Skip to content

The Dirty Dozen

The Browns Board
48 22 1.9k
  • Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #6

    Gene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb...

    One QB told the story that if Lipscomb ever offered a hand to help you off the ground after he knocked you down, do not take it... he would try to crush your hand.

  • cdl15C cdl15 wrote on last edited by
    #7

    Bo Jackson???

  • The Soldier said:

    Bill Romanowski

    Brian Urlacher

    Mike Singletary

    James Harrison

    While this thread title is "The Dirty Dozen" I was not actually thinking or hoping that we would not get "dirty" players....

    Urlacher and Singletary: OK.

    The other two may make a "Dirtiest player Dozen" list.

    C Captain Cheesedick wrote on last edited by
    #8

    @the-gipper said:

    While this thread title is "The Dirty Dozen" I was not actually thinking or hoping that we would not get "dirty" players....

    Urlacher and Singletary: OK.

    The other two may make a "Dirtiest player Dozen" list.

    I agree, somewhat. Romanowski was dirty. Harrison's hits may be considered dirty today, however, they are no dirtier than the classics (in their time) on your list.

  • Here is my list of the "Dirty Dozen", i.e. the Top 12 Badasses in NFL History. No order:

    Chuck Bednarik

    Jim Brown

    Dick Butkus

    Mean Joe Greene

    Deacon Jones

    Jack Lambert

    Dick Night Train Lane

    Ray Lewis

    Ronnie Lott

    Ray Nitschke

    Jack Tatum

    Lawrence Taylor

    For a Baker's Dozen include perhaps: Randy White

    Any other nominees?

    nickersN nickers wrote on last edited by nickers
    #9

    @the-gipper said:

    Here is my list of the "Dirty Dozen", i.e. the Top 12 Badasses in NFL History. No order:

    Chuck Bednarik

    Jim Brown

    Dick Butkus

    Mean Joe Greene

    Deacon Jones

    Jack Lambert

    Dick Night Train Lane

    Ray Lewis

    Ronnie Lott

    Ray Nitschke

    Jack Tatum

    Lawrence Taylor

    For a Baker's Dozen include perhaps: Randy White

    Any other nominees?

    Gino Marchetti.. Jim Otto.. And I'm trying to think of the one nuthead that played for the colts .. Art Donovan... Reggie White, too...

  • @the-gipper said:

    While this thread title is "The Dirty Dozen" I was not actually thinking or hoping that we would not get "dirty" players....

    Urlacher and Singletary: OK.

    The other two may make a "Dirtiest player Dozen" list.

    I agree, somewhat. Romanowski was dirty. Harrison's hits may be considered dirty today, however, they are no dirtier than the classics (in their time) on your list.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #10

    The Soldier said:

    I agree, somewhat. Romanowski was dirty. Harrison's hits may be considered dirty today, however, they are no dirtier than the classics (in their time) on your list.

    Maybe, I don't know. I avoided putting on the likes of Ben Davidson and Conrad Dobler and Hines Ward because of their reputation as dirty.

    I also left off the likes of Bruce Smith, Reggie White, Bob Lilly and some others.....though I did put in Joe Greene, who was about equal to those in terms of play.....but with a dirtier reputation.

  • MudflyM Mudfly wrote on last edited by Mudfly
    #11

    Walter Payton....probably the nicest badass ever...

    Browns havent had too many legit badasses, but for a short while Don Rogers fit the bill.....

  • Walter Payton....probably the nicest badass ever...

    Browns havent had too many legit badasses, but for a short while Don Rogers fit the bill.....

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #12

    @mudfly said:

    Walter Payton....probably the nicest badass ever...

    Browns havent had too many legit badasses, but for a short while Don Rogers fit the bill.....

    and Eric Turner

  • medicinemanM medicineman wrote on last edited by
    #13

    What players on our team do you think have what it takes to be on a championship team? I would say Joe Thomas but other than that IDK, Thoughts?

  • What players on our team do you think have what it takes to be on a championship team? I would say Joe Thomas but other than that IDK, Thoughts?

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #14

    @medicineman said:

    What players on our team do you think have what it takes to be on a championship team? I would say Joe Thomas but other than that IDK, Thoughts?

    Any of them could be on a championship team.

    Tramon Williams WAS on the 2010 Packers team that won the title.

    The thing that really matters is if the Browns can find a championship caliber QB.

    Give us Aaron Rodgers and I say here that ALL of the Browns on this roster have what it takes to be on a Championship team.

  • T Tony_Shalub wrote on last edited by
    #15

    How about Jack Youngblood

  • Gene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb...

    One QB told the story that if Lipscomb ever offered a hand to help you off the ground after he knocked you down, do not take it... he would try to crush your hand.

    Canton MikeC Canton Mike wrote on last edited by
    #16

    @tour2ma said:

    Gene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb...

    One QB told the story that if Lipscomb ever offered a hand to help you off the ground after he knocked you down, do not take it... he would try to crush your hand.

    Saw him play. Big Daddy was a giant back then & may be the ONLY player I ever saw take Jimmy Brown down one on one. He was an athletic freak, but sadly, had many demons & died while still a young man.

    Mike

  • Here is my list of the "Dirty Dozen", i.e. the Top 12 Badasses in NFL History. No order:

    Chuck Bednarik

    Jim Brown

    Dick Butkus

    Mean Joe Greene

    Deacon Jones

    Jack Lambert

    Dick Night Train Lane

    Ray Lewis

    Ronnie Lott

    Ray Nitschke

    Jack Tatum

    Lawrence Taylor

    For a Baker's Dozen include perhaps: Randy White

    Any other nominees?

    RichiswhereR Richiswhere wrote on last edited by
    #17

    @the-gipper said:

    Any other nominees?

    Erik Williams

  • BrownsnMoparB BrownsnMopar wrote on last edited by
    #18

    John Riggins

  • Canton DawgC Canton Dawg wrote on last edited by
    #19

    Conrad Dobler

  • Conrad Dobler

    hoortaH hoorta wrote on last edited by hoorta
    #20

    @canton-dawg said:

    Conrad Dobler

    Belongs in the "Dirtiest Player" HOF. As he said- stick you hand in my face, you're gonna get bit.

    Modern Day- Whines Hard would be a lock. Never missed an opportunity to blast a defender when he wasn't looking.

  • @the-gipper said:

    Here is my list of the "Dirty Dozen", i.e. the Top 12 Badasses in NFL History. No order:

    Any other nominees?

    I would say Mike Ditka, Kenny Easley, Earl Cambell, Mark Bavaro.

    StinkHoleS StinkHole wrote on last edited by
    #21

    @manzier said:

    I would say Mike Ditka, Kenny Easley, Earl Cambell, Mark Bavaro.

    Most of you are missing the point. Those were great players, but not badass. There is a distinction. As great as Earl Campbell was, he was still a gentleman.

    Jack Ham and Jack Lambert equally good and both HOF'ers. The only distinction between the two is that Ham was never regarded as a badass.

    CB Deon Sanders not a badass, Rod Woodson was.

  • Walter Payton....probably the nicest badass ever...

    Browns havent had too many legit badasses, but for a short while Don Rogers fit the bill.....

    StinkHoleS StinkHole wrote on last edited by
    #22

    @mudfly said:

    Walter Payton....probably the nicest badass ever...

    Browns havent had too many legit badasses, but for a short while Don Rogers fit the bill.....

    Um...Frank Minnifield and Handford Dixon? Both badass IMO.

  • Conrad Dobler

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #23

    @canton-dawg said:

    Conrad Dobler

    Perennial #1 on the dirty survey.

  • Z Zombo wrote on last edited by
    #24

    All Time Browns Dirty Dozen

    Drunk and winging it:

    Lou Groza

    Gene Hickerson

    Jim Brown

    Walter Johnson

    Jerry Sherk

    Doug Dieken

    Eddie Johnson

    Don Rogers

    Mike Baab

    Eric Turner

    Josh Cribbs

    Karlos Dansby

  • W wargograw wrote on last edited by wargograw
    #25

    Greatest Motown singers ever (with personal anecdotes littered in). Go.