the OSU roster today. WILL he be better than Winston after a full year of experience? I hope so.
But he's not there today.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login