Who do you think wins rookie of the year?

LondonBrown

@miktoxic said:

ouch.

funny though

The Gipper

Offense: Duke Johnson with 1300 yards running and receiving

Defense: Nate Orchard. For having about 10-12 sacks.

Why not be a homer?

WalterWhite

@the-gipper said:

Offense: Duke Johnson with 1300 yards running and receiving

Defense: Nate Orchard. For having about 10-12 sacks.

Why not be a homer?

That would be nice for once.

Both should be day 1 contributors.

gftChris

Nate Orchard I thought myself. I mean, who else? Beasley is good but on a team lacking defensive skill. Shelton, sure, but when does a NT get accolades? Williams is great but might get limited on that DL rotation. Orchard is in a position on a very good D to get a lot of sacks.

ORoY - Probably Kevin White?

miktoxic

i'd like to see a RB win it....maybe gordon? (ilike gurley but his injury history scares me).

defense williams.

homer picks would be johnson and orchard.

Opal312

Offense : Duke Johnson

Defense: Leonard Williams if he's the starter

Canton Mike

My picks ARE homer picks, so live with it! LOL

O= Duke Johnson, but he'll be pushed hard by Mayle & his red zone presence.

D= Danny Shelton over Orchard as Shelton will see more plays due to the diversity we'll see in the front 7.

Mike

PoeticG

Obviously not a rookie but Manziel will be the comeback player of the year... easy.

Canton Mike

@poeticg said:
Obviously not a rookie but Manziel will be the comeback player of the year... easy.

POG,

Due to how much he plays, I agree with this year or next. I think (or should I say "WE think") that Manziel WILL come back strong.

I think this kid has what it takes.

Mike

htownbrown

O: Gurley

Gregory

wargograw

@htownbrown said:

O: Gurley

Gregory

Agree on both. Gurley will do what Beckham did. Only play 3/4 of the season and still dominate everything. Gregory is just in the perfect situation to do well.

TexasAg1969

Offense: Green-Beckham just because we passed on him. (I think really it just might be a sleeper-WR Tyler Lockett who also steps up the return game)

Defense: Williams

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000492541/article/sudden-impact-projecting-top-100-nfl-rookies-of-2015

jrb12711

I think Melvin Gordon has the best chance for offense. Healthy RB going to a good, established team where he'll be a day one starter.

Defense is really a toss up but Leonard Williams or Shane Ray are my guess

The Gipper

@wargograw said:
Agree on both. Gurley will do what Beckham did. Only play 3/4 of the season and still dominate everything. Gregory is just in the perfect situation to do well.

Gurley will break again. Gregory will get busted again.

wargograw

The old what has always happened will happen again fallacy? Maybe so. I doubt Gurley breaks down in 10 games though. The Rams also seem to do well with new running backs.

The Gipper

@wargograw said:
The old what has always happened will happen again fallacy? Maybe so. I doubt Gurley breaks down in 10 games though. The Rams also seem to do well with new running backs.

I am just saying that I think there are more reliable guys. Without being a homer I would think on offense that it would not be one of the QBs....more like Cooper. And on defense, if a guy really does a number with sacks, he could get that ROY call. That is why Orchard is not a bad choice, but if not him, then one of the pass rushers....or perhaps Williams who is supposed to have both inside bullishness and pass rushing aptitude.

gumby73

The Key to my hometown guy Todd Gurley winning O ROYear is his sorry Rams OL. Along with Gurley the Rams Drafted 4 OL men and they needed them. Wish Todd Well.. On D ROYear It's a toss up between L. Williams and S. Ray. Ray on a good team that needs D help to get to the next step S. Ray Fits and I don't think he's going to let Himself or Family Down Again.. Doubt if you want not me..