Hey all, I'm a Bills fan, and thought I'd let you know what we think about Pettine.
First, I'd like to say I've always felt a camaraderie with Browns fans, since we've both experienced a lot of misery. With that said, stealing our coach puts somewhat a dent in those friendly feelings, lol.
I'd also like to say, if you live in Cleveland and know of RMG, I live in Rochester so I also listen to it every morning. I heard some of the thoughts on the hiring from Cleveland fans from the show this morning.
So here we go. Basically, I think a lot of Bills fans would tell you if we had it our way, we would have rather just promoted Pettine to HC and let Marrone go. Pettine is a hard-nosed "football guy", he lets his play do the talking rather than using cliche football speak.
He took our defense, which had been historically bad the past couple years, and made them elite. I know the yardage/points metrics make his defense look average, but that doesn't tell the whole story. For one, a struggling offense and a terrible special teams did the D no favors. His defense was 2nd in sacks and 2nd in INTs. According to PFF's DVOA which gives a more accurate depiction of a defense's overall performance, his D was 4th in the league.
One thing I heard this morning on the radio that I had to take issue with, was the sentiment that "We beat his defense last year, and now we hired him?" I do not think that is fair. We both lost our quarterbacks that game, the difference is that your replacement had started games already. Our replacement at QB was an undrafted rookie who had the worst QB performance I'd ever seen. It was so bad we signed Matt Flynn and promoted our practice squad QB to replace him the next week. Basically, it wasn't Pettine that failed that game, it was a terrible QB who had something like six 3-And-Outs in a row when he entered the game.
Not that our organization is much better, but I felt bad for you guys that coaches were spurning you, with all the talent on your squad. Your defense was already solid, it will be gangbusters with Pettine at the helm. You have some solid players on offense, getting the right QB in the draft and finding the right offensive coordinator will be key. I just hope your front office doesn't get in the way of success. The contrast is clear from the quotes yesterday...your front office guys are talking about the 3 Stooges like it's some comedy, while Pettine is talking about bloodying noses. Pettine's bloody nose quote nearly brought a tear to my eye.
To conclude, I'm going to just throw out some random notes.
-My brother moved to Cleveland for Law School, adopted the Browns, and still lives there. As pissed as I am you took Pettine, I'm still rooting for ya.
-As a Bills fan, I was hoping Pettine would get this opportunity. That's why he got out from under Rex Ryan. I just hoped we'd have one more year with him.
-In training camp, he was being likened to Darth Vader. While other coaches wore our red white and blue, he would wear dark grey and have that serious demeanor while he looked over the team. That's not to say he'll "Schiano" you, but he is an imposing presence who will whip guys into shape.
-Finally, if you aren't already aware, his father is the most winning high school coach in Pennsylvania history. Mike Jr got his coaching start under his father, before getting the HC job of a rival high school. This is all documented in a DVD called "The Last Game", which is a great watch. I saw this a few years ago, and I was very excited when the Bills first hired Pettine because of it. Here is a link: http://www.amazon.com/The-Last-Game-Mike-Pettine/dp/B0000W5H9M
Hope this was of any help. I'll keep this tab open for the night and try to answer any questions if you'd like. And I hope we crush you next year for stealing our coach, lol.