Skip to content
The Browns Board
  1. Home
  2. The Browns Board
  3. College Coaches Going To NFL

College Coaches Going To NFL

The Browns Board
12 6 464

  • IF Hue departs, which I seriously doubt, then his replacement is already in the coaches' room.

    "When you have a shared vision it is a lot easier to make unpopular decisions." - Paul DePodesta "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." - Paul Brown Complete 2017 Browns Board Mock: http://thebrownsboard.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=46196

  • Malzahn. Lol. Biggest redneck in the SEC. Should work well in Cleveland. 

  • Really hard transition since most successful college coaches are either running a system that isn't close to a NFL system, their team's talent much better than 90% of their competition and they are task masters that doesn't play in the NFL.

  • Most college coaches, I believe, don't fit.

    See:  Chip Kelly.    Nick Saban.  Steve Spurrier.

    Some few may.   Harbaugh, Carroll.    Most. Not.

  • The GipperT The Gipper

    Most college coaches, I believe, don't fit.

    See:  Chip Kelly.    Nick Saban.  Steve Spurrier.

    Some few may.   Harbaugh, Carroll.    Most. Not.

    @the-gipper said:

    Most college coaches, I believe, don't fit.

    See:  Chip Kelly.    Nick Saban.  Steve Spurrier.

    Some few may.   Harbaugh, Carroll.    Most. Not.

    What about Butch Davis? I always considered him to be a real good game day coach. GM...not so much. Talent wise though, he won with smoke and mirrors......like a good football coach should

  • flyingfooldougF flyingfooldoug

    @the-gipper said:

    Most college coaches, I believe, don't fit.

    See:  Chip Kelly.    Nick Saban.  Steve Spurrier.

    Some few may.   Harbaugh, Carroll.    Most. Not.

    What about Butch Davis? I always considered him to be a real good game day coach. GM...not so much. Talent wise though, he won with smoke and mirrors......like a good football coach should

    @flyingfooldoug said:

    What about Butch Davis? I always considered him to be a real good game day coach. GM...not so much. Talent wise though, he won with smoke and mirrors......like a good football coach should

    Well....I don't know how well Butch did with his college gigs once he left here.   He coached North Carolina I believe.

    And, in checking, he left there in like 2010 after 3-4 years...and since 2010 his only job in football was as an "advisor" to the Tampa Bay Bucs...whatever that means.

    Until this year when he took the HC job at Florida Internation Univ.   

    Quite a downgrade, fair to say?

  • The GipperT The Gipper

    @flyingfooldoug said:

    What about Butch Davis? I always considered him to be a real good game day coach. GM...not so much. Talent wise though, he won with smoke and mirrors......like a good football coach should

    Well....I don't know how well Butch did with his college gigs once he left here.   He coached North Carolina I believe.

    And, in checking, he left there in like 2010 after 3-4 years...and since 2010 his only job in football was as an "advisor" to the Tampa Bay Bucs...whatever that means.

    Until this year when he took the HC job at Florida Internation Univ.   

    Quite a downgrade, fair to say?

    @the-gipper said:

    Well....I don't know how well Butch did with his college gigs once he left here.   He coached North Carolina I believe.

    And, in checking, he left there in like 2010 after 3-4 years...and since 2010 his only job in football was as an "advisor" to the Tampa Bay Bucs...whatever that means.

    Until this year when he took the HC job at Florida Internation Univ.   

    Quite a downgrade, fair to say?

    Or enjoying the easy life. He did pretty well at NC but got run out over academics. He got paid handsomely there too. Downgrade? Maybe it's a choice. But he did coach the best years we had since 99.   Hue seems to coach like Romeo and look like Fester.  Gotta dig deep to find anything fun about this team.

  • Well, from my view, Butch had the best potential of any HC we have had since '99.  

    But....here again, Front Office dysfunction caused him to have to take over both the HC and GM position.    Part of that dysfunction was of course the death of Al Lerner....and the resignation of Carmen Policy.   Ergo...you had Randy Lerner steering the ship.......and his navigational skills were just a step below Gilligan's.  That is why Butch had to step in and become the overall Skipper. And while he may have made a fine Ship's Captain......he sucked as the Commodore of the fleet. 

    No Oliver Hazard Perry was he.   He was just the "Hazard".

  • The GipperT The Gipper

    Well, from my view, Butch had the best potential of any HC we have had since '99.  

    But....here again, Front Office dysfunction caused him to have to take over both the HC and GM position.    Part of that dysfunction was of course the death of Al Lerner....and the resignation of Carmen Policy.   Ergo...you had Randy Lerner steering the ship.......and his navigational skills were just a step below Gilligan's.  That is why Butch had to step in and become the overall Skipper. And while he may have made a fine Ship's Captain......he sucked as the Commodore of the fleet. 

    No Oliver Hazard Perry was he.   He was just the "Hazard".

    @the-gipper said:

    Well, from my view, Butch had the best potential of any HC we have had since '99.  

    But....here again, Front Office dysfunction caused him to have to take over both the HC and GM position.    Part of that dysfunction was of course the death of Al Lerner....and the resignation of Carmen Policy.   Ergo...you had Randy Lerner steering the ship.......and his navigational skills were just a step below Gilligan's.  That is why Butch had to step in and become the overall Skipper. And while he may have made a fine Ship's Captain......he sucked as the Commodore of the fleet. 

    No Oliver Hazard Perry was he.   He was just the "Hazard"

     Ya, GM was too much for him. And it wasn't his fault Manning tanked a game that cost us a playoff spot. 10-6 and sat home.

  • Of course, one "College" coach that went into pro football did pretty well:

    Paul Brown

    How many coaches have ever won both a College National Championships AND a pro football title?

    PB

    Jimmy Johnson

    Barry Switzer

    Pete Carroll

    Others that came close:

    finger Vermeil....won SB....had success at UCLA...finished in like Top 5 in nation a couple of times

    John Robinson....won College National Championship.....and also coached the Rams in two NFC Championship games...but did not win.

    Bobby Ross....won a share of a National Championship...at Georgia Tech.   Also led the San Diego Chargers to their only Super Bowl appearance.

    John McKay....won a couple of National titles with USC....and though famous for the 0-26 start of the Tampa Bay Bucs.....he did get that team into the NFC Championship game just a couple of years later in 1979.

    Think about Bud Grant.....coached the Vikings to 4 Super Bowls...no wins.   But did win a Grey Cup in the CFL.

    Anyone else?

Log in to reply