Rock n Roll Hall of Fame Class
-
Agreed Bob. Madonna, in my view is horrible. I think its more of a popularity contest then actual talent.
Agreed Bob. Madonna, in my view is horrible. I think its more of a popularity contest then actual talent.
And that is why Madonna is in. She is as talented as any female performer in history.....beyond being an icon.
And the hundreds of music professionals that have a HOF vote agree with that assessment.
And yes, certainly "popularity" is a legitimate factor. Anyone that sells hundreds of millions of record has to be give serious consideration.
Why do you think ABBA is in?
-
I never liked Nirvana, but I don't deny them their place.
Besides, other than The Beatles, Cat Stevens was the one guy from the Rock n Roll era that my mother liked. (long since passed away)
.......so that is all the credentials he needs as far as I am concerned to be HOF worthy.
Fair to say?
I don't deny him either. Just never cared for the guy. Maybe its because I was around 17 when his songs came out. Went into the Army when 'Peace Train' was popular. Just never got into his songs.
I don't deny him either. Just never cared for the guy. Maybe its because I was around 17 when his songs came out. Went into the Army when 'Peace Train' was popular. Just never got into his songs.
Well, again, if it were just one individual's musical tastes that were to apply, I may have said leave Black Sabbath and ACDC on the scrap heap....but that would be foolish of me to ignore their......yes.....popularity....and influence in R&R history.
KISS is in now solely on popularity. Their songs are pretty basic and occasionally catchy, but, they would never have been considered among the most forward thinking musical masterminds on the planet. But boy did they have a following......and they brought tremendous marketing genius to the table, so you cannot discount that.
-
Agreed Bob. Madonna, in my view is horrible. I think its more of a popularity contest then actual talent.
And that is why Madonna is in. She is as talented as any female performer in history.....beyond being an icon.
And the hundreds of music professionals that have a HOF vote agree with that assessment.
And yes, certainly "popularity" is a legitimate factor. Anyone that sells hundreds of millions of record has to be give serious consideration.
Why do you think ABBA is in?
And that is why Madonna is in. She is as talented as any female performer in history.....beyond being an icon.
And the hundreds of music professionals that have a HOF vote agree with that assessment.
And yes, certainly "popularity" is a legitimate factor. Anyone that sells hundreds of millions of record has to be give serious consideration.
Why do you think ABBA is in?
Seriously? ABBA is in there? Rock and Roll...nope, it's not.
-
And that is why Madonna is in. She is as talented as any female performer in history.....beyond being an icon.
And the hundreds of music professionals that have a HOF vote agree with that assessment.
And yes, certainly "popularity" is a legitimate factor. Anyone that sells hundreds of millions of record has to be give serious consideration.
Why do you think ABBA is in?
Seriously? ABBA is in there? Rock and Roll...nope, it's not.
Seriously? ABBA is in there? Rock and Roll...nope, it's not.
Didn't you browse the website like I asked? If you had, yes, you would know that ABBA is in there.
The way some people describe it to me....not being a big ABBA advocate, is that they were the 80s version of The Mamas and Papas.....who are a no brainer for the RRHOF.
So, given that explanation I would say.....if appropriate, then yes, they belong.
-
I love Rock & Roll, but find it funny how some artists are still waiting in the wings to get inducted, while others get into the HOF. Like Madonna or Joni Mitchell over Deep Purple or Genesis (Peter Gabriel gets his due this year).
I won 2 free memberships to the RRHOF for a year back in 2004, but never went. I swore I would never go until Black Sabbath got inducted (they did in 2006). I think musical taste is too subjective for all, and these kind of debates will always be there.
I love Rock & Roll, but find it funny how some artists are still waiting in the wings to get inducted, while others get into the HOF. Like Madonna or Joni Mitchell over Deep Purple or Genesis (Peter Gabriel gets his due this year).
I won 2 free memberships to the RRHOF for a year back in 2004, but never went. I swore I would never go until Black Sabbath got inducted (they did in 2006). I think musical taste is too subjective for all, and these kind of debates will always be there.
Uhm, FYI, Genesis is in. Has been for a few years now. Did not know if you knew that.
But, Deep Purple isn't....and perhaps should be.
Neither are the
Moody Blues,
Yes,
Todd Rundgren
B-52s
Bad Company
The Cars
Cheap Trick
Chicago
Def Leppard
Depeche Mode
Devo
Dire Straits
Doobie Bros.
ELO
ELP
Duran Duran
Eurythmics
Green Day
Nillson
Jethro Tull
Journey
King Crimson
LL Cool J
The Monkees
Motley Crue
Peter, Paul, and Mary
Procul Harum
Soundgarden
Steppenwolf
Steve Miller Band
T-Rex
Tommy James and the Shondells
War
Warren Zevon
Weird Al
The Zombies
-
Abba was 70s, not 80s, and like KISS they were a phenomenon that sold millions and millions of recordings. Not Rock n Roll ... But apparently pop music counts and it is The Big Musical Acts Post 1950 Hall of Fame.
Finally ... John Oates, Linda Rodstadt and Ace Freely on the same stage.
Z
-
Josh Gordon's theme song could be "Blue Bayou" by Linda R.
-
Abba was 70s, not 80s, and like KISS they were a phenomenon that sold millions and millions of recordings. Not Rock n Roll ... But apparently pop music counts and it is The Big Musical Acts Post 1950 Hall of Fame.
Finally ... John Oates, Linda Rodstadt and Ace Freely on the same stage.
Z
Zombo said:
Abba was 70s, not 80s, and like KISS they were a phenomenon that sold millions and millions of recordings. Not Rock n Roll ... But apparently pop music counts and it is The Big Musical Acts Post 1950 Hall of Fame.
Finally ... John Oates, Linda Rodstadt and Ace Freely on the same stage.
Z
Linda is no longer capable of performing due apparently to her severe Parkinson's that she is suffering from . Too bad.
-
Madonna was as hot as they get when she stormed out of Michigan in the early eighties.
-
The Rock Hall is nearing joke....Hall and Oates maker it yet Chicago and Bad Compamy don't??
Shoot....even Cat Stevens can make it yet Chicago....a groundbreaking band, or Bad Company with the greatest voice in Rock history, can't?
Joke.......move it out of Cleveland. It isn't worthy of the ground.
If everybody had like minds, we would never learn. -
The Moody Blues, Doobie Bros., Journey, Steppenwol and Steve Miller Band should all be in.
-
The Rock Hall is nearing joke....Hall and Oates maker it yet Chicago and Bad Compamy don't??
Shoot....even Cat Stevens can make it yet Chicago....a groundbreaking band, or Bad Company with the greatest voice in Rock history, can't?
Joke.......move it out of Cleveland. It isn't worthy of the ground.
The Rock Hall is nearing joke....Hall and Oates maker it yet Chicago and Bad Compamy don't??
Shoot....even Cat Stevens can make it yet Chicago....a groundbreaking band, or Bad Company with the greatest voice in Rock history, can't?
Joke.......move it out of Cleveland. It isn't worthy of the ground.
The greatest voice in rock history? Are you high? That's not even up for debate and it certainly wasn't Paul Rodgers. That's ridiculous. No one...no one would say Paul Rodgers had a better voice than Freddie Mercury.
This shit ain't nothing to me, man. -
The Rock Hall is nearing joke....Hall and Oates maker it yet Chicago and Bad Compamy don't??
Shoot....even Cat Stevens can make it yet Chicago....a groundbreaking band, or Bad Company with the greatest voice in Rock history, can't?
Joke.......move it out of Cleveland. It isn't worthy of the ground.
The Rock Hall is nearing joke....Hall and Oates maker it yet Chicago and Bad Compamy don't??
Shoot....even Cat Stevens can make it yet Chicago....a groundbreaking band, or Bad Company with the greatest voice in Rock history, can't?
Joke.......move it out of Cleveland. It isn't worthy of the ground.
Again, all a matter of personal taste, clearly.
I was never a Chicago fan.....so I am ambivalent about them not being in there. Blood, Sweat, and Tears, to me were a similar...better, earlier act.
I liked Bad Company....but they were not....as you say "groundbreaking". The principals of that band were in other bands that perhaps better consideration: Free with Paul Rodgers, Mott the Hoople with Mick Ralphs.
-
The Rock Hall is nearing joke....Hall and Oates maker it yet Chicago and Bad Compamy don't??
Shoot....even Cat Stevens can make it yet Chicago....a groundbreaking band, or Bad Company with the greatest voice in Rock history, can't?
Joke.......move it out of Cleveland. It isn't worthy of the ground.
The greatest voice in rock history? Are you high? That's not even up for debate and it certainly wasn't Paul Rodgers. That's ridiculous. No one...no one would say Paul Rodgers had a better voice than Freddie Mercury.
The greatest voice in rock history? Are you high? That's not even up for debate and it certainly wasn't Paul Rodgers. That's ridiculous. No one...no one would say Paul Rodgers had a better voice than Freddie Mercury.
Roy Orbison? any number of others. That is also very much a matter of personal taste.
-
The greatest voice in rock history? Are you high? That's not even up for debate and it certainly wasn't Paul Rodgers. That's ridiculous. No one...no one would say Paul Rodgers had a better voice than Freddie Mercury.
Roy Orbison? any number of others. That is also very much a matter of personal taste.
Roy Orbison? any number of others. That is also very much a matter of personal taste.
Do you consider Paul rodgers to have a better voice than Freddie Mercury?
-
Roy Orbison? any number of others. That is also very much a matter of personal taste.
Do you consider Paul rodgers to have a better voice than Freddie Mercury?
Do you consider Paul rodgers to have a better voice than Freddie Mercury?
No, not me personally. But others may. Recall that Queen got Rodgers to sing with them for a while to mimic Freddie.
-
Not to mimic Freddie. Just to make money. Nobody can mimic Freddie. They also split with rogers btw and got Adam Lambert.
This shit ain't nothing to me, man. -
I cannot understand why Peter Gabriel has shown indifference to his earlier days with Genesis?
It was not from a lack of effort on the part of the group to include Gabriel with them on what was thier last tour in 2007, and he turned it down.....
I liked the early "new" group without Gabriel actually, with Collins as the front guy - but apart from his costume get ups on stage - the guy can really sing.
-
I cannot understand why Peter Gabriel has shown indifference to his earlier days with Genesis?
It was not from a lack of effort on the part of the group to include Gabriel with them on what was thier last tour in 2007, and he turned it down.....
I liked the early "new" group without Gabriel actually, with Collins as the front guy - but apart from his costume get ups on stage - the guy can really sing.
I cannot understand why Peter Gabriel has shown indifference to his earlier days with Genesis?
It was not from a lack of effort on the part of the group to include Gabriel with them on what was thier last tour in 2007, and he turned it down.....
I liked the early "new" group without Gabriel actually, with Collins as the front guy - but apart from his costume get ups on stage - the guy can really sing.
I doubt you guys got the ad in the states because it's for a british band, but since we're talking Genesis, you might like this quite surreal commercial (and if not, then just the music).
-
Not to mimic Freddie. Just to make money. Nobody can mimic Freddie. They also split with rogers btw and got Adam Lambert.
Not to mimic Freddie. Just to make money. Nobody can mimic Freddie. They also split with rogers btw and got Adam Lambert.
Lambert comes/came as close to Mercury as anyone could.....a great voice. And a flamethrower as well.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login