WEEK 11 NCAA FOOTBALL, top 25, games and more, BIG shake-ups!

mjp28

@wargograw said:
Top 10 team goes down this week. Book it. Hell, it might be A&M again.

WHOA, 5 of the top 10? Understatement of the decade or century in D-1A college football.

mjp28

@wargograw said:

State always plays Bama after the latter plays LSU. State usually covers.

I like Pitt to cover. Maybe win outright

Really like USC straight up.

WHOA again. Three of four undefeated top 10 or better yet top 4 teams go down....were you near Las Vegas this week?

syd

if the big ten plays out how i believe it will,wisconson will play penn state in the title game,which i will give to the badgers,so who would the committee take OSU with one loss or the bigten champs with 2 ?

MLD Woody

You can't take a one loss team over 2 loss champ from that same teams conference. Especially when those teams played to OT.

I think OSU still needs some help to make the playoff if the committee values conference championships at all

wargograw

@bob806 said:
I'm pretty sure the BCS standings breaks the tie.

There are no BCS standings.

wargograw

@mjp28 said:
WHOA again. Three of four undefeated top 10 or better yet top 4 teams go down....were you near Las Vegas this week?

You like that, eh? One of my best friends played for Pitt. I have become endeared to them. They play a great brand of ball. PFF has been saying they have the best pass blocking OL in the country. We know Clemson has a great pass rush, so Pitt had the right tools to neutralize Clemson's strengths. Pitt has become an extremely tough out for anyone. Really, they've been that way basically since 2013, but now even moreso since Narduzzi's shored up the defense a bit while retaining the general concepts of Chryst's offense.

wargograw

Those talking about an 8 team playoff, how do you think this year shows it's necessary? If Alabama loses then you'd have a point. Otherwise, the 4 team playoff is likely going to crown the right champ.

mjp28

@wargograw said:
You like that, eh? One of my best friends played for Pitt. I have become endeared to them. They play a great brand of ball. PFF has been saying they have the best pass blocking OL in the country. We know Clemson has a great pass rush, so Pitt had the right tools to neutralize Clemson's strengths. Pitt has become an extremely tough out for anyone. Really, they've been that way basically since 2013, but now even moreso since Narduzzi's shored up the defense a bit while retaining the general concepts of Chryst's offense.

Pat Narduzzi is the son of Bill Narduzzi, who was the head coach at Youngstown State University from 1975 to 1985. Pat played football for his father in 1985 as a freshman.

Bill Narduzzi was a fine person and coach at YSU ironically I graduated from YSU in 1975 and got my MBA in 1985 all around the Narduzzi era.

Also QB Ron Jaworski graduated just ahead of Coach Narduzzi but he got another good QB Cliff Stout who went on to the Steelers. Small world huh.

Bob806

@wargograw said:

There are no BCS standings.

Semantics, ok.

MLD Woody

If anything, I'd go to a 6 team playoff first.

The Cysko Kid

With this meatchicken loss we should be back up on top of them which is what we have to worry about at the moment more than the playoffs.

The Cysko Kid

@mld-woody said:
If anything, I'd go to a 6 team playoff first.

I think 8 is the right number.

The Cysko Kid

I mean you've got 128 division one FBS schools. There's going to be some longshot teams that play fantastic that ought to have a shot at the playoffs. It will not be difficult to fill out an 8 school bracket with top contenders.

MLD Woody

@the-cysko-kid said:
I mean you've got 128 division one FBS schools. There's going to be some longshot teams that play fantastic that ought to have a shot at the playoffs. It will not be difficult to fill out an 8 school bracket with top contenders.

I'd like to make being one of the top two ranked schools actually mean something.

At the very least the 1st round should be home games for the higher ranked team.

mjp28

@mld-woody said:
If anything, I'd go to a 6 team playoff first.

Without an early bye how does a 6 team work? An 8 team does several things like allow for the P5 teams and several at large teams, 8 just pairs off better and would work.

And who doesn't think 16 might make some intriguing matchup games, 1/16, 2/15 etc.

And yes first round home games for higher seeded teams.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Oh my YSU Penguins should be back in the D-1AA Sweet Sixteen again under Bo Pelini, they've ONLY made the playoffs once since Tressel left!

MLD Woody

6 team giving the top two teams byes.

CFB is one of the few sports left where the regular season means something. A 16 team playoff shatters that

syd

@mld-woody said:

hostility

ya sorry

mjp28

@mld-woody said:

6 team giving the top two teams byes.

CFB is one of the few sports left where the regular season means something. A 16 team playoff shatters that

All of college football but D-1A has playoffs your regular season earns a spot in the playoffs or in D-1A those 30+ bowl games. Yes it matters.

You may hear the cry for expanded playoffs after this season.

MLD Woody

@mjp28 said:

All of college football but D-1A has playoffs your regular season earns a spot in the playoffs or in D-1A those 30+ bowl games. Yes it matters.

You may hear the cry for expanded playoffs after this season.

you'll hear the cry to expand it every season

No one really cares about D-1A football

The Cysko Kid

@mld-woody said:

I'd like to make being one of the top two ranked schools actually mean something.

At the very least the 1st round should be home games for the higher ranked team.

Western Michigan is undefeated. I know they haven't played anyone but you can say that about most teams. It would be good to see one or two teams per year like that get a shot