Skip to content

Biggest Draft Miss

The Browns Board
29 17 875
  • Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #1

    Since the Draft will be a nonstop topic for the next 3+ months, I'd like to know what player in a past draft did you absolutely love, who ended up being a NFL disappointment.

    Mine? OT Robert Gallery, Iowa. I loved this guy, probably watched half of his games his last season for the Hawkeyes. He dominated, just mauled guys. The Browns won a season finale vs Cincinnati that knocked us out of the Robert Gallery sweepstakes (I think Lee Suggs ran for like 200 yards?) and I was crushed. Gallery had a decent career, I guess, but wasn't even in the same time zone as Joe Thomas as a LT. (In fact, I think Gallery had to be moved to OG)

    I also had a rager for LB Aaron Curry from Vanderbilt, who was a pretty big disappointment.

  • LBC mikeL LBC mike wrote on last edited by LBC mike
    #2

    My buddy is a raider fan and thinks gallery was a bust pick .

  • tiamat63T tiamat63 wrote on last edited by
    #3

    Mo Claiborne.

  • My buddy is a raider fan and thinks gallery was a bust pick .

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #4

    @lbc-mike said:

    My buddy is a raider fan and thinks gallery was a bust pick .

    He was so damn good at Iowa. I don't know if I've ever wanted the Browns to draft someone as much as I wanted him. In comparison, I thought Joe Thomas at Wisconsin was "solid". šŸ˜†

    Another guy I wanted the Browns to take, that amounted to not much, was Ohio State LB Bobby Carpenter. I thought he was going to be a stud in the NFL. Not so much.

  • LBC mikeL LBC mike wrote on last edited by
    #5

    Trent Richardson. Anyone?Ā Ā 

  • Mo Claiborne.

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #6

    @tiamat63 said:

    Mo Claiborne.

    A guy from the board I came from (who fancies himself to this day as a 'draft guru') wanted this guy soooooooooooo bad, and would never admit that he wasn't that good.

    Same guy loved him some Mingo.

    Apparently he needs to stay away from LSU players.

  • Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #7

    Didn't Robert Gallery end up in Oakland?

    Off the top of my head Andrus Peat may be my biggest whiff... certainly is one of my most recent. Thought he was a plug-n-play LT for a decade. Pretty sure I had him as my top OL the year he came out. NO drafted him. He's now playing OG and doing reasonably well there and moves outside if an OT goes down.

    Close second... actually may be #1... would be Xavier Su'a-Filo who I gave a 1st round grade and included in my annual Browns mock at #26 overall. Has not been anywhere near great in his career in HOU.

  • Didn't Robert Gallery end up in Oakland?

    Off the top of my head Andrus Peat may be my biggest whiff... certainly is one of my most recent. Thought he was a plug-n-play LT for a decade. Pretty sure I had him as my top OL the year he came out. NO drafted him. He's now playing OG and doing reasonably well there and moves outside if an OT goes down.

    Close second... actually may be #1... would be Xavier Su'a-Filo who I gave a 1st round grade and included in my annual Browns mock at #26 overall. Has not been anywhere near great in his career in HOU.

    tiamat63T tiamat63 wrote on last edited by
    #8

    @tour2ma said:

    Didn't Robert Gallery end up in Oakland?

    Off the top of my head Andrus Peat may be my biggest whiff... certainly is one of my most recent. Thought he was a plug-n-play LT for a decade. Pretty sure I had him as my top OL the year he came out. NO drafted him. He's now playing OG and doing reasonably well there and moves outside if an OT goes down.

    Close second... actually may be #1... would be Xavier Su'a-Filo who I gave a 1st round grade and included in my annual Browns mock at #26 overall. Has not been anywhere near great in his career in HOU.

    Funny you say that because I read this board during that 14' draft before joining and saying the same.Ā  Ā Kid looked great at UCLA and I was all over him late 1st early 2nd.

  • Didn't Robert Gallery end up in Oakland?

    Off the top of my head Andrus Peat may be my biggest whiff... certainly is one of my most recent. Thought he was a plug-n-play LT for a decade. Pretty sure I had him as my top OL the year he came out. NO drafted him. He's now playing OG and doing reasonably well there and moves outside if an OT goes down.

    Close second... actually may be #1... would be Xavier Su'a-Filo who I gave a 1st round grade and included in my annual Browns mock at #26 overall. Has not been anywhere near great in his career in HOU.

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #9

    @tour2ma said:

    Didn't Robert Gallery end up in Oakland?

    Yep, drafted #2 overall in the '04 Draft, played there through the 2010 season. Played in Seattle for the 2011 season, signed with New England in 2012 but retired during training camp.

    Ended up being a decent guard, but never lived up to the hype surrounding him as he entered the league.

  • Canton MikeC Canton Mike wrote on last edited by
    #10

    Courtney Brown.

    Mike

  • BrownB499B BrownB499 wrote on last edited by
    #11

    Sammy Watkins

  • 7 7moses7 wrote on last edited by
    #12

    Kellen Winslow Jr.

  • Kellen Winslow Jr.

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #13

    @7moses7 said:

    Kellen Winslow Jr.

    I don't count this one.

    I fully believe if it wasn't for the horrible knee injury, he would have been great. Even so, he was still pretty decent.

  • Since the Draft will be a nonstop topic for the next 3+ months, I'd like to know what player in a past draft did you absolutely love, who ended up being a NFL disappointment.

    Mine? OT Robert Gallery, Iowa. I loved this guy, probably watched half of his games his last season for the Hawkeyes. He dominated, just mauled guys. The Browns won a season finale vs Cincinnati that knocked us out of the Robert Gallery sweepstakes (I think Lee Suggs ran for like 200 yards?) and I was crushed. Gallery had a decent career, I guess, but wasn't even in the same time zone as Joe Thomas as a LT. (In fact, I think Gallery had to be moved to OG)

    I also had a rager for LB Aaron Curry from Vanderbilt, who was a pretty big disappointment.

    Canton DawgC Canton Dawg wrote on last edited by Canton Dawg
    #14

    @dutch-oven said:

    I also had a rager for LB Aaron Curry from Vanderbilt, who was a pretty big disappointment.

    I also thought Curry was going to be a beast...swing and a miss (I believeĀ he went to Wake Forest).

  • T TexasAg1969 wrote on last edited by
    #15
  • @dutch-oven said:

    I also had a rager for LB Aaron Curry from Vanderbilt, who was a pretty big disappointment.

    I also thought Curry was going to be a beast...swing and a miss (I believeĀ he went to Wake Forest).

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #16

    @canton-dawg said:

    I also thought Curry was going to be a beast...swing and a miss (I believeĀ he went to Wake Forest).

    Oh yes he did. I mixed up my black and gold southern colleges!

  • Z Zombo wrote on last edited by
    #17

    Pork Chop Womack.

    I was going to do thread comparing my favorite prospect every year compared to who the Browns took ... but it would be too brutal towards the Browns.

    I don't think they've ever outdrafted me. Not bragging, I'm just a dude ... just shows how remarkably bad the Browns have been at this.

    Zombo

  • mjp28M mjp28 wrote on last edited by
    #18

    Putting Round 1 as a prime time disaster and dragging it out for two more days!Ā 

    Put it back on Saturday and Sunday on ESPN for us real football junkies the way the Lord intended it.Ā šŸ˜‰

    .......and while we're at it get rid of the NFL Thursday night games.

  • StinkHoleS StinkHole wrote on last edited by
    #19

    Brian Bosworth

    Gallery was an all pro compared to Tony Mandarich...biggest O line bust ever.

    Image result for manderich tackle bust

  • R RoyceRolls wrote on last edited by RoyceRolls
    #20

    I was all in on Trent Richardson. I wasn’t on the Board then, but I bought into the hype of the ā€œnext APā€. Ā The Brandon Weeden Pick was theĀ gut punch that ruined my night.Ā 

    Edit: I also thought Sammy Watkins would be a rare talent in the league. He isn’t a bust, but he is nowhere near what I expected him to be. Ā