Skip to content

Benjamin 'close' to signing a new contract

The Browns Board
56 17 1.4k
  • @roycerolls said:

    Manziel was good in college because he was in college. Receivers are the most overrated players on the field. The Panthers will probably win the Super Bowl and no one seems to care that their best wide receiver is Ted Ginn Jr. Almost every year the champions win with QB play and defense. We have neither and we still have people complaining about receivers? Do you people pay attention to what happens in the NFL or do you just watch your diabetic neighbor play madden?

    Remember that one time Bellicheck drafted a receiver in the first round? Yeah, neither does anyone else.

    Good post. And, I agree. But technically, there was Derrick Alexander

    WR 2014 7 29 244 Jeremy Gallon Michigan
    2013 2 27 59 Aaron Dobson Marshall
    2013 4 5 102 Josh Boyce Texas Christian
    2012 7 28 235 Jeremy Ebert Northwestern
    2010 3 26 90 Taylor Price Ohio
    2009 3 19 83 Brandon Tate North Carolina
    2008 5 18 153 Matt Slater UCLA
    2006 2 4 36 Chad Jackson Florida
    2004 5 32 164 P.K. Sam Florida State
    2003 2 13 45 Bethel Johnson Texas A&M
    2002 2 33 65 Deion Branch Louisville
    2002 7 33 244 David Givens Notre Dame
    1995 5 13 147 Mike Miller Notre Dame
    1995 7 23 231 A.C. Tellison Miami (FL)
    1994 1 29 29 Derrick Alexander Michigan
    1992 2 24 52 Patrick Rowe San Diego State
    1992 6 3 143 Rico Smith Colorado
    1992 11 9 289 Augustin Olobia Washington State
    1991 6 2 141 Michael Jackson Southern Mississippi
    1991 9 16 239 Shawn Wiggins Wyoming
    R RoyceRolls wrote on last edited by
    #27

    Zombo said:

    Good post. And, I agree. But technically, there was Derrick Alexander

    WR 2014 7 29 244 Jeremy Gallon Michigan

    2013 2 27 59 Aaron Dobson Marshall

    2013 4 5 102 Josh Boyce Texas Christian

    2012 7 28 235 Jeremy Ebert Northwestern

    2010 3 26 90 Taylor Price Ohio

    2009 3 19 83 Brandon Tate North Carolina

    2008 5 18 153 Matt Slater UCLA

    2006 2 4 36 Chad Jackson Florida

    2004 5 32 164 P.K. Sam Florida State

    2003 2 13 45 Bethel Johnson Texas A&M

    2002 2 33 65 Deion Branch Louisville

    2002 7 33 244 David Givens Notre Dame

    1995 5 13 147 Mike Miller Notre Dame

    1995 7 23 231 A.C. Tellison Miami (FL)

    1994 1 29 29 Derrick Alexander Michigan

    1992 2 24 52 Patrick Rowe San Diego State

    1992 6 3 143 Rico Smith Colorado

    1992 11 9 289 Augustin Olobia Washington State

    1991 6 2 141 Michael Jackson Southern Mississippi

    1991 9 16 239 Shawn Wiggins Wyoming

    You're right, I meant patriot era Belichick, after he had learned how to win.

  • mike evans was my fave receiver in that draft. push off or not, the browns have no one a qb can throw the ball 6 ft. over their had and come down with it in the end zone while little flea cbs bounce up and off him like the fleas they are (compared to him). gronk? mark bavarro? ozzie? can we find someone bigger that a beetle to grab a ball over their heads and then steam roll people into the end zone?

    maybe?

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #28

    @miktoxic said:

    mike evans was my fave receiver in that draft. push off or not, the browns have no one a qb can throw the ball 6 ft. over their had and come down with it in the end zone while little flea cbs bounce up and off him like the fleas they are (compared to him). gronk? mark bavarro? ozzie? can we find someone bigger that a beetle to grab a ball over their heads and then steam roll people into the end zone?

    maybe?

    Barnidge.....and Terrelle Pryor if he sticks and performs.

    Gordon, if he returns.....and yes, I am in favor of drafting a big WR. Mayle was supposed to be there as well. How could they have missed so badly on him?

  • @miktoxic said:

    mike evans was my fave receiver in that draft. push off or not, the browns have no one a qb can throw the ball 6 ft. over their had and come down with it in the end zone while little flea cbs bounce up and off him like the fleas they are (compared to him). gronk? mark bavarro? ozzie? can we find someone bigger that a beetle to grab a ball over their heads and then steam roll people into the end zone?

    maybe?

    Barnidge.....and Terrelle Pryor if he sticks and performs.

    Gordon, if he returns.....and yes, I am in favor of drafting a big WR. Mayle was supposed to be there as well. How could they have missed so badly on him?

    gftChrisG gftChris wrote on last edited by
    #29

    @the-gipper said:

    Barnidge.....and Terrelle Pryor if he sticks and performs.

    Gordon, if he returns.....and yes, I am in favor of drafting a big WR. Mayle was supposed to be there as well. How could they have missed so badly on him?

    Hartline is 6'2" also. With him and Barnie that's two. And don't forget bowe and housler...

  • Mike HM Mike H wrote on last edited by
    #30

    Housler was released. Bowe probably will be too.

  • miktoxicM miktoxic wrote on last edited by miktoxic
    #31

    yeah and barnidge is no gronk, or bavarro, or ozzie or evans. sure he looks great when he grabs a pass wide open because no one thinks anything of him except us. it was like the wentz pass to vanetti (osu te in the senior bowl)....you can say wow, great pass (behind him by 2 yards) or great catch but did he make it a yard after someone tripped him up by his shoelaces?

    c'mon man. there's a HUGE difference.

    i mean when's the last time we saw any browns player carry four defenders on his back 10 yards into the end zone? mack? meanwhile gronk and those built like him do it 10 times a game.

  • B BaconHound wrote on last edited by
    #32

    Benjamin is a solid #2 and should be accurately compensated. If he is looking for #1 money that is a harder decision.

  • Yet somehow Russell Wilson makes due with a set of WRs that are 5'10, 6'1, 5'10, 6'0 and 6'1... Why is that?

    And one the shortest was his best...

    B BaconHound wrote on last edited by
    #33

    @tour2ma said:

    Yet somehow Russell Wilson makes due with a set of WRs that are 5'10, 6'1, 5'10, 6'0 and 6'1... Why is that?

    And one the shortest was his best...

    Better O-Line, running game and defense.

  • Manziel was good in college because he was in college. Receivers are the most overrated players on the field. The Panthers will probably win the Super Bowl and no one seems to care that their best wide receiver is Ted Ginn Jr. Almost every year the champions win with QB play and defense. We have neither and we still have people complaining about receivers? Do you people pay attention to what happens in the NFL or do you just watch your diabetic neighbor play madden?

    Remember that one time Bellicheck drafted a receiver in the first round? Yeah, neither does anyone else.

    B BaconHound wrote on last edited by
    #34

    @roycerolls said:

    Manziel was good in college because he was in college. Receivers are the most overrated players on the field. The Panthers will probably win the Super Bowl and no one seems to care that their best wide receiver is Ted Ginn Jr. Almost every year the champions win with QB play and defense. We have neither and we still have people complaining about receivers? Do you people pay attention to what happens in the NFL or do you just watch your diabetic neighbor play madden?

    Remember that one time Bellicheck drafted a receiver in the first round? Yeah, neither does anyone else.

    Talk to the 49ers of the late 80s early 90s.

    All positions are going to be overvalued when you excel at other aspects. The Panthers have rushed for 100 yards in 31 straight games and combine that with their defense you don't need to throw for 400 yards.

  • @tour2ma said:

    Yet somehow Russell Wilson makes due with a set of WRs that are 5'10, 6'1, 5'10, 6'0 and 6'1... Why is that?

    And one the shortest was his best...

    Better O-Line, running game and defense.

    Mike HM Mike H wrote on last edited by
    #35

    @baconhound said:

    Better O-Line, running game and defense.

    Correlation does not equal causation.

    Put up one of the best stretches, if not the very best, in NFL history during the 2nd half of 2015. His O-line is also patch work, and not made up of highly-touted draft picks like the Browns'

  • @tour2ma said:

    Yet somehow Russell Wilson makes due with a set of WRs that are 5'10, 6'1, 5'10, 6'0 and 6'1... Why is that?

    And one the shortest was his best...

    Better O-Line, running game and defense.

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #36

    @baconhound said:

    Better O-Line, running game and defense.

    Which one makes Wilson taller?

  • @the-gipper said:

    Barnidge.....and Terrelle Pryor if he sticks and performs.

    Gordon, if he returns.....and yes, I am in favor of drafting a big WR. Mayle was supposed to be there as well. How could they have missed so badly on him?

    Hartline is 6'2" also. With him and Barnie that's two. And don't forget bowe and housler...

    FlugelF Flugel wrote on last edited by
    #37

    @gftchris said:

    Hartline is 6'2" also. With him and Barnie that's two. And don't forget bowe and housler...

    Cleveland was the 2nd straight team where the idea of Doogie Housler was way better than the reality of him.

    How many years do we need to go back to see Bowe's last TD reception?

  • @roycerolls said:

    Manziel was good in college because he was in college. Receivers are the most overrated players on the field. The Panthers will probably win the Super Bowl and no one seems to care that their best wide receiver is Ted Ginn Jr. Almost every year the champions win with QB play and defense. We have neither and we still have people complaining about receivers? Do you people pay attention to what happens in the NFL or do you just watch your diabetic neighbor play madden?

    Remember that one time Bellicheck drafted a receiver in the first round? Yeah, neither does anyone else.

    Good post. And, I agree. But technically, there was Derrick Alexander

    WR 2014 7 29 244 Jeremy Gallon Michigan
    2013 2 27 59 Aaron Dobson Marshall
    2013 4 5 102 Josh Boyce Texas Christian
    2012 7 28 235 Jeremy Ebert Northwestern
    2010 3 26 90 Taylor Price Ohio
    2009 3 19 83 Brandon Tate North Carolina
    2008 5 18 153 Matt Slater UCLA
    2006 2 4 36 Chad Jackson Florida
    2004 5 32 164 P.K. Sam Florida State
    2003 2 13 45 Bethel Johnson Texas A&M
    2002 2 33 65 Deion Branch Louisville
    2002 7 33 244 David Givens Notre Dame
    1995 5 13 147 Mike Miller Notre Dame
    1995 7 23 231 A.C. Tellison Miami (FL)
    1994 1 29 29 Derrick Alexander Michigan
    1992 2 24 52 Patrick Rowe San Diego State
    1992 6 3 143 Rico Smith Colorado
    1992 11 9 289 Augustin Olobia Washington State
    1991 6 2 141 Michael Jackson Southern Mississippi
    1991 9 16 239 Shawn Wiggins Wyoming
    FlugelF Flugel wrote on last edited by
    #38

    Zombo said:

    Good post. And, I agree. But technically, there was Derrick Alexander

    WR 2014 7 29 244 Jeremy Gallon Michigan
    2013 2 27 59 Aaron Dobson Marshall
    2013 4 5 102 Josh Boyce Texas Christian
    2012 7 28 235 Jeremy Ebert Northwestern
    2010 3 26 90 Taylor Price Ohio
    2009 3 19 83 Brandon Tate North Carolina
    2008 5 18 153 Matt Slater UCLA
    2006 2 4 36 Chad Jackson Florida
    2004 5 32 164 P.K. Sam Florida State
    2003 2 13 45 Bethel Johnson Texas A&M
    2002 2 33 65 Deion Branch Louisville
    2002 7 33 244 David Givens Notre Dame
    1995 5 13 147 Mike Miller Notre Dame
    1995 7 23 231 A.C. Tellison Miami (FL)
    1994 1 29 29 Derrick Alexander Michigan
    1992 2 24 52 Patrick Rowe San Diego State
    1992 6 3 143 Rico Smith Colorado
    1992 11 9 289 Augustin Olobia Washington State
    1991 6 2 141 Michael Jackson Southern Mississippi
    1991 9 16 239 Shawn Wiggins Wyoming

    Good stuff. Unfortunately, here's a list showing we haven't had a lot of luck w/ WRs in round 2 of the regular NFL draft either.

    Lawyer Tillman - I remembered looking forward to seeing/hearing some "Bernie to the Attorney" hook ups - but bad luck w/ injuries ruined that.

    Patrick Rowe

    Dennis Northcutt - good return guy but disappointing WR that demanded 1st round $ for being a 32 overall pick in 2000 (before a 32nd team was added).

    Quincey Morgan - The rock quarry for hands that inspired Bottlegate before Cincy took that tradition over a month ago.

    Andre Davis - Too many injuries to get anything going.

    Greg Little - Led us in dropped passes both years we led the conference in drops. Most PRO teams don't draft WRs that need to be taught how to catch.

  • @roycerolls said:

    Manziel was good in college because he was in college. Receivers are the most overrated players on the field. The Panthers will probably win the Super Bowl and no one seems to care that their best wide receiver is Ted Ginn Jr. Almost every year the champions win with QB play and defense. We have neither and we still have people complaining about receivers? Do you people pay attention to what happens in the NFL or do you just watch your diabetic neighbor play madden?

    Remember that one time Bellicheck drafted a receiver in the first round? Yeah, neither does anyone else.

    Good post. And, I agree. But technically, there was Derrick Alexander

    WR 2014 7 29 244 Jeremy Gallon Michigan
    2013 2 27 59 Aaron Dobson Marshall
    2013 4 5 102 Josh Boyce Texas Christian
    2012 7 28 235 Jeremy Ebert Northwestern
    2010 3 26 90 Taylor Price Ohio
    2009 3 19 83 Brandon Tate North Carolina
    2008 5 18 153 Matt Slater UCLA
    2006 2 4 36 Chad Jackson Florida
    2004 5 32 164 P.K. Sam Florida State
    2003 2 13 45 Bethel Johnson Texas A&M
    2002 2 33 65 Deion Branch Louisville
    2002 7 33 244 David Givens Notre Dame
    1995 5 13 147 Mike Miller Notre Dame
    1995 7 23 231 A.C. Tellison Miami (FL)
    1994 1 29 29 Derrick Alexander Michigan
    1992 2 24 52 Patrick Rowe San Diego State
    1992 6 3 143 Rico Smith Colorado
    1992 11 9 289 Augustin Olobia Washington State
    1991 6 2 141 Michael Jackson Southern Mississippi
    1991 9 16 239 Shawn Wiggins Wyoming
    MudflyM Mudfly wrote on last edited by Mudfly
    #39

    Zombo said:

    Good post. And, I agree. But technically, there was Derrick Alexander

    The irony is that Derrick Alexander is the 2nd best(in career production) WR drafted by the Browns in the last 30 years...

    So the one that Bullychuck picked was the only winner, compared to the other 14 we've picked in the top 2 rounds....of course, he left with the Browns in '95....

    @flugel said:

    Good stuff. Unfortunately, here's a list showing we haven't had a lot of luck w/ WRs in round 2 of the regular NFL draft either.

    I went back and researched every WR picked in the top 2 rounds since '85 and it's a long list....14 of them, to be exact....which is basically one every other year....and there are no real stars in the group....none....

    Who is the BEST WR the Browns have drafted in the last 30 years?....That would be Keenan McCardell in Round 12......problem is that we didnt play him and let him leave and the next year he exploded......had a great career elsewhere.....

    Out of the 14 high draft picks(rounds 1 & 2) only 2 of them stuck beyond their rookie contracts....Northcutt and Slaughter....

    Some of our more productive/popular WR's during that same 30 year period were Brian Brennan Rnd 4....Reggie Langhorne Rnd 7....Josh Cribbs UDFA

  • J joedawg69 wrote on last edited by
    #40

    I am good with this signing because he is a good WR and great on special teams. Cribbs was a great special teamer but he did not have the skills at WR that Benjamin has. Benjamin is worth it in my opinion.

  • I am good with this signing because he is a good WR and great on special teams. Cribbs was a great special teamer but he did not have the skills at WR that Benjamin has. Benjamin is worth it in my opinion.

    MudflyM Mudfly wrote on last edited by
    #41

    @joedawg69 said:

    Benjamin is worth it in my opinion.

    I would say it depends on what they pay him, cause Im not convinced this season wasnt a fluke.....give him #2 or 3 money and Im good.....but give him big money and I think they're making another money mistake.....

  • Zombo said:

    Good post. And, I agree. But technically, there was Derrick Alexander

    The irony is that Derrick Alexander is the 2nd best(in career production) WR drafted by the Browns in the last 30 years...

    So the one that Bullychuck picked was the only winner, compared to the other 14 we've picked in the top 2 rounds....of course, he left with the Browns in '95....

    @flugel said:

    Good stuff. Unfortunately, here's a list showing we haven't had a lot of luck w/ WRs in round 2 of the regular NFL draft either.

    I went back and researched every WR picked in the top 2 rounds since '85 and it's a long list....14 of them, to be exact....which is basically one every other year....and there are no real stars in the group....none....

    Who is the BEST WR the Browns have drafted in the last 30 years?....That would be Keenan McCardell in Round 12......problem is that we didnt play him and let him leave and the next year he exploded......had a great career elsewhere.....

    Out of the 14 high draft picks(rounds 1 & 2) only 2 of them stuck beyond their rookie contracts....Northcutt and Slaughter....

    Some of our more productive/popular WR's during that same 30 year period were Brian Brennan Rnd 4....Reggie Langhorne Rnd 7....Josh Cribbs UDFA

    FlugelF Flugel wrote on last edited by Flugel
    #42

    @mudfly said:

    The irony is that Derrick Alexander is the 2nd best(in career production) WR drafted by the Browns in the last 30 years...

    So the one that Bullychuck picked was the only winner, compared to the other 14 we've picked in the top 2 rounds....of course, he left with the Browns in '95....

    I went back and researched every WR picked in the top 2 rounds since '85 and it's a long list....14 of them, to be exact....which is basically one every other year....and there are no real stars in the group....none....

    Who is the BEST WR the Browns have drafted in the last 30 years?....That would be Keenan McCardell in Round 12......problem is that we didnt play him and let him leave and the next year he exploded......had a great career elsewhere.....

    Out of the 14 high draft picks(rounds 1 & 2) only 2 of them stuck beyond their rookie contracts....Northcutt and Slaughter....

    Some of our more productive/popular WR's during that same 30 year period were Brian Brennan Rnd 4....Reggie Langhorne Rnd 7....Josh Cribbs UDFA

    Great stuff! The only nitpick is Keenan McCardell was drafted by the Washington Redskins in round 12.

  • @mudfly said:

    The irony is that Derrick Alexander is the 2nd best(in career production) WR drafted by the Browns in the last 30 years...

    So the one that Bullychuck picked was the only winner, compared to the other 14 we've picked in the top 2 rounds....of course, he left with the Browns in '95....

    I went back and researched every WR picked in the top 2 rounds since '85 and it's a long list....14 of them, to be exact....which is basically one every other year....and there are no real stars in the group....none....

    Who is the BEST WR the Browns have drafted in the last 30 years?....That would be Keenan McCardell in Round 12......problem is that we didnt play him and let him leave and the next year he exploded......had a great career elsewhere.....

    Out of the 14 high draft picks(rounds 1 & 2) only 2 of them stuck beyond their rookie contracts....Northcutt and Slaughter....

    Some of our more productive/popular WR's during that same 30 year period were Brian Brennan Rnd 4....Reggie Langhorne Rnd 7....Josh Cribbs UDFA

    Great stuff! The only nitpick is Keenan McCardell was drafted by the Washington Redskins in round 12.

    MudflyM Mudfly wrote on last edited by
    #43

    @flugel said:

    Great stuff! The only nitpick is I don't think Keenan McCardell was drafted by Cleveland. Without looking, I think either Washington or Chicago drafted him.

    Son of a gun...you're right.....so the one great one we picked, we really didnt pick....figures

  • MudflyM Mudfly wrote on last edited by
    #44

    Here's another scary stat......the last 3 Browns WR's to make the Pro Bowl???

    2007 - Braylon Edwards

    1990 - Webster Slaughter

    1970 - Paul Warfield

    ouch!

  • @flugel said:

    Great stuff! The only nitpick is I don't think Keenan McCardell was drafted by Cleveland. Without looking, I think either Washington or Chicago drafted him.

    Son of a gun...you're right.....so the one great one we picked, we really didnt pick....figures

    FlugelF Flugel wrote on last edited by Flugel
    #45

    @mudfly said:

    Son of a gun...you're right.....so the one great one we picked, we really didnt pick....figures

    That was a good post so it wasn't a big deal at all Mud. I'm kind of partial to Brian Brennan when we factor in how often that guy came up huge on 3rd downs. The guy led our WRs in Receptions despite part time work almost exclusive to 3rd downs.

    The thing I like about Benjamin is he wasn't a high round and in our 2014 matchup with TN - I began to see our patience paying off from training/coaching up the investment to him knowing when/where to sit down in a route as well understanding how to adjust to a coverage leverage/zone blitz scheme. In 2014, he had our most yards per catch and TD receptions in the WR Corps despite only playing part time. I saw a lot of the same things in 2015.

  • Here's another scary stat......the last 3 Browns WR's to make the Pro Bowl???

    2007 - Braylon Edwards

    1990 - Webster Slaughter

    1970 - Paul Warfield

    ouch!

    FlugelF Flugel wrote on last edited by Flugel
    #46

    @mudfly said:

    Here's another scary stat......the last 3 Browns WR's to make the Pro Bowl???

    2007 - Braylon Edwards

    1990 - Webster Slaughter

    1970 - Paul Warfield

    ouch!

    Josh Gordon too.

    The scary thing is what came after the Pro Bowls from Gordon and Edwards. Football looked 2nd to partying.