If you had a QB Draft
-
The record speaks for itself. Not including a QB who played in four super bowls and won three and QB who played in two and won one and a QB who played in two and won two pretty much discredits that persons ability to rank the top ten.
here we go
1. Brady
2. Peyton
3. Brees
4. Ben
5. Rivers
6. Rogers*
7. Ryan*
8. Schaub
9. Flacco*
10 Eli
11. Freeman*
12. Vick
13. Garrard
14 Cassell
15. Bradford*
16. Sanchez*
Asterisk for QB's on the rise
The record speaks for itself. Not including a QB who played in four super bowls and won three and QB who played in two and won one and a QB who played in two and won two pretty much discredits that persons ability to rank the top ten.
Maybe those players aren't included because they are starting to get up there in age but hey if you want to draft guys in their mid 30's thats up to you
-
You guys do realize that Sanchez's career rating is actually lower than Tim Couch's?
Ratings are over rated.
Ratings are over rated.
So is Sanchez obviously. Rating is by no means the end all but it does serve as a decent stat to gauge QBs for comparison purposes. When you are in the same ballpark as QBs that can't make it in the NFL it raises red flags. Do you really think that if the Jets had no running game and a mediocre defense leading them to a .500 record that anyone would be mentioning Sanchez? He is currently 20th in rating, 17th in TDs, 29th in Comp%, and 18th in yardage. The Yardage and TDs may jump a little after tonight but not enough to make a big difference. The only positives that I can come with is that he is young and could certainly improve and he has done a much better job of not turning the ball over. Let's not forget that he also has a great offensive line and a very good receiving corp at his disposal.
OK, rant over.
-
The record speaks for itself. Not including a QB who played in four super bowls and won three and QB who played in two and won one and a QB who played in two and won two pretty much discredits that persons ability to rank the top ten.
Maybe those players aren't included because they are starting to get up there in age but hey if you want to draft guys in their mid 30's thats up to you
Maybe those players aren't included because they are starting to get up there in age but hey if you want to draft guys in their mid 30's thats up to you
Yeah, I took the initial question to mean that if you were starting a team tomorrow who would you pick going forward not just for this season.
-
1. Brady
2. P. Manning
3. Brees
4. Roethlisberger
5. Rivers
6. Rodgers
7. Vick
8. Ryan
9. Flacco
10. Eli
11. Schaub
12. Orton
13. Romo
14. Bradford
15. Kolb (I know that may sound crazy, but I still think this guy has skills and he is young)
-
Here is my list, perhaps with a little more flair. Let's make a trivia question out of it. Simply say who these nicknames apply to:
1. Lord Gaga aka Mr. Bundchen
2. Aw Shucks, version 1.0
3. Windy
4. Vapo Rub
5. Up a Creek
6. The Rhino
7. Hammerin'Singin' Cowboy
8. He's Coming
9. The Angry Sheep Dog
10. Pancho
11. The Hang Dog
12. The NFL version of the Stepford Wives
13. The Unibrow
14. The Investment Broker
15. Formerly a Slave, now a ____________
16. The Rook
17. Rhymes with Homo
18. Not _ramden, N_____
Answer key later
-
Formerly Stone said:
This thread points out just how delusional some Browns fans are! Leaving Roethlisberger out of the top five, let alone the top ten, just because of the team he plays for, is pure idiocy.He is top ten but leaving him out of the top 5 is not delusional at all. If you were drafting a QB for your team to lead you into the future, his off the field problems would definitely be worrisome. I could see cases being made for him being in the 1 spot down to 9th with none of them being delusional or absurd. Countering homerific views with more homerific views achieves nothing. Try adding some substance behind your argument beyond the insults.
-
1. Peyton Manning
2. Michael Vick
3. Tom Brady
4. Eli Manning
5. Phillip Rivers
6. Colt McCoy
7. Aaron Rogers
8. Joe Flacco
9. Matt Ryan
10. Drew Brees
11. Sam Bradford
12. Donovan McNabb
13. Matthew Stafford
14. Matt Cassell
15. Ben Rapistberger
Notice no Brett Favre on the list. RETIRE!
-
Here is my list, perhaps with a little more flair. Let's make a trivia question out of it. Simply say who these nicknames apply to:
1. Lord Gaga aka Mr. Bundchen
2. Aw Shucks, version 1.0
3. Windy
4. Vapo Rub
5. Up a Creek
6. The Rhino
7. Hammerin'Singin' Cowboy
8. He's Coming
9. The Angry Sheep Dog
10. Pancho
11. The Hang Dog
12. The NFL version of the Stepford Wives
13. The Unibrow
14. The Investment Broker
15. Formerly a Slave, now a ____________
16. The Rook
17. Rhymes with Homo
18. Not _ramden, N_____
Answer key later
Here is my list, perhaps with a little more flair. Let's make a trivia question out of it. Simply say who these nicknames apply to:
1. Lord Gaga aka Mr. Bundchen
Brady
2. Aw Shucks, version 1.0
Manning
3. Windy
Brees
4. Vapo Rub
Vick
5. Up a Creek
Rivers
6. The Rhino
Roethlisberger
7. Hammerin'Singin' Cowboy
Rodgers
8. He's Coming
9. The Angry Sheep Dog
Ryan
10. Pancho
Sanchez
11. The Hang Dog
12. The NFL version of the Stepford Wives
E. Manning
13. The Unibrow
Flacco
14. The Investment Broker
Schaub
15. Formerly a Slave, now a ____________
Freeman
16. The Rook
Cassel
17. Rhymes with Homo
Romo
18. Not _ramden, N_____
Cutler
Answer key later
-
Here is my list, perhaps with a little more flair. Let's make a trivia question out of it. Simply say who these nicknames apply to:
1. Lord Gaga aka Mr. Bundchen
2. Aw Shucks, version 1.0
3. Windy
4. Vapo Rub
5. Up a Creek
6. The Rhino
7. Hammerin'Singin' Cowboy
8. He's Coming
9. The Angry Sheep Dog
10. Pancho
11. The Hang Dog
12. The NFL version of the Stepford Wives
13. The Unibrow
14. The Investment Broker
15. Formerly a Slave, now a ____________
16. The Rook
17. Rhymes with Homo
18. Not _ramden, N_____
Answer key later
-
Richiswhere.
Good job. You got all but 6 of the 18 right, including the one's you left blank. The one's you got wrong are #6, 9, 8, 11, 12, 18. A couple of these may be a bit obtuse or esoteric. But you did well.
And no, Hang Dog does not refer to Vick. But, that's funny because I didn't even think of that when I came up with these.
-
man.....no love for brees here
since 2006 he has the most passing yardage, touchdowns, completions........he has the best completion percentage and passer rating
he has as many rings as manning(1) and has helped turn around one of the worst franchises in NFL history
i know hes not on TV as much but the numbers dont lie guys
i understand not putting him #1 but putting him 10th or even outside the top 5?.......wtf are some of you really not paying any attention to football?
-
Here is the answer for one of the nicknames:
He's coming. Who's coming? Eli's coming.
-
Here is another answer:
Not Kramden ....(n)Orton.
-
Another:
Matt Ryan:
I took this from a friend of mine whose name is Ryan but goes by Rhino.
-
Here is my list, perhaps with a little more flair. Let's make a trivia question out of it. Simply say who these nicknames apply to:
1. Lord Gaga aka Mr. Bundchen
2. Aw Shucks, version 1.0
3. Windy
4. Vapo Rub
5. Up a Creek
6. The Rhino
7. Hammerin'Singin' Cowboy
8. He's Coming
9. The Angry Sheep Dog
10. Pancho
11. The Hang Dog
12. The NFL version of the Stepford Wives
13. The Unibrow
14. The Investment Broker
15. Formerly a Slave, now a ____________
16. The Rook
17. Rhymes with Homo
18. Not _ramden, N_____
Answer key later
Here is my list, perhaps with a little more flair. Let's make a trivia question out of it. Simply say who these nicknames apply to:
9. The Angry Sheep Dog
Cutler
Dont think i would have ever gotten #6 and #8
-
1. Brett Favre
2. Brett Favre
3. Brett Favre
4. Brett Favre
5. Brett Favre
6. Brett Favre
7. Brett Favre
8. Brett Favre
9. Brett Favre
10. Brett Favre
11. Brett Favre
12. Brett Favre
13. Brett Favre
14. Brett Favre
...and BOOM!
15. Brett Favre
-
man.....no love for brees here
since 2006 he has the most passing yardage, touchdowns, completions........he has the best completion percentage and passer rating
he has as many rings as manning(1) and has helped turn around one of the worst franchises in NFL history
i know hes not on TV as much but the numbers dont lie guys
i understand not putting him #1 but putting him 10th or even outside the top 5?.......wtf are some of you really not paying any attention to football?
man.....no love for brees here
since 2006 he has the most passing yardage, touchdowns, completions........he has the best completion percentage and passer rating
he has as many rings as manning(1) and has helped turn around one of the worst franchises in NFL history
i know hes not on TV as much but the numbers dont lie guys
i understand not putting him #1 but putting him 10th or even outside the top 5?.......wtf are some of you really not paying any attention to football?
I had him at 2 behind Rivers.
-
man.....no love for brees here
since 2006 he has the most passing yardage, touchdowns, completions........he has the best completion percentage and passer rating
he has as many rings as manning(1) and has helped turn around one of the worst franchises in NFL history
i know hes not on TV as much but the numbers dont lie guys
i understand not putting him #1 but putting him 10th or even outside the top 5?.......wtf are some of you really not paying any attention to football?
I had him at 2 behind Rivers.
I had him at 2 behind Rivers.
more talkin about guys like colt12, richiswhere, clevelandsound
some guys even have ben or schaub ahead of him.......neither of which are actually better than him at anything
like i said....im not saying he needs to be #1 on everybodys list.......but im worried about some of you guys that come up with lists that put flacco or ryan or bradford or cutler ahead of him.......some people need to be slapped in the face for being so dumb
-
I would go
Aaron Rogers
Phillip Rivers
Drew Brees
Tom Brady
Peyton Manning
Matt Ryan
Ben Roethlisburger
Mike Vick
Tony Romo
Eli Manning
Joe Flacco
Josh Freeman
Kyle Orton
Jay Cutler
Sam Bradford
Just missing
Matt Schaub
Donovan McNabb
Matt Cassell
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login