Skip to content
The Browns Board
  1. Home
  2. The Browns Board
  3. Browns First Round Draft picks 2010-20 ranked

Browns First Round Draft picks 2010-20 ranked

The Browns Board
11 5 662

  • Here is more or less an augmentation to the Survey.   Below are listed all the players the Browns have taken in First Round from 2010-2020.   Rank the picks, best to worst.  (Inspired by a facebook video).  Note, leave Wills out as no basis to judge yet.

    k Year Rnd Pick Player Pos DrAge From To AP1 PB St CarAV G GS QBrec Cmp Att Yds TD Int Att Yds TD Rec Yds TD Int Sk College/Univ  
    1 2020 1 10 Jedrick Wills OT 21     0 0 0                                   Alabama College Stats
    2 2018 1 1 Baker Mayfield QB 23 2018 2019 0 0 2 21 30 29 12-17-0 627 1020 7552 49 35 67 272 3           Oklahoma College Stats
    3 2018 1 4 Denzel Ward CB 21 2018 2019 0 1 2 13 25 24                         5   Ohio St. College Stats
    4 2017 1 1 Myles Garrett DE 21 2017 2019 0 1 3 22 37 35                           30.5 Texas A&M College Stats
    5 2017 1 25 Jabrill Peppers S 21 2017 2019 0 0 3 14 40 40                         3 1.0 Michigan College Stats
    6 2017 1 29 David Njoku TE 21 2017 2019 0 0 1 7 36 20             1 1 0 93 1066 9     Miami (FL) College Stats
    7 2016 1 15 Corey Coleman WR 22 2016 2018 0 0 2 6 27 19             3 15 0 61 789 5     Baylor College Stats
    8 2015 1 12 Danny Shelton NT 22 2015 2019 0 0 4 29 75 59                           4.5 Washington College Stats
    9 2015 1 19 Cameron Erving C 23 2015 2019 0 0 3 20 69 42                             Florida St. College Stats
    10 2014 1 8 Justin Gilbert DB 22 2014 2016 0 0 0 4 35 3                         1   Oklahoma St. College Stats
    11 2014 1 22 Johnny Manziel QB 21 2014 2015 0 0 0 5 15 8 2-6-0 147 258 1675 7 7 46 259 1           Texas A&M College Stats
    12 2013 1 6 Barkevious Mingo LB 22 2013 2019 0 0 2 23 110 38                         1 10.0 LSU College Stats
    13 2012 1 3 Trent Richardson RB 22 2012 2014 0 0 3 17 46 37             614 2032 17 113 912 2     Alabama College Stats
    14 2012 1 22 Brandon Weeden QB 28 2012 2018 0 0 1 14 35 25 6-19-0 559 965 6462 31 30 62 200 1 0 -9 0     Oklahoma St. College Stats
    15 2011 1 21 Phil Taylor DT 23 2011 2014 0 0 2 20 44 42                           7.0 Baylor College Stats
    16 2010 1 7 Joe Haden DB 21 2010 2019 0 3 8 55 132 123

  • My own ranking...so far:

    1. Garrett

    2. Baker

    3. Haden

    4. Ward

    5. Phil Taylor

    6. Njoku

    7. Shelton

    8. Peppers

    9. Mingo

    10.  Richardson

    11. Weeden

    12. Coleman

    13. Erving

    14. JFF

    15. Gilbert

    The fact that I can only go like 4 deep here to find what I consider good players is just pathetic. 

    ballpeenB 1 Reply

  • My ranking would mirror the Gippers, except maybe moving Erving up to 10.(Didn't he do pretty well in KC? Was it KC?)

    The GipperT 1 Reply

  • Richardson should be dead last.  The only saving grace with him is the Colts gave us our pick back.

    “It is impossible to get a man to understand something if his livelihood depends on him not understanding.”
    The GipperT Dutch OvenD 2 Replies
  • htownbrownH htownbrown

    Richardson should be dead last.  The only saving grace with him is the Colts gave us our pick back.

    @htownbrown said:

    Richardson should be dead last.  The only saving grace with him is the Colts gave us our pick back.

    I would definitely not go that far, given that Gilbert did even worse. 

    I mean, even JFF  QBd the Browns to a couple of wins.   (he was 2-6.   I mean, 2d rounder Deshone Kizer was 0-15)

  • htownbrownH htownbrown

    Richardson should be dead last.  The only saving grace with him is the Colts gave us our pick back.

    @htownbrown said:

    Richardson should be dead last.  The only saving grace with him is the Colts gave us our pick back.

    Richardson was "eh" during his rookie season for the Browns.

    There's so many people on that list that would never come close to smelling "eh". 

    htownbrownH The GipperT 2 Replies
  • Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven

    @htownbrown said:

    Richardson should be dead last.  The only saving grace with him is the Colts gave us our pick back.

    Richardson was "eh" during his rookie season for the Browns.

    There's so many people on that list that would never come close to smelling "eh". 

    @dutch-oven said:

    Richardson was "eh" during his rookie season for the Browns.

    There's so many people on that list that would never come close to smelling "eh". 

    Richardson smelled more like ass than anything because that's all he ever ran into.  Apparently, its the only kind of hole he could find.

    “It is impossible to get a man to understand something if his livelihood depends on him not understanding.”
  • Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven

    @htownbrown said:

    Richardson should be dead last.  The only saving grace with him is the Colts gave us our pick back.

    Richardson was "eh" during his rookie season for the Browns.

    There's so many people on that list that would never come close to smelling "eh". 

    @dutch-oven said:

    Richardson was "eh" during his rookie season for the Browns.

    There's so many people on that list that would never come close to smelling "eh". 

    Richardson at least had one great moment. 

  • The GipperT The Gipper

    My own ranking...so far:

    1. Garrett

    2. Baker

    3. Haden

    4. Ward

    5. Phil Taylor

    6. Njoku

    7. Shelton

    8. Peppers

    9. Mingo

    10.  Richardson

    11. Weeden

    12. Coleman

    13. Erving

    14. JFF

    15. Gilbert

    The fact that I can only go like 4 deep here to find what I consider good players is just pathetic. 

    @the-gipper said:

    My own ranking...so far:

    1. Garrett

    2. Baker

    3. Haden

    4. Ward

    5. Phil Taylor

    6. Njoku

    7. Shelton

    8. Peppers

    9. Mingo

    10.  Richardson

    11. Weeden

    12. Coleman

    13. Erving

    14. JFF

    15. Gilbert

    The fact that I can only go like 4 deep here to find what I consider good players is just pathetic. 

    That looks good to me.  I would like to drop Njoku, but not sure who I would put in front of him.  I might put Peppers ahead of Danny.

    If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.
  • ballpeenB ballpeen

    @the-gipper said:

    My own ranking...so far:

    1. Garrett

    2. Baker

    3. Haden

    4. Ward

    5. Phil Taylor

    6. Njoku

    7. Shelton

    8. Peppers

    9. Mingo

    10.  Richardson

    11. Weeden

    12. Coleman

    13. Erving

    14. JFF

    15. Gilbert

    The fact that I can only go like 4 deep here to find what I consider good players is just pathetic. 

    That looks good to me.  I would like to drop Njoku, but not sure who I would put in front of him.  I might put Peppers ahead of Danny.

    @ballpeen said:

    That looks good to me.  I would like to drop Njoku, but not sure who I would put in front of him.  I might put Peppers ahead of Danny.

    Yea, obviously there is some flexibility in that middle ground.  Neither of those guys were around here long enough really 

  • B blitzz2

    My ranking would mirror the Gippers, except maybe moving Erving up to 10.(Didn't he do pretty well in KC? Was it KC?)

    @blitzz2 said:

    My ranking would mirror the Gippers, except maybe moving Erving up to 10.(Didn't he do pretty well in KC? Was it KC?)

    I guess I was just looking at what they did for the Browns.  In that case, maybe even JFF  would have been better.....for on field play, than Erving. JFF helped win a couple of games.   Maybe Erving is doing OK with KC...but I don't want to consider that. 

Log in to reply