Who gets Rookie of the week?

Ibleedbrown

Nick Chubb or Baker Mayfield?

Chubb 20 carries, 176 yards, 1 td.

Mayfield 17/20, 216 yards, and 3 tds.

Mark O

@ibleedbrown said:

Nick Chubb or Baker Mayfield?

Chubb 20 carries, 176 yards, 1 td.

Mayfield 17/20, 216 yards, and 3 tds.

Chubb

calfoxwc

@ibleedbrown said:

Nick Chubb or Baker Mayfield?

Chubb 20 carries, 176 yards, 1 td.

Mayfield 17/20, 216 yards, and 3 tds.

Nick Chubb's turn. but tough question.

On my one fantasy football team, I got 28.64 points with starting Mayfield !

and I got 35.90 points from Chubb !

Dang, I'm a genius !

except in the other league, I didn't start Mayfield or Wilson, but started...Dalton who got me 6 pts.

I'm an idiot at the same time. LOL

TexasAg1969

The record setter has to get the nod this week. Chubb!

Orion

A tie. But Chubb setting a record breaks the tie.

Canton Mike

@orion said:

A tie. But Chubb setting a record breaks the tie.

Agree. Two great performances for sure.

Mike

Dutch Oven

@orion said:

A tie. But Chubb setting a record breaks the tie.

Then again, Mayfield practically had a perfect day in QB rating, didn't he?

Watch Saquon run for 300 yards and 4 touchdowns tomorrow night to make it a moo point. ?

LBC mike

Chubb

flyingfooldoug

Rookie of the week? Gotta be Kitchens!

MLD Woody

Baker was more impressive

domcucch1994

It's a coin toss...

But I would say Chubb gets it.

gumby73

The popular vote may go to Mayfield? But Jim Donovan's radio call may put "Chubb-a-lub-a-hub" over the top..My vote goes to Chubb for his all day trucking forward performance..

Ibleedbrown

http://www.nfl.com/voting/rookies/2018/REG/8

A Browns player has taken the honor 6 out of 9 weeks so far. Mayfield thrice, Ward twice and Chubb once. Chubb probably deserves another.

Zombo

I'm just gonna vote five times for each of them and let the chips fall where they may ... http://www.nfl.com/voting/rookies/2018/REG/11

jiggins7919

Wow, no clue. How fun is THIS quandary? hahahaha!

At first, I would say Baker Mayfield. He literally didn't miss a single pass in the first half, and not only that, but he didn't have a ball that was really difficult for his guys to catch. Baker was hitting his receivers in stride. One of the BIGGEST reasons I was excited about Baker was his ability to hit people in stride, and we all knew our YAC would increase when he took over. Remember last year with Kizer? Even when he completed some decent balls, too often our guys had to dive, or jump backwards, or whatever. Rarely did we see our receivers running after we caught it. Now? A different story.

That being said, Chubb was simply an animal. And you know what? He's showing us that he can learn how to catch the ball, something he was never asked to do. It's easy to look at his amazing rushing numbers, but Chubb had some very big receptions, one that went for a score on an incredibly well-designed play.

Give it to Chubb. That 92 yard run was something special. Man, it felt so good to run around and cheer Sunday. Big plays on offense, defense, and an entertaining performance by our team.

mjp28

@dutch-oven said:

Then again, Mayfield practically had a perfect day in QB rating, didn't he?

Watch Saquon run for 300 yards and 4 touchdowns tomorrow night to make it a moo point. ?

Yeah the Cleveland icons Graham, Sipe, Plum......Mayfield? WHOA.

........oh on the NY bunch how did they win the game?

jrb12711

Mayfield had the "stronger" day, but Chubb had the flash. It's his to lose.

ATOM

speaking of chubb how's the other one been doing in denver (you know the one all the media said we should have drafted)

The Gipper

@atom said:

speaking of chubb how's the other one been doing in denver (you know the one all the media said we should have drafted)

I didn't look up his stats, but I heard he is doing pretty well. He has like 6-8 sacks on the season.

Canton Dawg

Nick Chubb.

First player with 3 TD runs of 40+ in a single season since Adrian Peterson in 2015.