Skip to content

If you had a QB Draft

The Browns Board
73 23 3.9k
  • T TexasFight wrote on last edited by
    #1

    OK, please help me settle a bet w/ my friend.

    Let's say there was a QB draft and you're the GM of the Browns. On your big board, who would be your top 15 QB's?

  • T TexasFight wrote on last edited by
    #2

    ps, just qb's currently in the league now. no college

  • OK, please help me settle a bet w/ my friend.

    Let's say there was a QB draft and you're the GM of the Browns. On your big board, who would be your top 15 QB's?

    B BROWNandORANGE wrote on last edited by
    #3

    @texasfight said:

    OK, please help me settle a bet w/ my friend.

    Let's say there was a QB draft and you're the GM of the Browns. On your big board, who would be your top 15 QB's?

    My top 5: (I'm too lazy to do top 15 😉 )

    1. Pretty Boy Brady

    2. Peyton Manning

    3. Aaron Rodgers

    4. Matt Ryan

    5. Phillip Rivers

  • @texasfight said:

    OK, please help me settle a bet w/ my friend.

    Let's say there was a QB draft and you're the GM of the Browns. On your big board, who would be your top 15 QB's?

    My top 5: (I'm too lazy to do top 15 😉 )

    1. Pretty Boy Brady

    2. Peyton Manning

    3. Aaron Rodgers

    4. Matt Ryan

    5. Phillip Rivers

    T TexasFight wrote on last edited by
    #4

    Colt12 said:

    My top 5: (I'm too lazy to do top 15 😉 )

    1. Pretty Boy Brady

    2. Peyton Manning

    3. Aaron Rodgers

    4. Matt Ryan

    5. Phillip Rivers

    oh come on!! the top 5 are the easy ones. i'm really more interested in 8-15

  • P pizzadeliveryguy wrote on last edited by
    #5

    1. Rivers

    2. Brees

    3. Brady

    4. Ryan

    5. P. Manning

    6. Rodgers

    7. Vick

    8. E. Manning

    9. Roethlisberger

    10. Schaub

    11. Romo

    12. Cutler

    13. Orton

    14. McNabb

    15. Bradford

  • 1. Rivers

    2. Brees

    3. Brady

    4. Ryan

    5. P. Manning

    6. Rodgers

    7. Vick

    8. E. Manning

    9. Roethlisberger

    10. Schaub

    11. Romo

    12. Cutler

    13. Orton

    14. McNabb

    15. Bradford

    B BROWNandORANGE wrote on last edited by
    #6

    @pizzadeliveryguy said:

    1. Rivers

    2. Brees

    3. Brady

    4. Ryan

    5. P. Manning

    6. Rodgers

    7. Vick

    8. E. Manning

    9. Roethlisberger

    10. Schaub

    11. Romo

    12. Cutler

    13. Orton

    14. McNabb

    15. Bradford

    get Eli out of the top 10 man.. I'd put Tony Homo on top of Eli almost every time.

  • @pizzadeliveryguy said:

    1. Rivers

    2. Brees

    3. Brady

    4. Ryan

    5. P. Manning

    6. Rodgers

    7. Vick

    8. E. Manning

    9. Roethlisberger

    10. Schaub

    11. Romo

    12. Cutler

    13. Orton

    14. McNabb

    15. Bradford

    get Eli out of the top 10 man.. I'd put Tony Homo on top of Eli almost every time.

    P pizzadeliveryguy wrote on last edited by
    #7

    Colt12 said:

    get Eli out of the top 10 man.. I'd put Tony Homo on top of Eli almost every time.

    They are close but I'll take the guy with the ring.

  • Colt12 said:

    get Eli out of the top 10 man.. I'd put Tony Homo on top of Eli almost every time.

    They are close but I'll take the guy with the ring.

    S Speedyd900rr wrote on last edited by
    #8

    @pizzadeliveryguy said:

    They are close but I'll take the guy with the ring.

    And here I thought football was a team sport.

  • @pizzadeliveryguy said:

    They are close but I'll take the guy with the ring.

    And here I thought football was a team sport.

    P pizzadeliveryguy wrote on last edited by
    #9

    @speedyd900rr said:

    And here I thought football was a team sport.

    All good teams need a leader.

  • RichiswhereR Richiswhere wrote on last edited by
    #10

    1. Rodgers

    2. Rivers

    3. Ryan

    4. Roethlisberger

    5. Flacco

    6. Bradford

    7. Cutler

    8. Stafford

    9. Schaub

    10. E. Manning

    11. Sanchez

    12. Freeman

    13. Brees

    14. Vick

    15.

  • ClevelandFanForLifeC ClevelandFanForLife wrote on last edited by
    #11

    If it is a qb I had to have this year only, it would be Brees. However, long term I like Rogers. He's the next great qb.

  • P pizzadeliveryguy wrote on last edited by
    #12

    Are you guys that are listing Sanchez serious?

  • Colt12 said:

    get Eli out of the top 10 man.. I'd put Tony Homo on top of Eli almost every time.

    They are close but I'll take the guy with the ring.

    VagitronV Vagitron wrote on last edited by
    #13

    @pizzadeliveryguy said:

    They are close but I'll take the guy with the ring.

    Eli better than Ben is the comical part.

  • @pizzadeliveryguy said:

    They are close but I'll take the guy with the ring.

    Eli better than Ben is the comical part.

    P pizzadeliveryguy wrote on last edited by
    #14

    Homotron said:

    Eli better than Ben is the comical part.

    He would no doubt be higher if it weren't for the off the field antics. Nothing comical about that. It is the same reason why most people didn't want to give the most talented QB in the league a second chance.

  • P pizzadeliveryguy wrote on last edited by
    #15

    Formerly Stone said:

    The love affair with Rivers is nauseating!

    1 & 2 Brady & Manning (take your pick)

    3. Roethlisberger

    4. Brees

    5. Rodgers

    6. Ryan

    7. Rivers

    8. Schaub

    9. Flacco

    10. Vick (if he keeps it up)

    11. Sanchez

    12. Garrard

    13, 14 & 15 Romo, E. Manning, McNaab (flip a coin, they all suck)

    Bradford (should be in their but not as a rookie)

    Having Garrard and Sanchez in the same conversation as Rivers throws all credibility out of the window.

  • M maddogg7888 wrote on last edited by
    #16

    1. Manning

    2. Brady

    3. Schaub

    4. Rivers

    5. Brees

    6. Vick

    7. Rodgers

    8. Ryan

    9. Orton

    10. Flacco

    11. Garrard

    12. Ben

    13. Eli

    14. Bradford

    15. Cassel

  • rich4eagleR rich4eagle wrote on last edited by rich4eagle
    #17

    The record speaks for itself. Not including a QB who played in four super bowls and won three and QB who played in two and won one and a QB who played in two and won two pretty much discredits that persons ability to rank the top ten.

    here we go

    1. Brady

    2. Peyton

    3. Brees

    4. Ben

    5. Rivers

    6. Rogers*

    7. Ryan*

    8. Schaub

    9. Flacco*

    10 Eli

    11. Freeman*

    12. Vick

    13. Garrard

    14 Cassell

    15. Bradford*

    16. Sanchez*

    Asterisk for QB's on the rise

  • The record speaks for itself. Not including a QB who played in four super bowls and won three and QB who played in two and won one and a QB who played in two and won two pretty much discredits that persons ability to rank the top ten.

    here we go

    1. Brady

    2. Peyton

    3. Brees

    4. Ben

    5. Rivers

    6. Rogers*

    7. Ryan*

    8. Schaub

    9. Flacco*

    10 Eli

    11. Freeman*

    12. Vick

    13. Garrard

    14 Cassell

    15. Bradford*

    16. Sanchez*

    Asterisk for QB's on the rise

    1 more season1 1 more season wrote on last edited by
    #18

    @rich4eagle said:

    The record speaks for itself. Not including a QB who played in four super bowls and won three and QB who played in two and won one and a QB who played in two and won two pretty much discredits that persons ability to rank the top ten.

    here we go

    1. Brady

    2. Peyton

    3. Brees

    4. Ben

    5. Rivers

    6. Rogers*

    7. Ryan*

    8. Schaub

    9. Flacco*

    10 Eli

    11. Freeman*

    12. Vick

    13. Garrard

    14 Cassell

    15. Bradford*

    16. Sanchez*

    Asterisk for QB's on the rise

    When I was putting together my list it most resemble this one. I had Rogers at 4.

  • P pizzadeliveryguy wrote on last edited by
    #19

    You guys do realize that Sanchez's career rating is actually lower than Tim Couch's?

  • P pizzadeliveryguy wrote on last edited by
    #20

    Other QBs with a better rating than Sanchez.......

    Patrick Ramsey

    David Carr

    Ryan Fitzpatrick

    JP Losman