Skip to content

Holmgren dodges Quinn question, again

The Browns Board
55 25 3.8k
  • When asked what he thought after watching the film on Quinn, Holmgren answered by talking about his injury instead of any type of analysis. Although did mention that he does know QBs. I still strongly believe his "tough decision" is trading Quinn. What do you all think of his reluctance to comment on Quinn? Especially when he has no problem at least complimenting Cribbs, Harrison, and fan favorite, DA.

    hoortaH hoorta wrote on last edited by
    #15

    @mopaji said:

    When asked what he thought after watching the film on Quinn, Holmgren answered by talking about his injury instead of any type of analysis. Although did mention that he does know QBs. I still strongly believe his "tough decision" is trading Quinn. What do you all think of his reluctance to comment on Quinn? Especially when he has no problem at least complimenting Cribbs, Harrison, and fan favorite, DA.

    I assume you're being sarcastic about DA. Holmgren has at least until the draft to evaluate Quinn, and like keeping EM, he's not about to make snap decisions.

    Guaranteed: one or the other qb will be gone- if you think it's Quinn, mucho bueno. IMHO it's DA that's gonna get the heave-ho, and it's gone far beyond the point of keeping on beating a very dead horse.

  • @ballpeen said:

    As my Mama said, "If you can't say something good about a person, you best just keep your mouth zipped".

    How would you know they sucked then?

    ballpeenB ballpeen wrote on last edited by ballpeen
    #16

    @kosar_for_president said:

    How would you know they sucked then?

    How many times have you ever heard a coach say something like " we just don't stand much of a chance when we have to play this guy"??

    You usually can tell what is felt by what isn't said, but as others noted, it may simply be a lack of information at this point to make any real comments.

    I am just not sure MH is a guy who lacks information.

    QB is a fairly key position. With all that happened with this team concerning the QB position, I find if hard to believe has hasn't spent at least a few hours watching some tape to at least begin to get a idea of what he faces at that critical position.

  • When asked what he thought after watching the film on Quinn, Holmgren answered by talking about his injury instead of any type of analysis. Although did mention that he does know QBs. I still strongly believe his "tough decision" is trading Quinn. What do you all think of his reluctance to comment on Quinn? Especially when he has no problem at least complimenting Cribbs, Harrison, and fan favorite, DA.

    DieHardBrownsFanD DieHardBrownsFan wrote on last edited by DieHardBrownsFan
    #17

    @mopaji said:

    When asked what he thought after watching the film on Quinn, Holmgren answered by talking about his injury instead of any type of analysis. Although did mention that he does know QBs. I still strongly believe his "tough decision" is trading Quinn. What do you all think of his reluctance to comment on Quinn? Especially when he has no problem at least complimenting Cribbs, Harrison, and fan favorite, DA.

    Holmgren and the new GM both stressed that passing is the way to win in the NFL. With that in mind I find it hard to believe that Quinn will be the starter. I have a feeling we will either obtain a QB thru free agency, a trade, or through the draft. Both Quinn and Anderson have shown they are not in our future.

  • @kosar_for_president said:

    How would you know they sucked then?

    How many times have you ever heard a coach say something like " we just don't stand much of a chance when we have to play this guy"??

    You usually can tell what is felt by what isn't said, but as others noted, it may simply be a lack of information at this point to make any real comments.

    I am just not sure MH is a guy who lacks information.

    QB is a fairly key position. With all that happened with this team concerning the QB position, I find if hard to believe has hasn't spent at least a few hours watching some tape to at least begin to get a idea of what he faces at that critical position.

    K kshutchins wrote on last edited by
    #18

    @ballpeen said:

    I am just not sure MH is a guy who lacks information.

    If he's anything like my son, there's no such thing as too much information. Also, Mike seems to put high value on talking with people as a component of a thorough analysis.

  • @mopaji said:

    When asked what he thought after watching the film on Quinn, Holmgren answered by talking about his injury instead of any type of analysis. Although did mention that he does know QBs. I still strongly believe his "tough decision" is trading Quinn. What do you all think of his reluctance to comment on Quinn? Especially when he has no problem at least complimenting Cribbs, Harrison, and fan favorite, DA.

    I assume you're being sarcastic about DA. Holmgren has at least until the draft to evaluate Quinn, and like keeping EM, he's not about to make snap decisions.

    Guaranteed: one or the other qb will be gone- if you think it's Quinn, mucho bueno. IMHO it's DA that's gonna get the heave-ho, and it's gone far beyond the point of keeping on beating a very dead horse.

    mopajiM mopaji wrote on last edited by
    #19

    @hoorta said:

    I assume you're being sarcastic about DA. Holmgren has at least until the draft to evaluate Quinn, and like keeping EM, he's not about to make snap decisions.

    Guaranteed: one or the other qb will be gone- if you think it's Quinn, mucho bueno. IMHO it's DA that's gonna get the heave-ho, and it's gone far beyond the point of keeping on beating a very dead horse.

    I was being sarcastic about DA. There should be punctuation for sarcasm, maybe reverse quotations?

  • @kosar_for_president said:

    How would you know they sucked then?

    How many times have you ever heard a coach say something like " we just don't stand much of a chance when we have to play this guy"??

    You usually can tell what is felt by what isn't said, but as others noted, it may simply be a lack of information at this point to make any real comments.

    I am just not sure MH is a guy who lacks information.

    QB is a fairly key position. With all that happened with this team concerning the QB position, I find if hard to believe has hasn't spent at least a few hours watching some tape to at least begin to get a idea of what he faces at that critical position.

    mopajiM mopaji wrote on last edited by
    #20

    @ballpeen said:

    How many times have you ever heard a coach say something like " we just don't stand much of a chance when we have to play this guy"??

    You usually can tell what is felt by what isn't said, but as others noted, it may simply be a lack of information at this point to make any real comments.

    I am just not sure MH is a guy who lacks information.

    QB is a fairly key position. With all that happened with this team concerning the QB position, I find if hard to believe has hasn't spent at least a few hours watching some tape to at least begin to get a idea of what he faces at that critical position.

    I agree with you but I just shed a tear for Holmgren. Can you imagine having to watch a few hours of film on these guys? And its your job to fix it?

  • @hoorta said:

    I assume you're being sarcastic about DA. Holmgren has at least until the draft to evaluate Quinn, and like keeping EM, he's not about to make snap decisions.

    Guaranteed: one or the other qb will be gone- if you think it's Quinn, mucho bueno. IMHO it's DA that's gonna get the heave-ho, and it's gone far beyond the point of keeping on beating a very dead horse.

    I was being sarcastic about DA. There should be punctuation for sarcasm, maybe reverse quotations?

    K kshutchins wrote on last edited by
    #21

    @mopaji said:

    I was being sarcastic about DA. There should be punctuation for sarcasm, maybe reverse quotations?

    ~How about these guys?~

    Good idea, actually.

  • H Hoss wrote on last edited by
    #22

    I notice he didn't dodge the question about Derek Anderson. Oh wait, he never mentioned Derek Anderson.

  • ATENEARSA ATENEARS wrote on last edited by
    #23

    I think he hates Quinn.

  • @mopaji said:

    When asked what he thought after watching the film on Quinn, Holmgren answered by talking about his injury instead of any type of analysis. Although did mention that he does know QBs. I still strongly believe his "tough decision" is trading Quinn. What do you all think of his reluctance to comment on Quinn? Especially when he has no problem at least complimenting Cribbs, Harrison, and fan favorite, DA.

    I assume you're being sarcastic about DA. Holmgren has at least until the draft to evaluate Quinn, and like keeping EM, he's not about to make snap decisions.

    Guaranteed: one or the other qb will be gone- if you think it's Quinn, mucho bueno. IMHO it's DA that's gonna get the heave-ho, and it's gone far beyond the point of keeping on beating a very dead horse.

    C Chicopee John wrote on last edited by
    #24

    @hoorta said:

    I assume you're being sarcastic about DA. Holmgren has at least until the draft to evaluate Quinn, and like keeping EM, he's not about to make snap decisions.

    Guaranteed: one or the other qb will be gone- if you think it's Quinn, mucho bueno. IMHO it's DA that's gonna get the heave-ho, and it's gone far beyond the point of keeping on beating a very dead horse.

    You're probably right, Larry. However, if DA leaves this doesn't mean that BQ lines up behind Center on opening day 2010.

  • I notice he didn't dodge the question about Derek Anderson. Oh wait, he never mentioned Derek Anderson.

    mopajiM mopaji wrote on last edited by
    #25

    @hoss said:

    I notice he didn't dodge the question about Derek Anderson. Oh wait, he never mentioned Derek Anderson.

    Actually, in his first presser he was asked about the QBs and he mentioned that he remembers DA killing his hawks in 07.

  • @hoss said:

    I notice he didn't dodge the question about Derek Anderson. Oh wait, he never mentioned Derek Anderson.

    Actually, in his first presser he was asked about the QBs and he mentioned that he remembers DA killing his hawks in 07.

    H Hoss wrote on last edited by
    #26

    @mopaji said:

    Actually, in his first presser he was asked about the QBs and he mentioned that he remembers DA killing his hawks in 07.

    LMAO - he had to go back to that 2007 year ya'll still live in. LOL.

    I think it is very obvious nobody is asking about DA any longer. But you keep the faith pojami.

  • @mopaji said:

    Actually, in his first presser he was asked about the QBs and he mentioned that he remembers DA killing his hawks in 07.

    LMAO - he had to go back to that 2007 year ya'll still live in. LOL.

    I think it is very obvious nobody is asking about DA any longer. But you keep the faith pojami.

    S SJ_Browns wrote on last edited by
    #27

    @hoss said:

    LMAO - he had to go back to that 2007 year ya'll still live in. LOL.

    I think it is very obvious nobody is asking about DA any longer. But you keep the faith pojami.

    😆

  • @mopaji said:

    Actually, in his first presser he was asked about the QBs and he mentioned that he remembers DA killing his hawks in 07.

    LMAO - he had to go back to that 2007 year ya'll still live in. LOL.

    I think it is very obvious nobody is asking about DA any longer. But you keep the faith pojami.

    mopajiM mopaji wrote on last edited by
    #28

    @hoss said:

    LMAO - he had to go back to that 2007 year ya'll still live in. LOL.

    I think it is very obvious nobody is asking about DA any longer. But you keep the faith pojami.

    I don't want either one. I was telling you what Walrus said. Simmer down now Hoss.

  • @mopaji said:

    When asked what he thought after watching the film on Quinn, Holmgren answered by talking about his injury instead of any type of analysis. Although did mention that he does know QBs. I still strongly believe his "tough decision" is trading Quinn. What do you all think of his reluctance to comment on Quinn? Especially when he has no problem at least complimenting Cribbs, Harrison, and fan favorite, DA.

    I always thought that Quinn was the fan favorite, what have I been missing?

    R roach wrote on last edited by
    #29

    @dawgtracker said:

    I always thought that Quinn was the fan favorite, what have I been missing?

    You're not missing anything.

    i've been following the Browns since Ernie Green gave up his body to block for Jim Brown, and this QB situation is the weirdest thing i can remember. Never can i recall a situation where the coaches and the teammates favor a certain player that the fans despise, while the competing player is a fan favorite that the coaches and team seem indifferent on. It is bizarre.

    If Quinn was that good, it would be a no-brainer to annoint him. If DA was that bad, it would be a no-brainer to cut him. That predicament has been around for a couple seasons now.

  • @dawgtracker said:

    I always thought that Quinn was the fan favorite, what have I been missing?

    You're not missing anything.

    i've been following the Browns since Ernie Green gave up his body to block for Jim Brown, and this QB situation is the weirdest thing i can remember. Never can i recall a situation where the coaches and the teammates favor a certain player that the fans despise, while the competing player is a fan favorite that the coaches and team seem indifferent on. It is bizarre.

    If Quinn was that good, it would be a no-brainer to annoint him. If DA was that bad, it would be a no-brainer to cut him. That predicament has been around for a couple seasons now.

    Riffer XR Riffer X wrote on last edited by Riffer X
    #30

    @roach said:

    You're not missing anything.

    i've been following the Browns since Ernie Green gave up his body to block for Jim Brown, and this QB situation is the weirdest thing i can remember. Never can i recall a situation where the coaches and the teammates favor a certain player that the fans despise, while the competing player is a fan favorite that the coaches and team seem indifferent on. It is bizarre.

    If Quinn was that good, it would be a no-brainer to annoint him. If DA was that bad, it would be a no-brainer to cut him. That predicament has been around for a couple seasons now.

    Since when is it predetermined that DA is favored by teammates and coaches?

    Seems to me that has been propagated by a few members on this board and is now being construed as fact.

    Can someone supply evidence of this supposed fact?

  • @roach said:

    You're not missing anything.

    i've been following the Browns since Ernie Green gave up his body to block for Jim Brown, and this QB situation is the weirdest thing i can remember. Never can i recall a situation where the coaches and the teammates favor a certain player that the fans despise, while the competing player is a fan favorite that the coaches and team seem indifferent on. It is bizarre.

    If Quinn was that good, it would be a no-brainer to annoint him. If DA was that bad, it would be a no-brainer to cut him. That predicament has been around for a couple seasons now.

    Since when is it predetermined that DA is favored by teammates and coaches?

    Seems to me that has been propagated by a few members on this board and is now being construed as fact.

    Can someone supply evidence of this supposed fact?

    R roach wrote on last edited by
    #31

    @riffer-x said:

    Since when is it predetermined that DA is favored by teammates and coaches?

    Seems to me that has been propagated by a few members on this board and is now being construed as fact.

    Can someone supply evidence of this supposed fact?

    The coach part is obvious. If they favored Quinn, they would have annointed him (or at least stuck with him at the beginning of the season). The teammate part is less scientific and based on antecdotal evidence.

  • @dawgtracker said:

    I always thought that Quinn was the fan favorite, what have I been missing?

    You're not missing anything.

    i've been following the Browns since Ernie Green gave up his body to block for Jim Brown, and this QB situation is the weirdest thing i can remember. Never can i recall a situation where the coaches and the teammates favor a certain player that the fans despise, while the competing player is a fan favorite that the coaches and team seem indifferent on. It is bizarre.

    If Quinn was that good, it would be a no-brainer to annoint him. If DA was that bad, it would be a no-brainer to cut him. That predicament has been around for a couple seasons now.

    mopajiM mopaji wrote on last edited by
    #32

    @roach said:

    You're not missing anything.

    i've been following the Browns since Ernie Green gave up his body to block for Jim Brown, and this QB situation is the weirdest thing i can remember. Never can i recall a situation where the coaches and the teammates favor a certain player that the fans despise, while the competing player is a fan favorite that the coaches and team seem indifferent on. It is bizarre.

    If Quinn was that good, it would be a no-brainer to annoint him. If DA was that bad, it would be a no-brainer to cut him. That predicament has been around for a couple seasons now.

    You said it all right there. You'll be challenged, don't take the bait. You'll be talking to a wall and eventually, someone will resort to name calling.

  • @riffer-x said:

    Since when is it predetermined that DA is favored by teammates and coaches?

    Seems to me that has been propagated by a few members on this board and is now being construed as fact.

    Can someone supply evidence of this supposed fact?

    The coach part is obvious. If they favored Quinn, they would have annointed him (or at least stuck with him at the beginning of the season). The teammate part is less scientific and based on antecdotal evidence.

    Tim Couch Pulls OutT Tim Couch Pulls Out wrote on last edited by
    #33

    @roach said:

    The coach part is obvious. If they favored Quinn, they would have annointed him (or at least stuck with him at the beginning of the season). The teammate part is less scientific and based on antecdotal evidence.

    You seem to forget that DA was pulled after 5 1/2 games himself, and got his job back only because BQ got put on IR. The coaches pulled the plug on both QB's, I think it's kind of hard to guess which one is the favorite.

    My guess is that their favorite would be the guy that wins games, whoever that may be.

  • @hoss said:

    I notice he didn't dodge the question about Derek Anderson. Oh wait, he never mentioned Derek Anderson.

    Actually, in his first presser he was asked about the QBs and he mentioned that he remembers DA killing his hawks in 07.

    LCDawgFan13L LCDawgFan13 wrote on last edited by
    #34

    @mopaji said:

    Actually, in his first presser he was asked about the QBs and he mentioned that he remembers DA killing his hawks in 07.

    ~See there's your answer...Quinn didn't get any playing time in '07 so he had nothing to comment on.~ Seriously, why are we even arguing over something that WASN'T said?! Give the guy some time! A lot of people thought that Mangini was gone because Holmgren didn't come out right away and say he was staying. Look how that turned out. He will not make a snap decision or snap judgement. If he doesn't know the answer to the question, he will not make something up just so the press has something to write! When he feels he has enough info on Quinn, he'll talk!

    Oh yeah...the ~'s are a good idea for sarcasm. There are too many people that don't seem to understand sarcasm when it smacks them in the face.