@the-gipper said:

OK, I asked the bucnut to do this, but apparently he couldn't "get it up" to do it, so I will.

Here are the starters of the Browns and Bucs per their respective website depth charts. Give who you think has the edge in each of these matchups:

OFFENSE:

QB Jake Delhomme vs. Josh Freeman browns

RB Jerome Harrison vs. Cadillac Williams browns

FB Lawrence Vickers vs. Earnest Graham browns

WR1 Moe. Massaquoi vs. Mike Williams browns

WR2 Brian Robiskie vs. Sammie Stroughter bucs

TE Ben Watson vs. K2 bucs

C Alex Mack vs. Jeff Faine browns

LT Joe Thomas vs. Danad? Penn browns

LG Eric Steinbach vs. Keydrick Vincent browns

RG Pork Chop Womack vs. Davin Joseph bucs

RT John St. Clair vs. Jeremy Trueblood (good HBO show!) bucs

DEFENSE:

LDE Robaire Smith vs. Kyle Moore browns

NT Shaun Rogers vs. Gerald McCoy # browns

RDE Kenyon Coleman vs. Stylez White bucs

OLB Matt Roth vs. Quincy Black

OLB Scott Fujita vs. Geno Hayes browns

MLB Eric Barton vs. DT Ray Miller# bucs

MLB Chris Gocung vs. Barret Ruud

LCB Eric Wright vs. Aqib Talib * bucs

RCB Sheldon Brown vs. Ronde Barber

SS Abram Elam vs. Sean Jones browns

FS TJ Ward vs. Tanard Jackson bucs

SPECIAL TEAMS:

K Phil Dawson vs. Connor Barth browns

P Reggie Hodges vs. Chris Bryan

H Reggie Hodges vs. Chris Bryan

LS Ryan Pontbriand vs. Andrew Economus

PR Josh Cribbs vs. Sammie Stroughter browns

KR Josh Cribbs vs. Kareem Huggins browns

* Aqib Talib is suspended for this game, but is the starter on their depth chart

# Browns play the 3-4, Bucs play the 4-3 so I had to put a MLB against a DT here.

Give your thoughts on the comparative talents. I honestly except for a few positions am not really able to give a full comparison.

brown24 bucs 17