Everyone is psyching themselves out.
Just because we spread risk around and got a bunch of new offensive players doesn't mean we have automatic starting talent and depth at every position.
Here's all of your expectations and how they stack up with reality:
Everyone thinks Kessler was a solid college QB with good stats. He's got a strong arm. We brought in 5 new WR's from the draft, so according to math at least one or two of them have to be automatic superstars plus we have more established receivers already on the roster. the offensive line is so-so and there's a lot of options to go with at RB. The amount of depth and spread risk should set us up for success.
No.
Cody Kessler wasn't anywhere close to among the best QB's in college ball. As an avid fan of the college game, I can attest to Kessler never making any kind of highlights or news. At the beginning of his career he was given one of the best programs in college led by one of the best QB's in the country; Matt Barkley (who has done next to nothing in the NFL), and immediately went down the shitter with it. He was the starter for USC since his sophomore season (3 years), he had a consistent, speedy set of WR's, had a top 10 rated O-line every single season he's started, and he plays in the worst defensive conference in the nation. You would think that with those types of advantages he would be heavily discussed every week, but no. He lacks presence, anticipation of the defense, anticipation of his receivers, accuracy, and he folds under pressure if a lineman gets too close.
Hoping that a few of the 5 receivers we picked up will be immediate superstars and Kessler will shine because there's highlight videos of him against the worst defenses in football is just nonsense and irrational.
Instead of watching his highlights, watch his games.
The reality is Connor Shaw will start. That worries many, but it's less crazy to think a guy who has game experience and time with the Browns will succeed compared to a fresh college player that was inconsistent and never considered NFL value.