Skip to content

Upset Browns Fans

The Browns Board
29 19 766 1
  • PFF had him far and away #1 so I wasn't shocked, I just hoped it would work out.

  • big deal - a few? fans were not happy? shocked? MOST fans were delighted. Any more old news ya got?

  • I was thinking of Rosen. But certainly I liked him as my second favorite. In the draft presser I liked him the most along Rosen and against Georgia he made some impressive passes. 

    One year later, I can't think of anyone more appropiate to lead this team, and Rosen has rumours saying that he's out of his team (which I think that whether you like him or not, it's absurd. He's a first round pick with only a year under his belt in a bad team)

    I'm glad the way everything turned out. Let's keep fighting. 

  • Truthfully I was thinking "Uh oh, another diminutive semi-running QB from the Big 12-2 who has rarely faced high level defenses." He is proving he is more than that thanks to work with Freddie.

  • at the time.i was like couldnt we have traded down and.still gotten him? but no, pats were gonna throw the jets years worth of drafts to move up for him

  • big deal - a few? fans were not happy? shocked? MOST fans were delighted. Any more old news ya got?

    @calfoxwc said:

    big deal - a few? fans were not happy? shocked? MOST fans were delighted. Any more old news ya got?

    The Titanic has sunk

  • I was happy as heck.  I knew we had to have that guy.  He was clearly the best.

  • For me, there was no other choice than Baker. I wanted that kid so bad & could only hope that Dorsey did too.I LOVED the part where Kirk Herbstreit politely shoved Mel's statement down his throat.

    Mike

  • I have to admit, the douchebag had a helluva rookie season..... ?

  • Originally I was dead set against drafting Manziel 2.   Then when it was convincing enough that he was NOT a Manziel I wasn't against him being the pick if that's who Dorsey thought was the best QB, but I wanted a tall guy with good mechanics.   In reality though, I wanted Dorsey to pick who he thought was the best QB at #1 and NOT to let someone else have the best QB and then go ahead and take who fell to him at #4.

  • For me, there was no other choice than Baker. I wanted that kid so bad & could only hope that Dorsey did too.I LOVED the part where Kirk Herbstreit politely shoved Mel's statement down his throat.

    Mike

    @canton-mike said:

    I LOVED the part where Kirk Herbstreit politely shoved Mel's statement down his throat.

    Mike

    Me too; because of how slightly politely it was to the Ratbird Cheerleader.   Herbie's skin wasn't just crawling - it was doing aerobics.  BLEE DAT! 

  • Truthfully I was thinking "Uh oh, another diminutive semi-running QB from the Big 12-2 who has rarely faced high level defenses." He is proving he is more than that thanks to work with Freddie.

    @texasag1969 said:

    Truthfully I was thinking "Uh oh, another diminutive semi-running QB from the Big 12-2 who has rarely faced high level defenses." He is proving he is more than that thanks to work with Freddie.

    The recent trend of Patrick Mahomes and Baker Mayfield from the Big 12 might want to have people looking at the QBs instead of their conferences moving forward.

    Once upon a time the Tedford System QBs were a "no no" until Aaron Rodgers ended such a trend.  Having said that, was that Tedford Trend a big reason such a talent like Rodgers slid all the way to #24 overall to the team Favre was starting for?   There were also the BYU QBs that didn't pan out as starters over the years like: Gifford Nielsen, Marc Wilson, Robbie Bosco, Ty Detmer and John Beck.  However, Jim McMahon and Steve Young were enough of an exception to that rule to remind people to look at the QB instead of the school, system, conference, etc...

  • I called it before the draft...been happy with the pick.

  • I called it before the draft...been happy with the pick.

    @canton-dawg said:

    I called it before the draft...been happy with the pick.

    I called Garrett two years before his draft. "Don't worry...............................be happy!"?

  • Truthfully I was thinking "Uh oh, another diminutive semi-running QB from the Big 12-2 who has rarely faced high level defenses." He is proving he is more than that thanks to work with Freddie.

    @texasag1969 said:

    Truthfully I was thinking "Uh oh, another diminutive semi-running QB from the Big 12-2 who has rarely faced high level defenses." He is proving he is more than that thanks to work with Freddie.

    This was my concern as well, by far. I didn't think the guy was Manziel 2.0 in the slightest, but rather the simple truth of Big 12 QB's having essentially no success in the NFL. Between Mahomes and Baker, that script is officially flipped.

  • @texasag1969 said:

    Truthfully I was thinking "Uh oh, another diminutive semi-running QB from the Big 12-2 who has rarely faced high level defenses." He is proving he is more than that thanks to work with Freddie.

    The recent trend of Patrick Mahomes and Baker Mayfield from the Big 12 might want to have people looking at the QBs instead of their conferences moving forward.

    Once upon a time the Tedford System QBs were a "no no" until Aaron Rodgers ended such a trend.  Having said that, was that Tedford Trend a big reason such a talent like Rodgers slid all the way to #24 overall to the team Favre was starting for?   There were also the BYU QBs that didn't pan out as starters over the years like: Gifford Nielsen, Marc Wilson, Robbie Bosco, Ty Detmer and John Beck.  However, Jim McMahon and Steve Young were enough of an exception to that rule to remind people to look at the QB instead of the school, system, conference, etc...

    @flugel said:

    The recent trend of Patrick Mahomes and Baker Mayfield from the Big 12 might want to have people looking at the QBs instead of their conferences moving forward.

    Once upon a time the Tedford System QBs were a "no no" until Aaron Rodgers ended such a trend.  Having said that, was that Tedford Trend a big reason such a talent like Rodgers slid all the way to #24 overall to the team Favre was starting for?   There were also the BYU QBs that didn't pan out as starters over the years like: Gifford Nielsen, Marc Wilson, Robbie Bosco, Ty Detmer and John Beck.  However, Jim McMahon and Steve Young were enough of an exception to that rule to remind people to look at the QB instead of the school, system, conference, etc...

    People seem to forget that every once in awhile.. a guy like 5'7" Eddie LeBaron comes along and surprises people...

  • @flugel said:

    The recent trend of Patrick Mahomes and Baker Mayfield from the Big 12 might want to have people looking at the QBs instead of their conferences moving forward.

    Once upon a time the Tedford System QBs were a "no no" until Aaron Rodgers ended such a trend.  Having said that, was that Tedford Trend a big reason such a talent like Rodgers slid all the way to #24 overall to the team Favre was starting for?   There were also the BYU QBs that didn't pan out as starters over the years like: Gifford Nielsen, Marc Wilson, Robbie Bosco, Ty Detmer and John Beck.  However, Jim McMahon and Steve Young were enough of an exception to that rule to remind people to look at the QB instead of the school, system, conference, etc...

    People seem to forget that every once in awhile.. a guy like 5'7" Eddie LeBaron comes along and surprises people...

    @nickers said:

    People seem to forget that every once in awhile.. a guy like 5'7" Eddie LeBaron comes along and surprises people...

    The Chrysler LeBaron, and Eddie happened a long time ago. Until real recently those nasty analytics nerds thought NFL quarterbacks shouldn't be less than 6'2". Brees and Wilson were considered outliers in the equation.  Baker's success last year threw that one out the window, and has paved the way for Kyler Murray to be drafted high this evening.  It will remain to be seen if Murray can duplicate Mayfield's instant success. 

  • @nickers said:

    People seem to forget that every once in awhile.. a guy like 5'7" Eddie LeBaron comes along and surprises people...

    The Chrysler LeBaron, and Eddie happened a long time ago. Until real recently those nasty analytics nerds thought NFL quarterbacks shouldn't be less than 6'2". Brees and Wilson were considered outliers in the equation.  Baker's success last year threw that one out the window, and has paved the way for Kyler Murray to be drafted high this evening.  It will remain to be seen if Murray can duplicate Mayfield's instant success. 

    @hoorta said:

    The Chrysler LeBaron, and Eddie happened a long time ago. Until real recently those nasty analytics nerds thought NFL quarterbacks shouldn't be less than 6'2". Brees and Wilson were considered outliers in the equation.  Baker's success last year threw that one out the window, and has paved the way for Kyler Murray to be drafted high this evening.  It will remain to be seen if Murray can duplicate Mayfield's instant success. 

    I just don't see Kyler as a pro QB.. I see him being a return man/RB/WildDawg type of guy... I just don't see him making an adjustment to the speed of the game based merely on the fact that WR's don't get 3 step cushions like they do in College...

  • @hoorta said:

    The Chrysler LeBaron, and Eddie happened a long time ago. Until real recently those nasty analytics nerds thought NFL quarterbacks shouldn't be less than 6'2". Brees and Wilson were considered outliers in the equation.  Baker's success last year threw that one out the window, and has paved the way for Kyler Murray to be drafted high this evening.  It will remain to be seen if Murray can duplicate Mayfield's instant success. 

    I just don't see Kyler as a pro QB.. I see him being a return man/RB/WildDawg type of guy... I just don't see him making an adjustment to the speed of the game based merely on the fact that WR's don't get 3 step cushions like they do in College...

    @nickers said:

    I just don't see Kyler as a pro QB.. I see him being a return man/RB/WildDawg type of guy... I just don't see him making an adjustment to the speed of the game based merely on the fact that WR's don't get 3 step cushions like they do in College...

    It's possible he may flop, certainly has a higher bust potential than Mayfield.  The little I've seen of Murray tells me he probably has more arm than Baker (reason he was a first round pick in MLB), and is certainly accurate enough- when his WRs were wide open. 🙂   Didn't like that he didn't run a 40, but then again neither did Lamar Jackson. The big question is does he have the smarts? There were reports his whiteboard stuff was terrible, and underlying stuff his Wunderlich showed he's not very bright.  

    EDIT: I'll take that back.  Murray isn't box of rocks thick like Vince Young (6) but current thinking is 20 is the cutoff for considering a qb. Kyler is right on the cusp. Was able to dig these scores up:   

     43 — Ryan Finley, South Carolina (re-test; scored 28 on the first try)
    42 — Gardner Minshew, Washington State
    37 — Daniel Jones, Duke
    32 — Easton Stick, North Dakota State
    32 — Clayton Thorson, Northwestern
    31 — Trace McSorley, Penn State
    30 — Will Grier, West Virginia
    28 — Brett Rypien, Boise State
    27 — Jarrett Stidham, Auburn
    26 — Drew Lock, Missouri
    25 — Tyree Jackson, Buffalo
    25 — Dwayne Haskins, Ohio State
    22 — Sean McGuire, Western Illinois
    20 — Kyler Murray, Oklahoma

    So what's his MO going to be in the pros? If his first read is covered, take off running? Quick trip to IR.  

    FWIW, Baker scored a 25 on the test and scored second highest on the improved version- the AIQ.  

    "This year’s most anticipated draft player, Baker Mayfield, has scored the second highest score ever on the Athlete IQ test, or AIQ. The AIQ, a modernized version of the Wonderlic test - a test designed to measure player performance under stress - has been in development with the NFL since 2012, and is being used with existing Wonderlic scores to allow coaches to find the players with the best mental form for their team."

  • I'm still in shock that we didn't pick Josh Allen 1st overall. He was the best QB prospect, by far.