Does Mcgee Make It To Week Two?

beefjerky

well said. I agree completely, with a better punter we probably win the game.

jrb12711

you know, sifting through all the worthless crap from worthless posters, I'm glad a decent post actually was brought up. This loss was tough, but mcgee was GLARINGLY bad. there's no way you can punt like he did for than a couple games and keep a job. I'm willing to give the guy another game to prove maybe just jitters wore off, but wow. To me that's probably one of the most underlying reasons we took on in the loss column today.

Gips

I couldnt agree more, i have seen all i care to see of richmond mcgee..

WRREBEL

I agree.. It was obvious he needs to be cut..

Also why the hell is robiske playing?? Again he is know where to be seen during the game.. Oh yeah he blocked. Why not start one of our back up line men in his place at wide out?

nickers

Is Scot Player still available?

Loyalty

I bet JaMarcus Russell could put his 280 lbs into a nice punt.

1 more season

I bet McGee will be gone this week. He's a professional so that needs to be respected but he's a punter and a messege needs to be sent regarding poor play, bad penalties and so on.

Canton Mike

My personal opinion is that it depends who else is available. Are they even LOOKING for a new punter? My money says....YES!

He has been inconsistent since he's been here & that can't continue.

Mike

DieHardBrownsFan

@canton-mike said:

My personal opinion is that it depends who else is available. Are they even LOOKING for a new punter? My money says....YES!

He has been inconsistent since he's been here & that can't continue.

Mike

I expect a news release sometime this week on a new Punter.

Harry Buffalo

Shurmer said in the press conference that they were going to take a serious look at punter.

hx214

I vote for Hulk Hogan... I mean Scot Player also.

1 more season

My middle school gym teacher was invited to browns camp a few times on the 80's as a punter. Made into a couple preseason games too.

Spring PE consisted of us shagging punts out on the HS practice field.

He may be available. ; )

dawg08

@hx214 said:

I'm pretty sure the Browns could have had someone come out of the stands and punt better than McGee did today.

After the coaches watched this crap all pre-season, how does this guy have a job?

I'd lay at least 10 points in this guys lap today.

Is it really that hard to find someone that can punt?

I would agree!! Last years punter was just as bad! There has got to be someone out there decent. Hopefully this guy is gone tomorrow!! He is one of the reasons Cincy scored on that quick play TD. His punt was like 20 yrds?? Giving the Bungles the ball on their own 40 after kicking it from the Browns 40. A good punter sets them back on the 10-15 yrd line. I think there punter kicked a 60yrder during the game!!

hx214

@1-more-season said:

Spring PE consisted of us shagging punts out on the HS practice field.

That's freaking awesome, 11 year olds running around trying to catch 60 yard punts.

Loyalty

It shouldn't be that hard to find a punter that can put it 45-50 yards downfield.

1 more season

@hx214 said:

That's freaking awesome, 11 year olds running around trying to catch 60 yard punts.

It was crazy. Bruises on our arms and chest. In cooomminnnngggggg......!!!!!

WarrenDawg

@hx214 said:

I vote for Hulk Hogan... I mean Scot Player also.

I think someone here called Scott Player, "Punty McOnebar"

bringbackbrownie2

@dawg08 said:

I would agree!! Last years punter was just as bad! There has got to be someone out there decent. Hopefully this guy is gone tomorrow!! He is one of the reasons Cincy scored on that quick play TD. His punt was like 20 yrds?? Giving the Bungles the ball on their own 40 after kicking it from the Browns 40. A good punter sets them back on the 10-15 yrd line. I think there punter kicked a 60yrder during the game!!

What team were you watching last year?