If the Browns had listened to Kiper, McShay

[The Gipper]

Mel Kiper’s Final Picks for the Browns 2010-2016 Year Player Position All-Pro Pro Bowl Games Started Approximate Value

2010 Derrick Morgan DE 0 0 80 35

2011 Julio Jones WR 2 4 78 74

2012 Justin Blackmon WR 0 0 18 9

Doug Martin RB 1 2 57 35

2013 Dee Milliner CB 0 0 14 6

2014 Sammy Watkins WR 0 0 37 21

Teddy Twatwater QB 0 1 28 22

2015 Danny Shelton NT 0 0 31 12

Nelson Agholor WR 0 0 26 5

2016 Ronnie Stanley OT 0 0 12 6 TOTAL 3 7 381 225

[The Gipper]

Todd McShay’s Final Picks for the Browns 2010-2016 Year Player Position All-Pro Pro Bowl Games Started Approximate Value

2010 Dan Williams NT 0 0 66 36

2011 Julio Jones WR 2 4 78 74

2012 Trent Richardson RB 0 0 37 18

Kendall Wright WR 0 0 41 26

2013 Geno Smith QB 0 0 30 14

2014 Sammy Watkins WR 0 0 37 21

Teddy Twatwater QB 0 1 28 22

2015 Danny Shelton NT 0 0 31 12

Melvin Gordon RB 0 1 24 15

2016 Joey Bosa DE 0 0 11 6 TOTAL 2 6 383 244

[alporcini]

Interesting post Gip. Though had we taken Jones we wouldn't have had the same WR need for Blackmon, Watkins or Agohlar.

I often wonder if we would have traded out of 6 if AJ Green was still there or Peterson.

Remember many of the pundits worrying about JJ's hands. AJ was the whole package.

[The Gipper]

@alporcini said:

Interesting post Gip. Though had we taken Jones we wouldn't have had the same WR need for Blackmon, Watkins or Agohlar.

I often wonder if we would have traded out of 6 if AJ Green was still there or Peterson.

Remember many of the pundits worrying about JJ's hands. AJ was the whole package.

Yes, I am of the opinion that if AJ Green had been there that there would have been no trade...that the Browns would have grabbed him. But the Bengals jumped in one pick ahead of us.

[wargograw]

I'm sure they'd be the exact same players had we drafted them instead of the team that did.

[BaconHound]

Better than the team did, scary

[CaineDeSoulis]

Walter footballs for comparison

2010
Eric Berry ~ S ~ 3,5,86
2011
Julio Jones ~ WR ~ 2,4,78
2012
Trent Richardson ~ RB ~ 0,0,37
Kendall Wright ~ WR ~ 0,0,41
2013
Geno Smith ~ QB ~ 0,0,30
2014
Mike Evans ~ WR ~ 1,1,46
Teddy Twatwater ~ QB ~ 0,1,28
2015
Danny Shelton ~ NT ~ 0,0,31
D.J. Humphries ~ OT ~ 0,0,13
2016
Ezekiel Elliot ~ RB ~ 1,1,15

[TexasAg1969]

Interesting that none of them is going QB for the Browns @ #1 this year.

I guess for the Browns to stay true to form, they get the QB. It's what they do.

[Tour2ma]

@texasag1969 said:

Interesting that none of them is going QB for the Browns @ #1 this year.

Because they all solved our problem there with Geno and Teddy...