Skip to content

I Thought He Missed It, Too

The Browns Board
31 22 3.2k
  • S shepwrite wrote on last edited by
    #1

    In fact, for a while, CBS listed the game as a tie on the ticker.

    http://cle.scout.com/2/907541.html

  • A AZBrowns wrote on last edited by
    #2

    Dude, getting a tie back could be crucial to the Browns playoff chances 😵

  • K Koa wrote on last edited by Koa
    #3

    I'm surprised it wasn't more controversial. My buddy and I were jumping up laughing thinking it went wide...

  • Dude, getting a tie back could be crucial to the Browns playoff chances 😵

    ? AdaM wrote on last edited by
    #4

    @azbrowns said:

    Dude, getting a tie back could be crucial to the Browns playoff chances 😵

    It would piss off bungle fans, which I would enjoy.

  • K Koa

    I'm surprised it wasn't more controversial. My buddy and I were jumping up laughing thinking it went wide...

    BrownIndianB BrownIndian wrote on last edited by
    #5

    @koa said:

    I'm surprised it wasn't more controversial. My buddy and I were jumping up laughing thinking it went wide...

    me 2. I thought we had gone for a draw but was surprised to see that it went in.

  • @azbrowns said:

    Dude, getting a tie back could be crucial to the Browns playoff chances 😵

    It would piss off bungle fans, which I would enjoy.

    A AZBrowns wrote on last edited by
    #6

    AdaM said:

    It would piss off bungle fans, which I would enjoy.

    Touché

  • ATENEARSA ATENEARS wrote on last edited by
    #7

    It's that a new rule that you can challenge field goals (Dawson rule?)

    Wonder why if it was even close, why we wouldn't have challenged it.

    I thought it was no good, but was at the opposite end of the stadium. The video I just watched made it look like it wasn't really even that close.

  • The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #8

    This reminds me of the Karliss kick in "The Drive" game, which I would swear from the video was no good. And from the video here I would swear this kick was no good.

    Are these video angles this deceiving?

    Was there another video angle of this kick perhaps from the far end of the field? I know they have umpteen cameras taking these shots, why couldn't we see another angle like we get for any other on field play? Does the league suppress these shots once the refs make a call?

    Perhaps they should lengthen the goal posts. The Karliss kick, this kick and many others could benefit from taller goal posts.

  • This reminds me of the Karliss kick in "The Drive" game, which I would swear from the video was no good. And from the video here I would swear this kick was no good.

    Are these video angles this deceiving?

    Was there another video angle of this kick perhaps from the far end of the field? I know they have umpteen cameras taking these shots, why couldn't we see another angle like we get for any other on field play? Does the league suppress these shots once the refs make a call?

    Perhaps they should lengthen the goal posts. The Karliss kick, this kick and many others could benefit from taller goal posts.

    R RestinPeace wrote on last edited by
    #9

    @the-gipper said:

    This reminds me of the Karliss kick in "The Drive" game, which I would swear from the video was no good. And from the video here I would swear this kick was no good.

    Are these video angles this deceiving?

    Was there another video angle of this kick perhaps from the far end of the field? I know they have umpteen cameras taking these shots, why couldn't we see another angle like we get for any other on field play? Does the league suppress these shots once the refs make a call?

    Perhaps they should lengthen the goal posts. The Karliss kick, this kick and many others could benefit from taller goal posts.

    I was thinking the same thing.

  • It's that a new rule that you can challenge field goals (Dawson rule?)

    Wonder why if it was even close, why we wouldn't have challenged it.

    I thought it was no good, but was at the opposite end of the stadium. The video I just watched made it look like it wasn't really even that close.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #10

    @atenears said:

    It's that a new rule that you can challenge field goals (Dawson rule?)

    Wonder why if it was even close, why we wouldn't have challenged it.

    I thought it was no good, but was at the opposite end of the stadium. The video I just watched made it look like it wasn't really even that close.

    I believe it is only challengeable if the ball strikes the goal posts and bounces around. Here it was apparently a pure judgment call on whether the ball "would have been" inside the goal posts IF the posts had extended higher.

    Again, my point is: why not just extend the height of the posts? I mean, won't they be straight if you make them taller? Will they bend or snap under their weight?

    What is preventing the extension of the posts?

  • ? AdaM wrote on last edited by
    #11

    They could solve this VERY easilly....

    All they need to do is put a half inch wide reflective strip from top of the inside goalpost, down across the cross bar and up the other side.

    Put a chip in the ball, if the chip doesn't break the plain of the reflective strip, or laser system or what have you, its no good.

    You wouldn't even need ref's to have a say in it.

  • DrunkandstoopidD Drunkandstoopid wrote on last edited by
    #12

    After a bunch of pause/plays on that NFL highlight link above, it sure looks to me like it went just outside the top, not over the top, of the goalpost. Might have even barely clipped it.

    Oh well, game's over.

  • JibzJ Jibz wrote on last edited by
    #13

    AdaM

    excellent idea.

    Let's take the guesswork out of the judges hands.

    Win or lose I would feel better if it wasn't just someones opinion.

  • ? c-dawg wrote on last edited by
    #14

    Pushed it right.

  • It's that a new rule that you can challenge field goals (Dawson rule?)

    Wonder why if it was even close, why we wouldn't have challenged it.

    I thought it was no good, but was at the opposite end of the stadium. The video I just watched made it look like it wasn't really even that close.

    ? Masters wrote on last edited by
    #15

    @atenears said:

    It's that a new rule that you can challenge field goals (Dawson rule?)

    Wonder why if it was even close, why we wouldn't have challenged it.

    I thought it was no good, but was at the opposite end of the stadium. The video I just watched made it look like it wasn't really even that close.

    You can challange a FG (Dawson rule if you will that went into effect last year).

    In OT all reviews must come from the booth. It's the same rules as inside 2 minutes in the 4th QTR (i.e. no coaches challanges in OT). On top of that, if this was the 4th QTR inside 2 minutes (instead of inside 2 mintues in OT), it couldn't be challanged by the coach.

  • @koa said:

    I'm surprised it wasn't more controversial. My buddy and I were jumping up laughing thinking it went wide...

    me 2. I thought we had gone for a draw but was surprised to see that it went in.

    daydawg19D daydawg19 wrote on last edited by
    #16

    @brownindian said:

    me 2. I thought we had gone for a draw but was surprised to see

    that it went in.

    Did it? 🤔

  • ? AdaM wrote on last edited by
    #17

    I find it pretty laughable that they DIDNT review it.

  • N NigelTufnel wrote on last edited by NigelTufnel
    #18

    Probably a dumb question, but could the league review this and proclaim a tie? Or is it a "what's done is done" thing?

    I too thought he missed it when I was watching live and was surprised when the refs raised their hands.

  • Probably a dumb question, but could the league review this and proclaim a tie? Or is it a "what's done is done" thing?

    I too thought he missed it when I was watching live and was surprised when the refs raised their hands.

    B Browns wrote on last edited by
    #19

    @nigeltufnel said:

    Probably a dumb question, but could the league review this and proclaim a tie? Or is it a "what's done is done" thing?

    I too thought he missed it when I was watching live and was surprised when the refs raised their hands.

    I think it's been to long to try to make the NFL over turn the call.

  • R RestinPeace wrote on last edited by
    #20

    The best you will get from the NFL is "sorry".