Garoppolo
-
Shoulda...woulda....coulda...
We should've drafted a lot of players.
-
Shoulda...woulda....coulda...
We should've drafted a lot of players.
The list of guys we shoulda, coulda drafted since 1999 is as long as my arm. I was probably wrong and Jimmy- and if he pans out, I'll admit I'm wrong. But to give a guy $$$$ and declare him a "franchise qb"after 7 starts is a tad premature.
The 49ers better hope he's not another Derek Anderson. Plenty of chatter on nfl.com to tag Jimmy in 2018, and then give him the long term contract the following year.
-
Foles earned the right to sit in Philly a year & never have to buy 1 Dinner with Drinks.. AJ McCarron just had a wet dream counting his last $690K salary..Just say "No Way" to Hue & Jimmy Dorsey.. So now what is AJ worth? Dalton sits a 16M same with Glennon at Bears..
-
We should have drafted him. He just got a huge contract from his new team
wow.
https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/02/08/ex-49ers-qbs-current-teammates-rejoice-at-garoppolo-deal/
We should have drafted him. He just got a huge contract from his new team
wow.
https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/02/08/ex-49ers-qbs-current-teammates-rejoice-at-garoppolo-deal/
Maybe yes and maybe no.
There is now some film on Jimmy to study this 2018 off season. Not a lot, but more than than defenses had to break down prior to this last season. The 2nd and 3rd years of a QB are where the rubber meets the road. Bradys 2nd season he struggled because Marty Schottenhiemer figured out that if you could pressure Brady to move from his spot that he was less effective. The Chargers won. The 2002 San Diego vs NE game was early in the season and then every NFL defense tried to copy what the Chargers did. NE missed the playoffs.
Every QB has strengths and weaknesses. Things that he excels at and things that he is not good at. His favorite go to plays and his least favorite plays. NFL teams are going to work this off season and breakdown Garrapolis tendencies and figure what he likes and then take it away.
-
Shoulda...woulda....coulda...
We should've drafted a lot of players.
The list of guys we shoulda, coulda drafted since 1999 is as long as my arm. I was probably wrong and Jimmy- and if he pans out, I'll admit I'm wrong. But to give a guy $$$$ and declare him a "franchise qb"after 7 starts is a tad premature.
The 49ers better hope he's not another Derek Anderson. Plenty of chatter on nfl.com to tag Jimmy in 2018, and then give him the long term contract the following year.
The list of guys we shoulda, coulda drafted since 1999 is as long as my arm. I was probably wrong and Jimmy- and if he pans out, I'll admit I'm wrong. But to give a guy $$$$ and declare him a "franchise qb"after 7 starts is a tad premature.
The 49ers better hope he's not another Derek Anderson. Plenty of chatter on nfl.com to tag Jimmy in 2018, and then give him the long term contract the following year.
Derek Carr was supposed to be a world beater. Cam Newton was Superman.
Everybody is so fast to name this guy the next Joe Montana and that guy the next Randy Moss after a season or two.
-
Yes, it is a no-brainer to say we should have drafted him over Johnny.
But what we really should have done is traded for him. Before last year. When we could get him in there for a year before the contract was due. I think I had about 100 page thread about it. We deiced to do nothing and bank on a 21 year old second rounder instead. And then when we realized the consequences of that, we were passed over by NE for Grop and made a lame attempt at McCarron that failed.
That's why Sashi isn't here. Because of Wentz, Watson, the Grop trade and the failed McCarron trade.
But hopefully this bullshit is over. In Dorsey We Trust.
Zombo
-
Yes, it is a no-brainer to say we should have drafted him over Johnny.
But what we really should have done is traded for him. Before last year. When we could get him in there for a year before the contract was due. I think I had about 100 page thread about it. We deiced to do nothing and bank on a 21 year old second rounder instead. And then when we realized the consequences of that, we were passed over by NE for Grop and made a lame attempt at McCarron that failed.
That's why Sashi isn't here. Because of Wentz, Watson, the Grop trade and the failed McCarron trade.
But hopefully this bullshit is over. In Dorsey We Trust.
Zombo
Zombo said:
Yes, it is a no-brainer to say we should have drafted him over Johnny.
But what we really should have done is traded for him. Before last year. When we could get him in there for a year before the contract was due. I think I had about 100 page thread about it. We deiced to do nothing and bank on a 21 year old second rounder instead. And then when we realized the consequences of that, we were passed over by NE for Grop and made a lame attempt at McCarron that failed.
That's why Sashi isn't here. Because of Wentz, Watson, the Grop trade and the failed McCarron trade.
But hopefully this cowpoop is over. In Dorsey We Trust.
Zombo
I'll keep saying it over and over again. I don't think Sashi is the one to blame for the Garoppolo trade.
If you do what all the league considers logic at one point, then how could you be blamed? We offered a 2nd round, IIRC, and NOBODY thought that we should have offered more.
We drafted Kizer as a plan B. And I'm not angry because Trubisky doesn't look very good, Watson has confirmed the injury concerns and we haven't seen Mahomes yet.
-
Zombo said:
Yes, it is a no-brainer to say we should have drafted him over Johnny.
But what we really should have done is traded for him. Before last year. When we could get him in there for a year before the contract was due. I think I had about 100 page thread about it. We deiced to do nothing and bank on a 21 year old second rounder instead. And then when we realized the consequences of that, we were passed over by NE for Grop and made a lame attempt at McCarron that failed.
That's why Sashi isn't here. Because of Wentz, Watson, the Grop trade and the failed McCarron trade.
But hopefully this cowpoop is over. In Dorsey We Trust.
Zombo
I'll keep saying it over and over again. I don't think Sashi is the one to blame for the Garoppolo trade.
If you do what all the league considers logic at one point, then how could you be blamed? We offered a 2nd round, IIRC, and NOBODY thought that we should have offered more.
We drafted Kizer as a plan B. And I'm not angry because Trubisky doesn't look very good, Watson has confirmed the injury concerns and we haven't seen Mahomes yet.
I'll keep saying it over and over again. I don't think Sashi is the one to blame for the Garoppolo trade.
If you do what all the league considers logic at one point, then how could you be blamed? We offered a 2nd round, IIRC, and NOBODY thought that we should have offered more.
We drafted Kizer as a plan B. And I'm not angry because Trubisky doesn't look very good, Watson has confirmed the injury concerns and we haven't seen Mahomes yet.
Did we offer a 2nd before the draft last year? Because that's what I'm talking about. I would have given up our second first rounder for him last year, it's on record. But we parlayed that into a safety that plays 30 yards off the ball, so we're good.
Zombo
-
I'll keep saying it over and over again. I don't think Sashi is the one to blame for the Garoppolo trade.
If you do what all the league considers logic at one point, then how could you be blamed? We offered a 2nd round, IIRC, and NOBODY thought that we should have offered more.
We drafted Kizer as a plan B. And I'm not angry because Trubisky doesn't look very good, Watson has confirmed the injury concerns and we haven't seen Mahomes yet.
Did we offer a 2nd before the draft last year? Because that's what I'm talking about. I would have given up our second first rounder for him last year, it's on record. But we parlayed that into a safety that plays 30 yards off the ball, so we're good.
Zombo
Zombo said:
Did we offer a 2nd before the draft last year? Because that's what I'm talking about. I would have given up our second first rounder for him last year, it's on record. But we parlayed that into a safety that plays 30 yards off the ball, so we're good.
Zombo
Well, had it gone wrong today we would be saying why the heck did we trade Garoppolo for a 1st round.
It can go both ways and if you make a reasonable decision (not risking a 1st) you shouldn't be blamed for it.
-
Zombo said:
Did we offer a 2nd before the draft last year? Because that's what I'm talking about. I would have given up our second first rounder for him last year, it's on record. But we parlayed that into a safety that plays 30 yards off the ball, so we're good.
Zombo
Well, had it gone wrong today we would be saying why the heck did we trade Garoppolo for a 1st round.
It can go both ways and if you make a reasonable decision (not risking a 1st) you shouldn't be blamed for it.
Well, had it gone wrong today we would be saying why the heck did we trade Garoppolo for a 1st round.
It can go both ways and if you make a reasonable decision (not risking a 1st) you shouldn't be blamed for it.
If you are the head of the organization and after two years your QB stable is Deshone Kizer, Cody Kessler and Kevin Hogan ... You should be blamed for it.
Zombo
-
Well, had it gone wrong today we would be saying why the heck did we trade Garoppolo for a 1st round.
It can go both ways and if you make a reasonable decision (not risking a 1st) you shouldn't be blamed for it.
If you are the head of the organization and after two years your QB stable is Deshone Kizer, Cody Kessler and Kevin Hogan ... You should be blamed for it.
Zombo
-
Zombo said:
If you are the head of the organization and after two years your QB stable is Deshone Kizer, Cody Kessler and Kevin Hogan ... You should be blamed for it.
Zombo
Of course. But I'm talking only about Jimmy Garoppolo here.
Of course. But I'm talking only about Jimmy Garoppolo here.
Sashi Brown's NFL gravemarker reads "passed on Wentz, passed on Watson, didn't ante up for Jimmy, couldn't beat the clock on A.J*, here lies 1-31"
I expect Dorsey to be WAY more aggressive when it comes to securing a franchise QB for the Cleveland Browns. If he goes down, he goes down swinging.
Zombo
*Not that I am any fan of McCarren, but the fact that he botched that trade was his final kiss of death
-
Of course. But I'm talking only about Jimmy Garoppolo here.
Sashi Brown's NFL gravemarker reads "passed on Wentz, passed on Watson, didn't ante up for Jimmy, couldn't beat the clock on A.J*, here lies 1-31"
I expect Dorsey to be WAY more aggressive when it comes to securing a franchise QB for the Cleveland Browns. If he goes down, he goes down swinging.
Zombo
*Not that I am any fan of McCarren, but the fact that he botched that trade was his final kiss of death
-
Of course. But I'm talking only about Jimmy Garoppolo here.
Sashi Brown's NFL gravemarker reads "passed on Wentz, passed on Watson, didn't ante up for Jimmy, couldn't beat the clock on A.J*, here lies 1-31"
I expect Dorsey to be WAY more aggressive when it comes to securing a franchise QB for the Cleveland Browns. If he goes down, he goes down swinging.
Zombo
*Not that I am any fan of McCarren, but the fact that he botched that trade was his final kiss of death
Zombo said:
Sashi Brown's NFL gravemarker reads "passed on Wentz, passed on Watson, didn't ante up for Jimmy, couldn't beat the clock on A.J*, here lies 1-31"
I expect Dorsey to be WAY more aggressive when it comes to securing a franchise QB for the Cleveland Browns. If he goes down, he goes down swinging.
Zombo
*Not that I am any fan of McCarren, but the fact that he botched that trade was his final kiss of death
You can also throw in the fact that Sashi couldn’t draft or bring in a WR worth a sh!t.
Two things that will define you: Your determination when you have nothing. Your attitude when you have everything. - Mike McCartney -
I think I read or heard that the Browns offered a 1st before the season and were turned down. Jimmy didn't want to go to Cleveland, and Belichick wasn't sending him out to somewhere he didn't want to be.
In the short time he has been on the field (and things could certainly change, he won't be UNDEFEATED forever), he has looked better than any of the FA QBs and better than rookies besides Watson who got hurt
-
Zombo said:
Sashi Brown's NFL gravemarker reads "passed on Wentz, passed on Watson, didn't ante up for Jimmy, couldn't beat the clock on A.J*, here lies 1-31"
I expect Dorsey to be WAY more aggressive when it comes to securing a franchise QB for the Cleveland Browns. If he goes down, he goes down swinging.
Zombo
*Not that I am any fan of McCarren, but the fact that he botched that trade was his final kiss of death
You can also throw in the fact that Sashi couldn’t draft or bring in a WR worth a sh!t.
You can also throw in the fact that Sashi couldn’t draft or bring in a WR worth a sh!t.
What? He brought in Britt, Bowe and "hands" Coleman! What more could you ask for?
-
Zombo said:
Sashi Brown's NFL gravemarker reads "passed on Wentz, passed on Watson, didn't reach for a 3 game starter 2nd round backup offering a #12 overall, couldn't beat the clock on A.J*, here lies 1-31"
FIFY.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login