Skip to content

who would be your choice?

The Browns Board
47 25 2.0k 1
  • MLD WoodyM MLD Woody wrote on last edited by
    #25

    Keep Williams as HC

    Keep Kitchens as OC

    FIRE ANUS

  • Keep Williams as HC

    Keep Kitchens as OC

    FIRE ANUS

    W Westside Steve wrote on last edited by
    #26

    @mld-woody said:

    Keep Williams as HC

    Keep Kitchens as OC

    FIRE ANUS

    Isn't that a condition you get from eating too much roughage and hot sauce?

    WSS

  • Bob806B Bob806 wrote on last edited by
    #27

    I think it's up to Williams and his attitude in an interview.

    Maybe he doesn't want the HC job. If he really does, and they don't offer it, he walks away. 

  • I think it's up to Williams and his attitude in an interview.

    Maybe he doesn't want the HC job. If he really does, and they don't offer it, he walks away. 

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #28

    @bob806 said:

    I think it's up to Williams and his attitude in an interview.

    Maybe he doesn't want the HC job. If he really does, and they don't offer it, he walks away. 

    Pretty much.

    He's either getting the head coach job or he's gone. There's no way they could keep him around, because that would make for an awkward locker room dynamic. 

  • @bob806 said:

    I think it's up to Williams and his attitude in an interview.

    Maybe he doesn't want the HC job. If he really does, and they don't offer it, he walks away. 

    Pretty much.

    He's either getting the head coach job or he's gone. There's no way they could keep him around, because that would make for an awkward locker room dynamic. 

    Bob806B Bob806 wrote on last edited by
    #29

    @dutch-oven said:

    Pretty much.

    He's either getting the head coach job or he's gone. There's no way they could keep him around, because that would make for an awkward locker room dynamic. 

    Agree. Weird thing is he might actually not care about the prestige/money involved in being  a HC. 

    Maybe he'd stay and make a modest pay raise as DC if offered it

  • @dutch-oven said:

    Pretty much.

    He's either getting the head coach job or he's gone. There's no way they could keep him around, because that would make for an awkward locker room dynamic. 

    Agree. Weird thing is he might actually not care about the prestige/money involved in being  a HC. 

    Maybe he'd stay and make a modest pay raise as DC if offered it

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #30

    @bob806 said:

    Agree. Weird thing is he might actually not care about the prestige/money involved in being  a HC. 

    Maybe he'd stay and make a modest pay raise as DC if offered it

    I can't see a situation where Dorsey doesn't give Williams the job but he's kept as DC.

    Wouldn't be really fair to the new head coach to have the guy (Williams) some of the players in the locker room wished was given the HC job still in the room. 

  • @bob806 said:

    Agree. Weird thing is he might actually not care about the prestige/money involved in being  a HC. 

    Maybe he'd stay and make a modest pay raise as DC if offered it

    I can't see a situation where Dorsey doesn't give Williams the job but he's kept as DC.

    Wouldn't be really fair to the new head coach to have the guy (Williams) some of the players in the locker room wished was given the HC job still in the room. 

    W Westside Steve wrote on last edited by
    #31

    @dutch-oven said:

    I can't see a situation where Dorsey doesn't give Williams the job but he's kept as DC.

    Wouldn't be really fair to the new head coach to have the guy (Williams) some of the players in the locker room wished was given the HC job still in the room. 

    That makes sense. So let's hope he just leaves things where they are. Keep in mind that all the head coach candidates are doing something other than working as head coaches for a reason.

    WSS

  • @dutch-oven said:

    I can't see a situation where Dorsey doesn't give Williams the job but he's kept as DC.

    Wouldn't be really fair to the new head coach to have the guy (Williams) some of the players in the locker room wished was given the HC job still in the room. 

    That makes sense. So let's hope he just leaves things where they are. Keep in mind that all the head coach candidates are doing something other than working as head coaches for a reason.

    WSS

    jcam222J jcam222 wrote on last edited by
    #32

    @westside-steve said:

    That makes sense. So let's hope he just leaves things where they are. Keep in mind that all the head coach candidates are doing something other than working as head coaches for a reason.

    WSS

    Don’t forget a large part of that reason is simply lack of job openings. The only concern with leaving it how it is today is potential to lose Kitchens if someone offers him the HC gig. 

  • B Bigalow80 wrote on last edited by
    #33

    This is a really interesting article. Obviously there is some conjecture placed into it, but it makes a lot of really good points. I'm not totally sold on the fact that Dorsey had no input on Williams becoming the interim HC. That seems like a stretch to say that DePodesta has THAT much influence over coaching personnel. I for one believe, if such was the case, Dorsey would have stepped down. He's a control freak, which is what got him in trouble in KC. I think in the end it comes down to Greg Williams. How long does he plan on coaching? Is he willing to mentor Kitchens as the future HC of this team? if so, does that put the browns in a position similar to what happened to Tampa and Lovie Smith & Dirk Koeter? All valid reasons for potentially bringing in some young gun such as Lincoln Riley. If that happens, how much of the staff does he keep and if Williams is on the staff, how much chaos does that bring? My only hope is that Jimmer has very little input. 

    https://sports.yahoo.com/gregg-williams-right-browns-coach-baker-mayfield-024313965.html

  • @westside-steve said:

    That makes sense. So let's hope he just leaves things where they are. Keep in mind that all the head coach candidates are doing something other than working as head coaches for a reason.

    WSS

    Don’t forget a large part of that reason is simply lack of job openings. The only concern with leaving it how it is today is potential to lose Kitchens if someone offers him the HC gig. 

    W Westside Steve wrote on last edited by
    #34

    @jcam222 said:

    Don’t forget a large part of that reason is simply lack of job openings. The only concern with leaving it how it is today is potential to lose Kitchens if someone offers him the HC gig. 

    That could happen no matter what we do. Probably Williams as well with his experience and current success.

    WSS

  • @jcam222 said:

    Don’t forget a large part of that reason is simply lack of job openings. The only concern with leaving it how it is today is potential to lose Kitchens if someone offers him the HC gig. 

    That could happen no matter what we do. Probably Williams as well with his experience and current success.

    WSS

    jcam222J jcam222 wrote on last edited by
    #35

    @westside-steve said:

    That could happen no matter what we do. Probably Williams as well with his experience and current success.

    WSS

    Yep, I was alluding to the fact it might be impossible to keep them both. They might both have HC opportunities 

  • @westside-steve said:

    That could happen no matter what we do. Probably Williams as well with his experience and current success.

    WSS

    Yep, I was alluding to the fact it might be impossible to keep them both. They might both have HC opportunities 

    W Westside Steve wrote on last edited by Westside Steve
    #36

    @jcam222 said:

    Yep, I was alluding to the fact it might be impossible to keep them both. They might both have HC opportunities 

    Could be. I'd be surprised if somebody was bold enough to pick up Freddy after a half a season as OC but stranger things have happened. I wouldn't think coach Williams would be happy with a demotion. So give William the head coaching job and promote Freddy to assistant head coach in charge of the offense.

    WSS

  • T Tacosman wrote on last edited by
    #37

    Lets thank williams for a job well done even if we lose sunday and go with a new HC.  We have an incredibly attractive opening and we can leverage that.  Bounty hunter, while a nice story(especially if he gets to 8-7-1) is not where we need to go with the opening we have.  As for OC and DC, a lot of it depends on the new HC.  Obviously it needs to be someone the HC wants and works well with.  

  • TopDawg31T TopDawg31 wrote on last edited by
    #38

    For me, I think McCarthy is the most qualified. Whoever Dorsey selects will be fine by me. I'm not jumping on the GW and Kitchens are the saviors. Good teams made them both look clueless. Against sub .500 teams they look like world beaters. Beat the hell out of Baltimore on Sunday and I could buy in.

  • For me, I think McCarthy is the most qualified. Whoever Dorsey selects will be fine by me. I'm not jumping on the GW and Kitchens are the saviors. Good teams made them both look clueless. Against sub .500 teams they look like world beaters. Beat the hell out of Baltimore on Sunday and I could buy in.

    jcam222J jcam222 wrote on last edited by
    #39

    @topdawg31 said:

    For me, I think McCarthy is the most qualified. Whoever Dorsey selects will be fine by me. I'm not jumping on the GW and Kitchens are the saviors. Good teams made them both look clueless. Against sub .500 teams they look like world beaters. Beat the hell out of Baltimore on Sunday and I could buy in.

    Speaking of buy in, the players have and that’s damn important. I stand by the fact these guys have made an amazing turn around and there is not need to start over yet again with a new playbook

  • flyingfooldougF flyingfooldoug wrote on last edited by
    #40

    Regardless of the raisins score, we have witnessed the greatest turnaround in Cleveland Browns history. Told to take charge, school the QB and win games, Greg Williams has done much more than most of us could have wildly imagined. How do you break that up? I mean really. Ariens? Ready to collapse. We got a good thing going here. And after learning much more about Williams ....keep him and the staff minus special teams coaching. They can do better there. 

    The leagues Black Monday should sound like this in Cleveland 

    Cha-Ching!!

  • T TexasAg1969 wrote on last edited by
    #41

    Watch the full Cincy game and try to tell Dorsey to break this up with new coaching. Just can't happen.

  • darren15D darren15 wrote on last edited by
    #42

    If Williams is to become HC do you promote a DC from within or go get one ?

  • If Williams is to become HC do you promote a DC from within or go get one ?

    flyingfooldougF flyingfooldoug wrote on last edited by flyingfooldoug
    #43

    @darren15 said:

    If Williams is to become HC do you promote a DC from within or go get one ?

    Keep what you have. The kid is doing a fine job as DC. Haven’t you heard? Blake Williams is running the D with input from pop

  • @darren15 said:

    If Williams is to become HC do you promote a DC from within or go get one ?

    Keep what you have. The kid is doing a fine job as DC. Haven’t you heard? Blake Williams is running the D with input from pop

    T TexasAg1969 wrote on last edited by
    #44

    @flyingfooldoug said:

    Keep what you have. The kid is doing a fine job as DC. Haven’t you heard?

    Totally agree. Don't mess with the stew when it's just right!