5 Observations from "The Tie"
-
He won't last 13 quarters before he's hurt physically, and sooner than that mentally.
Tim Couch would like a word with you.
I completely agree. As bad as the offensive line looked yesterday, I'd prefer Baker not see the field for a good long time, preferably not till next season. Tim Couch is the perfect analogy.
I completely agree. As bad as the offensive line looked yesterday, I'd prefer Baker not see the field for a good long time, preferably not till next season. Tim Couch is the perfect analogy.
Or at least until the bye week this season for the final six games...
But I concur totally with the gist of what you are saying, for sure.
-
I'm sure it's been mentioned somewhere, but I haven't seen it, but I'm still beyond pissed about the penalty called on Garrett for his hit on Roethlisberger that gave the Steelers a first down and eventually their first touchdown of the day.
How exactly are you supposed to take down a 6'5, 240lb QB who has made a career of extending plays by not going down with arm tackles? Garrett hit him cleanly with his shoulder, wrapped him with his arms and drove through him... LIKE EVERY KID IN FOOTBALL HAS BEEN TAUGHT TO TACKLE SINCE THE BIRTH OF THE Shmucking SPORT.
-
I'm sure it's been mentioned somewhere, but I haven't seen it, but I'm still beyond pissed about the penalty called on Garrett for his hit on Roethlisberger that gave the Steelers a first down and eventually their first touchdown of the day.
How exactly are you supposed to take down a 6'5, 240lb QB who has made a career of extending plays by not going down with arm tackles? Garrett hit him cleanly with his shoulder, wrapped him with his arms and drove through him... LIKE EVERY KID IN FOOTBALL HAS BEEN TAUGHT TO TACKLE SINCE THE BIRTH OF THE Shmucking SPORT.
I'm sure it's been mentioned somewhere, but I haven't seen it, but I'm still beyond pissed about the penalty called on Garrett for his hit on Roethlisberger that gave the Steelers a first down and eventually their first touchdown of the day.
How exactly are you supposed to take down a 6'5, 240lb QB who has made a career of extending plays by not going down with arm tackles? Garrett hit him cleanly with his shoulder, wrapped him with his arms and drove through him... LIKE EVERY KID IN FOOTBALL HAS BEEN TAUGHT TO TACKLE SINCE THE BIRTH OF THE Shmucking SPORT.
The rule stinks but you have to adjust. You can’t keep getting them because the rule stinks.
-
I'm sure it's been mentioned somewhere, but I haven't seen it, but I'm still beyond pissed about the penalty called on Garrett for his hit on Roethlisberger that gave the Steelers a first down and eventually their first touchdown of the day.
How exactly are you supposed to take down a 6'5, 240lb QB who has made a career of extending plays by not going down with arm tackles? Garrett hit him cleanly with his shoulder, wrapped him with his arms and drove through him... LIKE EVERY KID IN FOOTBALL HAS BEEN TAUGHT TO TACKLE SINCE THE BIRTH OF THE Shmucking SPORT.
I'm sure it's been mentioned somewhere, but I haven't seen it, but I'm still beyond pissed about the penalty called on Garrett for his hit on Roethlisberger that gave the Steelers a first down and eventually their first touchdown of the day.
How exactly are you supposed to take down a 6'5, 240lb QB who has made a career of extending plays by not going down with arm tackles? Garrett hit him cleanly with his shoulder, wrapped him with his arms and drove through him... LIKE EVERY KID IN FOOTBALL HAS BEEN TAUGHT TO TACKLE SINCE THE BIRTH OF THE Shmucking SPORT.
While we're on the subject of penalties, what was the unnecessary roughness call on Gordon?
It was a running play...He blocked his man (If you could call it that) And then he shoved the guy to the ground . What did I miss ? It's still football right? You're allowed to knock people down!
-
I'm sure it's been mentioned somewhere, but I haven't seen it, but I'm still beyond pissed about the penalty called on Garrett for his hit on Roethlisberger that gave the Steelers a first down and eventually their first touchdown of the day.
How exactly are you supposed to take down a 6'5, 240lb QB who has made a career of extending plays by not going down with arm tackles? Garrett hit him cleanly with his shoulder, wrapped him with his arms and drove through him... LIKE EVERY KID IN FOOTBALL HAS BEEN TAUGHT TO TACKLE SINCE THE BIRTH OF THE Shmucking SPORT.
The rule stinks but you have to adjust. You can’t keep getting them because the rule stinks.
The rule stinks but you have to adjust. You can’t keep getting them because the rule stinks.
Nah the rule needs to go and will be reviewed. As has been said they also called it wrong and objectively cost the browns 4 points. Theres no way that can ever be a penalty in the nfl.
-
I thought the team missed Danny Shelton in a run stopping role. Really never understood his decision to trade him to NE
-
I thought the team missed Danny Shelton in a run stopping role. Really never understood his decision to trade him to NE
I thought the team missed Danny Shelton in a run stopping role. Really never understood his decision to trade him to NE
It really became a head-scratcher when young guys like Brantley and Meder - got cut the following training camp. I assumed Shelton was traded because the organization liked the younger and cheaper DTs they've gotten, but then they got rid of them too...
-
Nate don't like no ties. He thinks Mayfield would have won it.
-
No, I sound like someone who has watched the same shite for the last 5 years. Turning second and 3 into 3rd-and-we-can't-see-that-far. Defense makes a big play to get off the field and a stupid penalty gives the other team a first down inside the 5. A big turnover deep into opposing territory but a stupid penalty brings it back. You don't have to be a 5-year veteran to get the fukking snap count--two times in a row. You don't have to be a veteran to know not to block someone in the back.
Undisciplined play. Year after year.
Year after year tells you something. Us getting a different coach after 2 years is a big problem. We'll never have any consistency until we keep a coach around at least 5 years.
Year after year tells you something. Us getting a different coach after 2 years is a big problem. We'll never have any consistency until we keep a coach around at least 5 years.
I agree with this except that I would say we keep getting the WRONG coach. The Browns fall into the trap that a lot of teams that are searching for a coach fall into: hiring the 'hot' coordinator/assistant coach expecting that his qualities as an assistant will automatically transfer to head coaching success.
The list of successful coordinators who didn't make the transfer to successful head coach is long and not limited to: Lindy Infante, Richie Pettibone, Chris Palmer, pretty much everyone who has coached under Belicheck---and, I'm afraid, Hue. One notable exception is Bill Cowher. He succeeded Chuck Noll and you saw an immediate difference on the field. I'm talking attitude, disciplined play, 'stage presence', if you will. Cowher had a presence on the sidelines that the players responded to. I think back over the last several years in Cleveland and it's fukking depressing. Shurmer always looking like he was about to burst into tears every time the Browns committed a stupid penalty to kill a drive or give the other offense new life. Hue with that perplexed look on his face after every stupid penalty--"Uh, what just happened?"
For the first time in a long time I'm actually impressed with some of the talent we're putting on the field. But until we find 'our Cowher', someone who brings passion and who inspires the players... after Chud was fired after one season I remember several players were upset because they thought he was such a swell guy. The problem was that they quit on him a month before the season ended. We have to find that guy who will put the fear of god in players but who will also inspire them to run through a brick wall. Until then, I fear we're just spinning our wheels.
Edit: P.S. Several years ago I read an article about Bill Parcells. By that time he was with Dallas, I think. Keyshawn was one of his players at the time. One quote which stood out for me came from Phil Simms: "Football players want to be led, and Bill Parcells leads."
The Browns need a leader.
-
Nate don't like no ties. He thinks Mayfield would have won it.
Nate don't like no ties. He thinks Mayfield would have won it.
A QB playing in bad weather in his first NFL game behind an OLine that was a sieve would have ran away with a victory?
Hmmmm….
-
Ties
-
Nate don't like no ties. He thinks Mayfield would have won it.
A QB playing in bad weather in his first NFL game behind an OLine that was a sieve would have ran away with a victory?
Hmmmm….
A QB playing in bad weather in his first NFL game behind an OLine that was a sieve would have ran away with a victory?
Hmmmm….
I don't agree with him, but he is a former Browns player with an opinion. I said elsewhere that Baker needs to stay on the sidelines at least until this OL is fixed well enough to utilize his skills without getting hospitalized and out for the season. We need to thoroughly peruse other team's PS and any FA still left out there (if such an animal exists). Might help to stop playing musical chairs and actually coach whom we have. Wiley is totally unimpressive to me. Got to be a better OL coach out there somewhere.
-
I'm sure it's been mentioned somewhere, but I haven't seen it, but I'm still beyond pissed about the penalty called on Garrett for his hit on Roethlisberger that gave the Steelers a first down and eventually their first touchdown of the day.
How exactly are you supposed to take down a 6'5, 240lb QB who has made a career of extending plays by not going down with arm tackles? Garrett hit him cleanly with his shoulder, wrapped him with his arms and drove through him... LIKE EVERY KID IN FOOTBALL HAS BEEN TAUGHT TO TACKLE SINCE THE BIRTH OF THE Shmucking SPORT.
While we're on the subject of penalties, what was the unnecessary roughness call on Gordon?
It was a running play...He blocked his man (If you could call it that) And then he shoved the guy to the ground . What did I miss ? It's still football right? You're allowed to knock people down!
I don't start Baker 2 NOLA in that noisy dome vs. what was a very good D in 2017...
... but regardless of the outcome, if TT does not play well Week 2, then I start Baker the following Thursday... at home... vs. the Jets.
While we're on the subject of penalties, what was the unnecessary roughness call on Gordon?
It was a running play...He blocked his man (If you could call it that) And then he shoved the guy to the ground . What did I miss ? It's still football right? You're allowed to knock people down!
Block was late and far enough away from the end of the play that it was "unnecessary"... thus the name of the penalty.
Swap uniforms and we'd be calling it a "cheap shot".
I think JG was frustrated and took a shot at the source.
"When you have a shared vision it is a lot easier to make unpopular decisions." - Paul DePodesta "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." - Paul Brown Complete 2017 Browns Board Mock: http://thebrownsboard.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=46196 -
I don't start Baker 2 NOLA in that noisy dome vs. what was a very good D in 2017...
... but regardless of the outcome, if TT does not play well Week 2, then I start Baker the following Thursday... at home... vs. the Jets.
While we're on the subject of penalties, what was the unnecessary roughness call on Gordon?
It was a running play...He blocked his man (If you could call it that) And then he shoved the guy to the ground . What did I miss ? It's still football right? You're allowed to knock people down!
Block was late and far enough away from the end of the play that it was "unnecessary"... thus the name of the penalty.
Swap uniforms and we'd be calling it a "cheap shot".
I think JG was frustrated and took a shot at the source.
Block was late and far enough away from the end of the play that it was "unnecessary"... thus the name of the penalty.
Swap uniforms and we'd be calling it a "cheap shot".
I think JG was frustrated and took a shot at the source.
Still one of those calls that seems totally unnecessary. Considering a late hit on the actual receiver just a couple plays later went uncalled. Looked a lot like a flop by the Steelers defender as well, so good for him, he got the call.
-
He won't last 13 quarters before he's hurt physically, and sooner than that mentally.
Tim Couch would like a word with you.
I completely agree. As bad as the offensive line looked yesterday, I'd prefer Baker not see the field for a good long time, preferably not till next season. Tim Couch is the perfect analogy.
I completely agree. As bad as the offensive line looked yesterday, I'd prefer Baker not see the field for a good long time, preferably not till next season. Tim Couch is the perfect analogy.
This OL though is miles ahead of the OL that Couch played behind, even if they did not have a good game on Sunday.
-
Year after year tells you something. Us getting a different coach after 2 years is a big problem. We'll never have any consistency until we keep a coach around at least 5 years.
I agree with this except that I would say we keep getting the WRONG coach. The Browns fall into the trap that a lot of teams that are searching for a coach fall into: hiring the 'hot' coordinator/assistant coach expecting that his qualities as an assistant will automatically transfer to head coaching success.
The list of successful coordinators who didn't make the transfer to successful head coach is long and not limited to: Lindy Infante, Richie Pettibone, Chris Palmer, pretty much everyone who has coached under Belicheck---and, I'm afraid, Hue. One notable exception is Bill Cowher. He succeeded Chuck Noll and you saw an immediate difference on the field. I'm talking attitude, disciplined play, 'stage presence', if you will. Cowher had a presence on the sidelines that the players responded to. I think back over the last several years in Cleveland and it's fukking depressing. Shurmer always looking like he was about to burst into tears every time the Browns committed a stupid penalty to kill a drive or give the other offense new life. Hue with that perplexed look on his face after every stupid penalty--"Uh, what just happened?"
For the first time in a long time I'm actually impressed with some of the talent we're putting on the field. But until we find 'our Cowher', someone who brings passion and who inspires the players... after Chud was fired after one season I remember several players were upset because they thought he was such a swell guy. The problem was that they quit on him a month before the season ended. We have to find that guy who will put the fear of god in players but who will also inspire them to run through a brick wall. Until then, I fear we're just spinning our wheels.
Edit: P.S. Several years ago I read an article about Bill Parcells. By that time he was with Dallas, I think. Keyshawn was one of his players at the time. One quote which stood out for me came from Phil Simms: "Football players want to be led, and Bill Parcells leads."
The Browns need a leader.
I agree with this except that I would say we keep getting the WRONG coach. The Browns fall into the trap that a lot of teams that are searching for a coach fall into: hiring the 'hot' coordinator/assistant coach expecting that his qualities as an assistant will automatically transfer to head coaching success.
The list of successful coordinators who didn't make the transfer to successful head coach is long and not limited to: Lindy Infante, Richie Pettibone, Chris Palmer, pretty much everyone who has coached under Belicheck---and, I'm afraid, Hue. One notable exception is Bill Cowher. He succeeded Chuck Noll and you saw an immediate difference on the field.
Yes, Bill Cowher succeeded Chuck Noll. But lets think about this. How many head coaches did the steelers have since Noll? Two. Noll had a system that he ran with success. Cowher and Tomlin came in and followed that pattern. Both won Superbowls. Neither could come into Cleveland and win one here without time to build the team (at least 5 years). Hue might not be the coach to do this in Cleveland, but until you give him time, you will never find out. Romeo Crennel had 5 year I believe, but we know he was not the guy. So, how many head coaches have we had in Cleveland since '99 other than Romeo? Coaches need time to build and organization. Until we give them time, I'll be on this board saying the same thing.
-
I think we need to start Baker and I've thought so since the preseason. I think Tyrod is a solid QB in the right offense but Haley doesn't play to his strengths. We won't be able to run a consistent offense unless we get Tyrod out of the pocket and making more easy reads. Bottom line he holds on to the ball too long looking for his receiver to get open instead of trusting his man to be in the right spot. He drink and dunked all through the preseason and it's pretty much what he did in this game with a handful of of shots that looked like he knew where he was going with the ball before the snap.
Kirksey is kind of trash. Hes not bad against the run but he can't cover. The play with James and the long gain by Juju were because he didn't make a play. If we didn't just give him a huge payday I would say put him on the trade block and start Burgess.
I think we need to start Baker and I've thought so since the preseason. I think Tyrod is a solid QB in the right offense but Haley doesn't play to his strengths.
After 1 game this is really what you think? Especially with the Steelers constantly bringing pressure? Do really think Baker could've avoided the blitz as well as Taylor and made better throws under constant pressure? I admit there were some throws that I thought Baker could've made better than Tyrod, but putting him the game so early spells disaster. If he fails, then we're right back to where we started. I might be the only one on this board who wants Tyrod to start all games and let Baker learn. Of course, if we lose the next 5 games, then of course we need to start Baker. I don't see that happening especially with this D. And considering we won't see the Pittsburg D through most of the remaing games, we should be able to get the ball to our receivers. And don't forget that Gordon wasn't even with the team through preseason. This was basically his first preseason game. His game will improve.
-
I think we need to start Baker and I've thought so since the preseason. I think Tyrod is a solid QB in the right offense but Haley doesn't play to his strengths.
After 1 game this is really what you think? Especially with the Steelers constantly bringing pressure? Do really think Baker could've avoided the blitz as well as Taylor and made better throws under constant pressure? I admit there were some throws that I thought Baker could've made better than Tyrod, but putting him the game so early spells disaster. If he fails, then we're right back to where we started. I might be the only one on this board who wants Tyrod to start all games and let Baker learn. Of course, if we lose the next 5 games, then of course we need to start Baker. I don't see that happening especially with this D. And considering we won't see the Pittsburg D through most of the remaing games, we should be able to get the ball to our receivers. And don't forget that Gordon wasn't even with the team through preseason. This was basically his first preseason game. His game will improve.
After 1 game this is really what you think? Especially with the Steelers constantly bringing pressure? Do really think Baker could've avoided the blitz as well as Taylor and made better throws under constant pressure? I admit there were some throws that I thought Baker could've made better than Tyrod, but putting him the game so early spells disaster. If he fails, then we're right back to where we started. I might be the only one on this board who wants Tyrod to start all games and let Baker learn. Of course, if we lose the next 5 games, then of course we need to start Baker. I don't see that happening especially with this D. And considering we won't see the Pittsburg D through most of the remaing games, we should be able to get the ball to our receivers. And don't forget that Gordon wasn't even with the team through preseason. This was basically his first preseason game. His game will improve.
Yes after 1 game and all preseason. Tyrod is slow to react and is dumping the ball off. It's his first year in this offense just like the rookie. Baker has shown the ability to hit guys with timing and in stride at all 3 levels.
Baker also knows how to manipulate the pocket, which is what separate the men from the boys at the QB position. As long as there isn't a free rusher Mayfield can dance around in phone booth and make his offensive line look good.
I think Baker is mentally tough enough to take the lumps right now and I'm not concerned about getting him hurt, its football. Baker just needs seasoning.
-
After 1 game this is really what you think? Especially with the Steelers constantly bringing pressure? Do really think Baker could've avoided the blitz as well as Taylor and made better throws under constant pressure? I admit there were some throws that I thought Baker could've made better than Tyrod, but putting him the game so early spells disaster. If he fails, then we're right back to where we started. I might be the only one on this board who wants Tyrod to start all games and let Baker learn. Of course, if we lose the next 5 games, then of course we need to start Baker. I don't see that happening especially with this D. And considering we won't see the Pittsburg D through most of the remaing games, we should be able to get the ball to our receivers. And don't forget that Gordon wasn't even with the team through preseason. This was basically his first preseason game. His game will improve.
Yes after 1 game and all preseason. Tyrod is slow to react and is dumping the ball off. It's his first year in this offense just like the rookie. Baker has shown the ability to hit guys with timing and in stride at all 3 levels.
Baker also knows how to manipulate the pocket, which is what separate the men from the boys at the QB position. As long as there isn't a free rusher Mayfield can dance around in phone booth and make his offensive line look good.
I think Baker is mentally tough enough to take the lumps right now and I'm not concerned about getting him hurt, its football. Baker just needs seasoning.
Tyrod is slow to react and is dumping the ball off.
Would it interest you to know that TT had the highest percentage of passes over 20 yards in week 1?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login