Homotron said:
EDIT: And what stats are you looking at? 700 less total yards? CJ barely beat out Peterson in receiving yards and catches and only had 193 more yards on the ground.
I believe he was looking at the 2009 NFL stats for some reason.
CJ: Rushing Yards: 2006 Receiving yards: 503 Total Yards: 2509
AP: Rushing Yards: 1383 Receiving yards: 436 Total Yards: 1819
2509-1819= 690 yds.
Not quite 700, but close right?
He had 600 more yards on the ground. You were right with the receiving yards though.
Also, here are their total fantasy points for 2009 in a PPR league.
CJ: 360 total
AP: 292 total
68 point difference. Accounting for a 16 game schedule, Johnson outscored him by 4.25 points per week.
So the question is, is TJ Houschmazoadazilla 4.25 points better than your average guy off the wire?
T.J. was the number 26 receiver in this format. A WR3. He scored 149 points or 9.3125 per week.
Mario Manningham was number 30. He scored 133 points, or 8.3125 per week.
Chris Chambers was 40. He scored 118 points or 7.375 per week.
Giving up T.J. just leaves an open spot on your roster to pick up a young guy getting hot. There's no throwing in anything extra. It all comes down to who is more valuable to you between CJ and AP. TJ's stats were a dime a dozen. Hasslebeck is still in a bad position, I like Forsett but he won't get his shots, and Seattle is still not a good team.