Draft Talk
-
Hooker entering the picture helps push Foster down...
... but I would not mind Hooker being the pick.QB-wise... I really like Kizer at #33.
Hooker entering the picture helps push Foster down...
... but I would not mind Hooker being the pick.QB-wise... I really like Kizer at #33.
You can pretty much post for me at this point.
Allen, Hooker, Kizer, then Oline depth and secondary.
I'm not opposed to trading down our 2nd first rounder because some people will be learly of taking a safety near top.10. 13-15 range.
-
My point is that we essentially selected Kessler to be that project, and he hasn't looked awful. If we get a stud instant franchise guy then great, but we already have a third round project guy.
Alternatively, we also have a guy with a big arm and athleticism in RG3.
I don't want more projects started, I want to actually finish a product or get a finished article.
-
My point is that we essentially selected Kessler to be that project, and he hasn't looked awful. If we get a stud instant franchise guy then great, but we already have a third round project guy.
Alternatively, we also have a guy with a big arm and athleticism in RG3.
I don't want more projects started, I want to actually finish a product or get a finished article.
But RG3 is a project, albeit with a salvage title.My point is that we essentially selected Kessler to be that project, and he hasn't looked awful. If we get a stud instant franchise guy then great, but we already have a third round project guy.
Alternatively, we also have a guy with a big arm and athleticism in RG3.
I don't want more projects started, I want to actually finish a product or get a finished article.
None of the three top quarterbacks have been NFL failures yet.
No idea how accurate this list of prospects might be when push comes to shove. Others have rated MT as the best QB prospect of the three.
Most seem to have Garrett over Allen.
If the first pic is not a quarterback I'll expect him to start and make a difference day one.
WSS
-
It's hard to say when QB's may be taken, considering the draft order of QB's between now and draft time can change drastically. I wouldn't be surprised to see this draft end up like whatever year EJ Manuel went #16 overall as the first QB off the board. There are just so many question marks about some of these QB's. I just think that without a doubt, baring some crazy pre draft injury, that Garrett is the guy. Wouldn't be mad with Allen either at #1. Both would make an immediate impact and have the potential to be consistent pro bowlers. Hooker at #12 would be a steal as well. He does have some injury concerns, and he was only a 1 year starter, but he has shown to have elite level instincts.
I honestly wouldn't be mad to see us not draft a QB, but I also wouldn't be mad if we did. Just so many questions marks. Honestly I think taking a shot at Tyrod Taylor (assuming that he gets cut) would be a good option.
-
Mahomes declared for the draft today.
-
It's hard to say when QB's may be taken, considering the draft order of QB's between now and draft time can change drastically. I wouldn't be surprised to see this draft end up like whatever year EJ Manuel went #16 overall as the first QB off the board. There are just so many question marks about some of these QB's. I just think that without a doubt, baring some crazy pre draft injury, that Garrett is the guy. Wouldn't be mad with Allen either at #1. Both would make an immediate impact and have the potential to be consistent pro bowlers. Hooker at #12 would be a steal as well. He does have some injury concerns, and he was only a 1 year starter, but he has shown to have elite level instincts.
I honestly wouldn't be mad to see us not draft a QB, but I also wouldn't be mad if we did. Just so many questions marks. Honestly I think taking a shot at Tyrod Taylor (assuming that he gets cut) would be a good option.
It's hard to say when QB's may be taken, considering the draft order of QB's between now and draft time can change drastically. I wouldn't be surprised to see this draft end up like whatever year EJ Manuel went #16 overall as the first QB off the board. There are just so many question marks about some of these QB's. I just think that without a doubt, baring some crazy pre draft injury, that Garrett is the guy. Wouldn't be mad with Allen either at #1. Both would make an immediate impact and have the potential to be consistent pro bowlers. Hooker at #12 would be a steal as well. He does have some injury concerns, and he was only a 1 year starter, but he has shown to have elite level instincts.
I honestly wouldn't be mad to see us not draft a QB, but I also wouldn't be mad if we did. Just so many questions marks. Honestly I think taking a shot at Tyrod Taylor (assuming that he gets cut) would be a good option.
I was thinking the same thing with Tyrod but the last I heard he was trying to get surgery in order the guarantee his contract. Granted I've slept since reading that article so I could be off on that. Regardless, he's a guy worth monitoring.
-
Not a fan of going after Tyrod... nice QB, but I don't think "" when I see him.
Agree with those not seeing Kizer last to #33, but should he fall there, then Imma take'n him. If he's not, then I'll find one later... maybe even Day 3. Chad Kelly should be there then... he'd do until I do more work.
Remember my motto: You always have to be looking for your next QB.
-
I wonder what Garoppolo would cost with a draft pick? If the Browns could get him with no more than that second 2nd round pick, he might be worth it. I'd like to see the Browns go Miles Garrett and another top defensive player ( Rueben Foster, Tim Williams ) or a Jonathon Allen/Solomon Thomas duo. Maybe a Pat Elflein in the second.
-
Hooker entering the picture helps push Foster down...
... but I would not mind Hooker being the pick.QB-wise... I really like Kizer at #33.
Hooker entering the picture helps push Foster down...
... but I would not mind Hooker being the pick.QB-wise... I really like Kizer at #33.
Kizer scares me- (as well as ND QBs in general) I've watched enough of him. Worth #33 probably. If you want to posit he's a good talent on a lousy team, I might buy that.
Word is that Josh Allen QB from Wyoming may be declaring. From what I watched of him, he has the physical tools but is another project.
He needs to stay in Laramie for another year. Poor man's Trubisky.
-
What about drafting 2 QB? Spend a high pick on one of the top 3. And pick an insurance policy in the 4th or 5th? Maybe Cooper Rush, Mahomes, Webb, Falk or kelly.... Is Baker Mayfield draftable this year?
-
I'm not a huge fan of Tyrod either, BUT I do think he'd be an immediate "temporary" upgrade. I wouldn't mind bringing in Tyrod for the right price, cutting McCown (keeping him as coach?), waiving RG III, AND drafting a QB high in the draft. That would give us Tyrod, Kessler, and presumably Kizer or Watson (if they are available at 12, and we draft defense with #1. Mitch won't be there at 12).
Those three QB's won't blow anyone away, but it could be a start. We definitely know that Hue values a mobile QB, and the read-option can be devastating when used correctly. It SHOULD'VE won us the game against the Steelers in overtime, but my therapist instructed me not to speak of that play again. Tyrod struggled with his deep ball this year, but two years ago he was extremely adept at slinging down the field. He's very similar to RG III, but I could argue he's better.
Edit: The Eagles winning their last two drastically hurt our chances to draft one of the top 3 rated QB's in this draft, and I'm pretty sure the Bills have the same record as the Eagles, but pick before them due to tiebreaker. That's significant because if they don't keep Tyrod, they will most likely be drafting a QB, and that's one more team taking a player we probably want.
-
The way I see it is this. Your most glaring weaknesses were offensive line and your secondary, so this is how I would approach it.
QB: You keep who you have at QB outside of McCown. I don't like any of these guys coming out, even Watson, who looked pedestrian against OSU's defense. Kevin Hogan showed promise, I'd continue developing him, he looked like an early version of Steve Young.
RB: You're set.
OL: Outside of LT, LG, RG, you're in trouble. I would find a C/RT in free agency, get some PROVEN talent up there and pay handsomely if I have to and be done with Cam Erving.
WR: It was a disappointing season for this group. Gordon gone again, Coleman hurt, then practically vanished. All this hype about the rookie class, where the heck was Higgins???? Only Louis and Pryor stepped up, and Hawkins was eh. The FA class only has two good names in it that aren't coming here, so you're going to have to go back into the draft for your outside WR, for Coleman's playing in the slot in this offense. I'd go after Westbrook (Oklahoma) or Darboh (Michigan) in the second round.
TE: You're set.
DE: Hands down, my #1 pick is either Allen or Garrett. The biggest weakness on the line is RDE, and you plant one of them there, it'll help Nassib and Shelton, because if you double team either of them, someone is coming free to make a play.
LB: Throw money at Collins, flat out. Give him a 5 years deal, put him on the outside and be done with it. The biggest weakness is on the inside because of Davis, so I'd dip into the draft Either Davis from Florida or Walker from Northwestern in the second round.
CB: Oy vey, the teams OTHER biggest weakness. Flat out, if I can't trade Haden, I'm cutting him and starting over with this group. The only bonafide starter on the roster is Taylor, but he's a solid #2 corner. MAYBE you can get Tankersley (Clemson) or Conley (OSU) to fall into your lap, but if they keep Haden, go after Hooker (OSU).
S: You need a killer back there at SS with some weight on him, so I'm thinking Clemons (Louisville). He'd pair well with Hooker.
So in order, my draft board would look like this...
First round: (2) Own pick and the Eagles' pick.
DE (Allen, Garrett), S (Hooker)
Second round: (2) Own pick and the Titans' pick.
CB (Tankersely, Conley), ILB (Davis, Walker)
Third round: (1) Own pick.
SS (Clemons)
Fourth round: (3) Three *compensatory picks due to free agent losses in 2016.
CB, CB, WR (best players available)
Fifth round: (3) Own pick, the Patriots' pick and a *compensatory pick due to free agent loss in 2016.
WR, RT, C. (Best players available)
Sixth round: (1) Own pick.
SS (Best player available)
Seventh round: (1) The Colts' pick.
FS (Best player available).
With that, you're shoring up your teams biggest weaknesses.
-
Not a bad take, but our OL is not as dire a situation as you have painted it.
And no to cutting Haden... there's not even a cap justification for the move. Change his role? Sure, but keep him and milk whatever he has left.
"When you have a shared vision it is a lot easier to make unpopular decisions." - Paul DePodesta "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." - Paul Brown Complete 2017 Browns Board Mock: http://thebrownsboard.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=46196 -
I like just about everything, but there will have to be an adjustment at QB. I'm not sure how or who, but we can't roll into next year with the same guys.
-
It's so funny seeing how all over the place everyone is with where qbs will go. 3 guys gone in the top 10? I would be surprised to see 3 go top 20
-
It's so funny seeing how all over the place everyone is with where qbs will go. 3 guys gone in the top 10? I would be surprised to see 3 go top 20
It's so funny seeing how all over the place everyone is with where qbs will go. 3 guys gone in the top 10? I would be surprised to see 3 go top 20
Who would be the third QB? Trubisky and Watson both go Top 10...maybe Top 5. At this point not sure any others would go first round.
Kizer?
Kaaya?
Kelly?
any other QB whose name begins with a K?
Possible?
-
Your score is: 10587 (GRADE: A-)
Your Picks:
Round 1 Pick 1: Myles Garrett, DE/OLB, Texas A&M (A+)
Round 1 Pick 12: Mitch Trubisky, QB, North Carolina (A-)
Round 2 Pick 1: Christian McCaffrey, RB, Stanford (A-)
Round 2 Pick 18: Marcus Williams, FS, Utah (A)
Round 3 Pick 1: Tyler Orlosky, C, West Virginia (A)
Round 4 Pick 1: Patrick Mahomes , QB, Texas Tech (A+)
Round 5 Pick 32: Daniel Carlson, K, Auburn (A+)
Round 6 Pick 1: Taywan Taylor, WR, Western Kentucky (A+)
the 3 comp picks at bottom of the 4th should be used on SS,CB,CB and the 5th comp pick should be on LB -
Your score is: 10587 (GRADE: A-)
Your Picks:
Round 1 Pick 1: Myles Garrett, DE/OLB, Texas A&M (A+)
Round 1 Pick 12: Mitch Trubisky, QB, North Carolina (A-)
Round 2 Pick 1: Christian McCaffrey, RB, Stanford (A-)
Round 2 Pick 18: Marcus Williams, FS, Utah (A)
Round 3 Pick 1: Tyler Orlosky, C, West Virginia (A)
Round 4 Pick 1: Patrick Mahomes , QB, Texas Tech (A+)
Round 5 Pick 32: Daniel Carlson, K, Auburn (A+)
Round 6 Pick 1: Taywan Taylor, WR, Western Kentucky (A+)
the 3 comp picks at bottom of the 4th should be used on SS,CB,CB and the 5th comp pick should be on LBYour score is: 10587 (GRADE: A-)
Your Picks:
Round 1 Pick 1: Myles Garrett, DE/OLB, Texas A&M (A+)
Round 1 Pick 12: Mitch Trubisky, QB, North Carolina (A-)
Round 2 Pick 1: Christian McCaffrey, RB, Stanford (A-)
Round 2 Pick 18: Marcus Williams, FS, Utah (A)
Round 3 Pick 1: Tyler Orlosky, C, West Virginia (A)
Round 4 Pick 1: Patrick Mahomes , QB, Texas Tech (A+)
Round 5 Pick 32: Daniel Carlson, K, Auburn (A+)
Round 6 Pick 1: Taywan Taylor, WR, Western Kentucky (A+)
the 3 comp picks at bottom of the 4th should be used on SS,CB,CB and the 5th comp pick should be on LB
Why take another QB. And why waste a pick on a kicker.
And there is one defensive player here. That would be absurd.
-
Your score is: 10587 (GRADE: A-)
Your Picks:
Round 1 Pick 1: Myles Garrett, DE/OLB, Texas A&M (A+)
Round 1 Pick 12: Mitch Trubisky, QB, North Carolina (A-)
Round 2 Pick 1: Christian McCaffrey, RB, Stanford (A-)
Round 2 Pick 18: Marcus Williams, FS, Utah (A)
Round 3 Pick 1: Tyler Orlosky, C, West Virginia (A)
Round 4 Pick 1: Patrick Mahomes , QB, Texas Tech (A+)
Round 5 Pick 32: Daniel Carlson, K, Auburn (A+)
Round 6 Pick 1: Taywan Taylor, WR, Western Kentucky (A+)
the 3 comp picks at bottom of the 4th should be used on SS,CB,CB and the 5th comp pick should be on LB
Why take another QB. And why waste a pick on a kicker.
And there is one defensive player here. That would be absurd.
Why take another QB. And why waste a pick on a kicker.
And there is one defensive player here. That would be absurd.
well i wanted to take a project QB with a comp pick but they are not represented on firstpick so i picked mahomes because he was there and has a live arm and is a great athlete good player to sit and learn for a few years.
We havent had a good kicker since Phil Dawson and we really need a good kicker which has been shown this year. 4 Secondary picks and 2 front seven picks.
1a. DE
1b. QB
2a. RB
2b. FS
3a. C
4a. QB
4b. SS
4c. CB
4d. CB
5a. K
5b. LB
6a. WR
Offense: 5 Defense: 6
plus the kicker
-
Why take another QB. And why waste a pick on a kicker.
And there is one defensive player here. That would be absurd.
well i wanted to take a project QB with a comp pick but they are not represented on firstpick so i picked mahomes because he was there and has a live arm and is a great athlete good player to sit and learn for a few years.
We havent had a good kicker since Phil Dawson and we really need a good kicker which has been shown this year. 4 Secondary picks and 2 front seven picks.
1a. DE
1b. QB
2a. RB
2b. FS
3a. C
4a. QB
4b. SS
4c. CB
4d. CB
5a. K
5b. LB
6a. WR
Offense: 5 Defense: 6
plus the kicker
well i wanted to take a project QB with a comp pick but they are not represented on firstpick so i picked mahomes because he was there and has a live arm and is a great athlete good player to sit and learn for a few years.
We havent had a good kicker since Phil Dawson and we really need a good kicker which has been shown this year. 4 Secondary picks and 2 front seven picks.
1a. DE
1b. QB
2a. RB
2b. FS
3a. C
4a. QB
4b. SS
4c. CB
4d. CB
5a. K
5b. LB
6a. WR
Offense: 5 Defense: 6
plus the kicker
Looks like you changed your story.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login