Skip to content

The SEC Myth

College Football Forum
71 14 4.6k
  • The Cysko KidT The Cysko Kid wrote on last edited by
    #59

    When you hand a certain conference the title year after year of course they're going to look dominant. When you make them play for it...well...

  • AxeA Axe

    @the-cysko-kid said:

    Axe is so mad right now. Sorry bro, OSU > Alabama

    Not mad at all.. I gave OSU a 50/50 chance and kudos to them.. The SEC is down this yr even tho apparently Iowa didn't get the memo.. The SEC HAS been dominant.. Denying that is ludicrous.. Are things starting to even out? It looks like it might. If OSU/ALA played 10 times.. It might go 5/5.. Good luck next week, Oregon looked mighty tough! Tho FSU was over rated.

    bbedwardB bbedward wrote on last edited by bbedward
    #60

    @axe said:

    Not mad at all.. I gave OSU a 50/50 chance and kudos to them.. The SEC is down this yr even tho apparently Iowa didn't get the memo.. The SEC HAS been dominant.. Denying that is ludicrous.. Are things starting to even out? It looks like it might. If OSU/ALA played 10 times.. It might go 5/5.. Good luck next week, Oregon looked mighty tough! Tho FSU was over rated.

    FSU pulled a bunch of games out of their ass against lesser opponents all year.

    The SEC is dominant on paper, further evaluation tells a different story. The playoffs system maybe telling a different story too. Given the polls biasing towards SEC.

  • BTW, anybody think the SEC "dominance" would have been a little less if we had the playoffs in earlier years?

    MLD WoodyM MLD Woody wrote on last edited by
    #61

    @bbedward said:

    BTW, anybody think the SEC "dominance" would have been a little less if we had the playoffs in earlier years?

    Definitely. Also, if we got rid of preseason rankings and didn't have ranking until like week 6

  • AxeA Axe

    @the-cysko-kid said:

    Axe is so mad right now. Sorry bro, OSU > Alabama

    Not mad at all.. I gave OSU a 50/50 chance and kudos to them.. The SEC is down this yr even tho apparently Iowa didn't get the memo.. The SEC HAS been dominant.. Denying that is ludicrous.. Are things starting to even out? It looks like it might. If OSU/ALA played 10 times.. It might go 5/5.. Good luck next week, Oregon looked mighty tough! Tho FSU was over rated.

    tiamat63T tiamat63 wrote on last edited by
    #62

    @axe said:

    Not mad at all.. I gave OSU a 50/50 chance and kudos to them.. The SEC is down this yr even tho apparently Iowa didn't get the memo.. The SEC HAS been dominant.. Denying that is ludicrous.. Are things starting to even out? It looks like it might. If OSU/ALA played 10 times.. It might go 5/5.. Good luck next week, Oregon looked mighty tough! Tho FSU was over rated.

    I believe in both 2006 and 2007 the SEC had a losing bowl record. But you'd never know because when Florida and LSU won the title games, that means they're the end all- be all.

  • AxeA Axe

    @the-cysko-kid said:

    Axe is so mad right now. Sorry bro, OSU > Alabama

    Not mad at all.. I gave OSU a 50/50 chance and kudos to them.. The SEC is down this yr even tho apparently Iowa didn't get the memo.. The SEC HAS been dominant.. Denying that is ludicrous.. Are things starting to even out? It looks like it might. If OSU/ALA played 10 times.. It might go 5/5.. Good luck next week, Oregon looked mighty tough! Tho FSU was over rated.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #63

    @axe said:

    Not mad at all.. I gave OSU a 50/50 chance and kudos to them.. The SEC is down this yr even tho apparently Iowa didn't get the memo.. The SEC HAS been dominant.. Denying that is ludicrous.. Are things starting to even out? It looks like it might. If OSU/ALA played 10 times.. It might go 5/5.. Good luck next week, Oregon looked mighty tough! Tho FSU was over rated.

    The SEC has had some dominant teams, but the league has not been dominant, not really.....unless you mean dominance of all the cupcakes they schedule.

    As I noted....this year anyway, that conference did not play a single game vs. the Pac 12....which probably really is the dominant conference.. If they did their .500 record against the other power conferences would probably have been much worse.

  • @axe said:

    Not mad at all.. I gave OSU a 50/50 chance and kudos to them.. The SEC is down this yr even tho apparently Iowa didn't get the memo.. The SEC HAS been dominant.. Denying that is ludicrous.. Are things starting to even out? It looks like it might. If OSU/ALA played 10 times.. It might go 5/5.. Good luck next week, Oregon looked mighty tough! Tho FSU was over rated.

    I believe in both 2006 and 2007 the SEC had a losing bowl record. But you'd never know because when Florida and LSU won the title games, that means they're the end all- be all.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #64

    @tiamat63 said:

    I believe in both 2006 and 2007 the SEC had a losing bowl record. But you'd never know because when Florida and LSU won the title games, that means they're the end all- be all.

    Yes, my point being that one dominant school does not make a dominant conference.

    If the SEC continues to schedule cupcakes then the selection committee will hold that against them in future years.

    Of the Power 5 conferences the Big Ten scheduled the most games against the other 4 (plus Notre Dame), the SEC the least.

  • @tiamat63 said:

    I believe in both 2006 and 2007 the SEC had a losing bowl record. But you'd never know because when Florida and LSU won the title games, that means they're the end all- be all.

    Yes, my point being that one dominant school does not make a dominant conference.

    If the SEC continues to schedule cupcakes then the selection committee will hold that against them in future years.

    Of the Power 5 conferences the Big Ten scheduled the most games against the other 4 (plus Notre Dame), the SEC the least.

    Browns149B Browns149 wrote on last edited by
    #65

    @the-gipper said:

    Yes, my point being that one dominant school does not make a dominant conference.

    If the SEC continues to schedule cupcakes then the selection committee will hold that against them in future years.

    Of the Power 5 conferences the Big Ten scheduled the most games against the other 4 (plus Notre Dame), the SEC the least.

    The SEC will continue to schedule those cupcakes. That way they can stay at home in the south and not travel anywhere west or north.

    If they start scheduling big ten or pac 12 teams they will have to do the home-and-home series and they don't want that.

  • DieHardBrownsFanD DieHardBrownsFan wrote on last edited by
    #66

  • AxeA Axe wrote on last edited by
    #67

    Still the funniest thing I've seen in a while 😆

  • AxeA Axe

    Still the funniest thing I've seen in a while 😆

    Browns149B Browns149 wrote on last edited by
    #68

    @axe said:

    Still the funniest thing I've seen in a while 😆

    Saw that awhile back. HILARIOUS !!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @the-gipper said:

    Yes, my point being that one dominant school does not make a dominant conference.

    If the SEC continues to schedule cupcakes then the selection committee will hold that against them in future years.

    Of the Power 5 conferences the Big Ten scheduled the most games against the other 4 (plus Notre Dame), the SEC the least.

    The SEC will continue to schedule those cupcakes. That way they can stay at home in the south and not travel anywhere west or north.

    If they start scheduling big ten or pac 12 teams they will have to do the home-and-home series and they don't want that.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #69

    @browns149 said:

    The SEC will continue to schedule those cupcakes. That way they can stay at home in the south and not travel anywhere west or north.

    If they start scheduling big ten or pac 12 teams they will have to do the home-and-home series and they don't want that.

    Yes, that is true.....though I do think that Tennessee and Ohio St. have a home and home series coming up. I also understand the concept that "we can make more money by playing home games in front of 80-100K people against cupcakes than going on the road to play a tough opponent and thereby losing a home game". All major schools do that, OSU included.....but they usually will schedule at least 1 or two games vs. the other conferences.

    The SEC West was all smoke and mirrors, primarily because of the Mississippi schools. Neither Ole Miss nor MSU scheduled a single non-conference game against a power conference opponent....choosing instead to both schedule 4 cupcakes. While those schools did make a reputation by beating Auburn and Alabama respectively....the fact is they gained their reputation merely by committing incest....I mean, they couldn't get laid except to do it with their sisters.

  • S sadbrownsfan wrote on last edited by
    #70

    This really shows how an actual playoff is better than no playoffs(though much rather see it expanded to 6 or 8 teams). If they had used the BCS system this year, it would have been FSU(an undefeated power 5 conference team) vs Alabama(1 loss SEC team), while Oregon and OSU would have played in the Rose Bowl.

    At the very least the BIG 12 can quit crying about OSU being selected above them.

  • This really shows how an actual playoff is better than no playoffs(though much rather see it expanded to 6 or 8 teams). If they had used the BCS system this year, it would have been FSU(an undefeated power 5 conference team) vs Alabama(1 loss SEC team), while Oregon and OSU would have played in the Rose Bowl.

    At the very least the BIG 12 can quit crying about OSU being selected above them.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #71

    @sadbrownsfan said:

    This really shows how an actual playoff is better than no playoffs(though much rather see it expanded to 6 or 8 teams). If they had used the BCS system this year, it would have been FSU(an undefeated power 5 conference team) vs Alabama(1 loss SEC team), while Oregon and OSU would have played in the Rose Bowl.

    At the very least the BIG 12 can quit crying about OSU being selected above them.

    Except it would have been Alabama/Oregon who was ranked #2 by the committee.....though this committee would not have been in place. Who did like the Sagarin rankings put at the top 2 spots?