Skip to content

Greatest Team of All Time Bracket

The Browns Board
22 7 926
  • I know this may be a subject more for the offseason....but, it is still just preseason, so I will do this anyway. A debate is always ongoing about what the greatest team of all time is. Well here is your chance to weigh in. I am going to do an NCAA Tournament type Bracket and allow you all to vote for your choices amongst the contestants.

    I have chosen what I think are probably the 24 best teams from NFL history to compete. Of these 24 I have chose 8 to get byes. I will tell you those 8 at the end. Sixteen teams will play off in the first round....then the winners of those 16 matches will face the teams that got the first round bye.

    Here are the first round matchups. You choose who you pick, by noting it somehow. After a few days, I will terminate the voting and declare the first round winner:

    Round 1:

    Game 1:

    2007 Patriots 16-0

    vs

    2004 Patriots 14-2

    Brady vs. Brady....2007 Pats only team in competition who did not win the title.

    Game 2:

    1992 Cowboys 13-3

    vs.

    1998 Broncos

    Aikman and Smith vs. Elway and Davis

    Game 3:

    1991 Redskins 14-2

    vs.

    1989 49ers 14-2

    Best of Joe Gibbs teams, vs. Bill Walsh/Joe Montana

    Game 4:

    1986 Giants 14-2

    vs.

    1976 Raiders 13-1

    Parcells/LT/Simms vs. John Madden/the Snake/nasty boy defense

    Game 5:

    1963 Bears 11-1-2

    vs.

    1962 Packers 13-1

    Papa Bear's last title as a coach vs. Lombardi/Starr etc. in the middle of their dynasty

    Game 6:

    1958 Colts 9-3

    vs.

    1953 Lions 10-2

    Johnny U's Greatest Game year vs. Bobby Layne/Doak Walker

    Game 7:

    1950 Browns 10-2

    vs.

    1949 Eagles 11-1

    Upstart Champions from AAFC vs. old line Champions from NFL

    Game 8:

    1942 Redskins 10-1

    vs

    1941 Bears 10-1

    Sid Luckman vs. Sammy Baugh

    Choose your winners. They will face the following teams:

    1923 Bulldogs 11-0-1 (three year run at 28-1-4)

    1929 Packers 12-0-1

    1948 Browns 15-0 undefeated/untied

    1966 Packers 12-2 first SB Champs

    1972 Dolphins 17-0 second undefeated/untied

    1978 Steelers, best of that dynasty 17-2

    1984 49ers 18-1 Best of that dynasty

    1985 Bears 18-1

  • FYI, here are very outstanding teams that did not make my cut:

    Champions:

    1977 Cowboys 14-2

    1945 Rams 11-1

    1926 Yellow Jackets 14-1-2

    1927 Giants 11-1-1

    1936 Packers 10-1-1

    1943 Bear 8-1-1

    1947 Browns 12-1-1

    1949 Browns 9-1-2

    1965 Bills 12-2

    1970 Colts 14-2-1

    1973 Dolphins 15-2

    2003 Pats 17-2

    Super solid teams that did not make, as they did not win a title:

    2011 Packers 15-1

    2010 Pats 14-2

    2009 Colts 14-2

    2006 Chargers 14-2

    2005 Colts 14-2

    2004 Steelers 15-1

    2001 Rams 14-2

    1999 Jags 14-2

    1998 Vikings 15-1

    1998 Falcons 14-2

    1992 49ers 14-2

    1990 49ers 14-2

    1987 49ers 13-2

    1986 Bears 14-2

    1984 Dolphins 14-2

    1983 Redskins 14-2

    1977 Broncos 12-2

    1968 Colts 13-1

    1967 Rams 11-1-2

    1953 Browns 11-1

    1951 Browns 11-1

    1948 Cardinals 11-1

    1944 Giants 8-1-1

    1942 Bears 11-0 (reg season)

    1939 Giants 9-1-1

    1937 Bears 9-1-1

    1934 Bears 13-0 (reg season)

  • Game 1

    Pats 2004, they won the SB

    Game 2

    1992 Cowboys, They also had Michael Irvin

    Game 3

    1989 Niners, One of the Greatest collections of talent and coaching

    Game 4

    1976 Raiders, It was my first Sb I remember watching Raiders vs. Vikings

    GAme 5

    1962 Packers. Maybe Lombardi's best team

    Game 6

    1958 Colts, they won the "Greatest " game ever, in most people's opinion

    Game 7

    1950 Browns. Enough said

    Game 8

    1942 Skins, They beat the defending champ 1941 Bears

  • I know this may be a subject more for the offseason....but, it is still just preseason, so I will do this anyway. A debate is always ongoing about what the greatest team of all time is. Well here is your chance to weigh in. I am going to do an NCAA Tournament type Bracket and allow you all to vote for your choices amongst the contestants.

    I have chosen what I think are probably the 24 best teams from NFL history to compete. Of these 24 I have chose 8 to get byes. I will tell you those 8 at the end. Sixteen teams will play off in the first round....then the winners of those 16 matches will face the teams that got the first round bye.

    Here are the first round matchups. You choose who you pick, by noting it somehow. After a few days, I will terminate the voting and declare the first round winner:

    Round 1:

    Game 1:

    2007 Patriots 16-0

    vs

    2004 Patriots 14-2

    Brady vs. Brady....2007 Pats only team in competition who did not win the title.

    Game 2:

    1992 Cowboys 13-3

    vs.

    1998 Broncos

    Aikman and Smith vs. Elway and Davis

    Game 3:

    1991 Redskins 14-2

    vs.

    1989 49ers 14-2

    Best of Joe Gibbs teams, vs. Bill Walsh/Joe Montana

    Game 4:

    1986 Giants 14-2

    vs.

    1976 Raiders 13-1

    Parcells/LT/Simms vs. John Madden/the Snake/nasty boy defense

    Game 5:

    1963 Bears 11-1-2

    vs.

    1962 Packers 13-1

    Papa Bear's last title as a coach vs. Lombardi/Starr etc. in the middle of their dynasty

    Game 6:

    1958 Colts 9-3

    vs.

    1953 Lions 10-2

    Johnny U's Greatest Game year vs. Bobby Layne/Doak Walker

    Game 7:

    1950 Browns 10-2

    vs.

    1949 Eagles 11-1

    Upstart Champions from AAFC vs. old line Champions from NFL

    Game 8:

    1942 Redskins 10-1

    vs

    1941 Bears 10-1

    Sid Luckman vs. Sammy Baugh

    Choose your winners. They will face the following teams:

    1923 Bulldogs 11-0-1 (three year run at 28-1-4)

    1929 Packers 12-0-1

    1948 Browns 15-0 undefeated/untied

    1966 Packers 12-2 first SB Champs

    1972 Dolphins 17-0 second undefeated/untied

    1978 Steelers, best of that dynasty 17-2

    1984 49ers 18-1 Best of that dynasty

    1985 Bears 18-1

    @the-gipper said:

    I know this may be a subject more for the offseason....but, it is still just preseason, so I will do this anyway. A debate is always ongoing about what the greatest team of all time is. Well here is your chance to weigh in. I am going to do an NCAA Tournament type Bracket and allow you all to vote for your choices amongst the contestants.

    I have chosen what I think are probably the 24 best teams from NFL history to compete. Of these 24 I have chose 8 to get byes. I will tell you those 8 at the end. Sixteen teams will play off in the first round....then the winners of those 16 matches will face the teams that got the first round bye.

    Here are the first round matchups. You choose who you pick, by noting it somehow. After a few days, I will terminate the voting and declare the first round winner:

    Round 1:

    Game 1:

    __________________________________________________________________________2007 Patriots 16-0

    vs

    2004 Patriots 14-2

    Brady vs. Brady....2007 Pats only team in competition who did not win the title.

    Game 2:

    __________________________________________________________________________1992 Cowboys 13-3

    vs.

    1998 Broncos

    Aikman and Smith vs. Elway and Davis

    Game 3:

    _____________________________________________________________________________________1991 Redskins 14-2

    vs.

    1989 49ers 14-2

    Best of Joe Gibbs teams, vs. Bill Walsh/Joe Montana

    Game 4:

    1986 Giants 14-2

    vs.

    _______________________________________________________________________________________1976 Raiders 13-1

    Parcells/LT/Simms vs. John Madden/the Snake/nasty boy defense

    Game 5:

    1963 Bears 11-1-2

    vs.

    ________________________________________________________________________________________1962 Packers 13-1

    Papa Bear's last title as a coach vs. Lombardi/Starr etc. in the middle of their dynasty

    Game 6:

    1958 Colts 9-3

    vs.

    ___________________________________________________________________________________________1953 Lions 10-2

    Johnny U's Greatest Game year vs. Bobby Layne/Doak Walker

    Game 7:

    ___________________________________________________________________________________________1950 Browns 10-2

    vs.

    1949 Eagles 11-1

    Upstart Champions from AAFC vs. old line Champions from NFL

    Game 8:

    1942 Redskins 10-1

    vs

    _____________________________________________________________________________________________1941 Bears 10-1

    Sid Luckman vs. Sammy Baugh

    Choose your winners. They will face the following teams:

    1923 Bulldogs 11-0-1 (three year run at 28-1-4)

    1929 Packers 12-0-1

    1948 Browns 15-0 undefeated/untied

    1966 Packers 12-2 first SB Champs

    1972 Dolphins 17-0 second undefeated/untied

    1978 Steelers, best of that dynasty 17-2

    1984 49ers 18-1 Best of that dynasty

    1985 Bears 18-1

  • I know this is a Browns board, but I think you have too many Browns teams listed..I'll just nail my ending now.....85 Bears kick ass all the way to the end.

  • I know this is a Browns board, but I think you have too many Browns teams listed..I'll just nail my ending now.....85 Bears kick ass all the way to the end.

    @ballpeen said:

    I know this is a Browns board, but I think you have too many Browns teams listed..I'll just nail my ending now.....85 Bears kick ass all the way to the end.

    I only have 2. There are also 2 Pats, 2 Redskins, 3 Packers, 3 Bears, 2 49ers, so I don't think I was overly generous to the home team vis a vis other teams.

  • Round 1:



    Game 1:


    2007 Patriots 16-0


    vs


    2004 Patriots 14-2



    Brady vs. Brady....2007 Pats only team in competition who did not win the title.




    Game 2:


    1992 Cowboys 13-3


    vs.


    1998 Broncos



    Aikman and Smith vs. Elway and Davis




    Game 3:


    1991 Redskins 14-2


    vs.


    1989 49ers 14-2



    Best of Joe Gibbs teams, vs. Bill Walsh/Joe Montana




    Game 4:


    1986 Giants 14-2


    vs.


    1976 Raiders 13-1



    Parcells/LT/Simms vs. John Madden/the Snake/nasty boy defense



    Game 5:


    1963 Bears 11-1-2


    vs.


    1962 Packers 13-1



    Papa Bear's last title as a coach vs. Lombardi/Starr etc. in the middle of their dynasty




    Game 6:


    1958 Colts 9-3


    vs.


    1953 Lions 10-2



    Johnny U's Greatest Game year vs. Bobby Layne/Doak Walker




    Game 7:


    1950 Browns 10-2


    vs.


    1949 Eagles 11-1



    Upstart Champions from AAFC vs. old line Champions from NFL



    They played this game ... Browns won




    Game 8:


    1942 Redskins 10-1


    vs


    1941 Bears 10-1



    Sid Luckman vs. Sammy Baugh

  • They played this game

    Yea, well, you know, I kinda set it up that way.

    I will leave this first round open over the weekend. Let's see about another 10-12 put in their votes.

  • I know this is a Browns board, but I think you have too many Browns teams listed..I'll just nail my ending now.....85 Bears kick ass all the way to the end.

    @ballpeen said:

    I know this is a Browns board, but I think you have too many Browns teams listed..I'll just nail my ending now.....85 Bears kick ass all the way to the end.

    Yup... that was last year's result IIRC...

  • @ballpeen said:

    I know this is a Browns board, but I think you have too many Browns teams listed..I'll just nail my ending now.....85 Bears kick ass all the way to the end.

    Yup... that was last year's result IIRC...

    @tour2ma said:

    Yup... that was last year's result IIRC...

    Uhm, where are your picks?

  • I know this may be a subject more for the offseason....but, it is still just preseason, so I will do this anyway. A debate is always ongoing about what the greatest team of all time is. Well here is your chance to weigh in. I am going to do an NCAA Tournament type Bracket and allow you all to vote for your choices amongst the contestants.

    I have chosen what I think are probably the 24 best teams from NFL history to compete. Of these 24 I have chose 8 to get byes. I will tell you those 8 at the end. Sixteen teams will play off in the first round....then the winners of those 16 matches will face the teams that got the first round bye.

    Here are the first round matchups. You choose who you pick, by noting it somehow. After a few days, I will terminate the voting and declare the first round winner:

    Round 1:

    Game 1:

    2007 Patriots 16-0

    vs

    2004 Patriots 14-2

    Brady vs. Brady....2007 Pats only team in competition who did not win the title.

    Game 2:

    1992 Cowboys 13-3

    vs.

    1998 Broncos

    Aikman and Smith vs. Elway and Davis

    Game 3:

    1991 Redskins 14-2

    vs.

    1989 49ers 14-2

    Best of Joe Gibbs teams, vs. Bill Walsh/Joe Montana

    Game 4:

    1986 Giants 14-2

    vs.

    1976 Raiders 13-1

    Parcells/LT/Simms vs. John Madden/the Snake/nasty boy defense

    Game 5:

    1963 Bears 11-1-2

    vs.

    1962 Packers 13-1

    Papa Bear's last title as a coach vs. Lombardi/Starr etc. in the middle of their dynasty

    Game 6:

    1958 Colts 9-3

    vs.

    1953 Lions 10-2

    Johnny U's Greatest Game year vs. Bobby Layne/Doak Walker

    Game 7:

    1950 Browns 10-2

    vs.

    1949 Eagles 11-1

    Upstart Champions from AAFC vs. old line Champions from NFL

    Game 8:

    1942 Redskins 10-1

    vs

    1941 Bears 10-1

    Sid Luckman vs. Sammy Baugh

    Choose your winners. They will face the following teams:

    1923 Bulldogs 11-0-1 (three year run at 28-1-4)

    1929 Packers 12-0-1

    1948 Browns 15-0 undefeated/untied

    1966 Packers 12-2 first SB Champs

    1972 Dolphins 17-0 second undefeated/untied

    1978 Steelers, best of that dynasty 17-2

    1984 49ers 18-1 Best of that dynasty

    1985 Bears 18-1

    @the-gipper said:

    Game 1:

    2007 Patriots 16-0

    vs

    2004 Patriots 14-2

    Game 2:

    1992 Cowboys 13-3

    vs.

    1998 Broncos

    Game 3:

    1991 Redskins 14-2

    vs.

    1989 49ers 14-2

    This is the toughest game to pick.......I basically flipped a coin, 49ers won, and I went bact to the Redskins

    Game 4:

    1986 Giants 14-2

    vs.

    1976 Raiders 13-1

    Game 5:

    1963 Bears 11-1-2

    vs.

    1962 Packers 13-1

    Game 6:

    1958 Colts 9-3

    vs.

    1953 Lions 10-2

    Game 7:

    1950 Browns 10-2

    vs.

    1949 Eagles 11-1

    Game 8:

    1942 Redskins 10-1

    vs

    1941 Bears 10-1

  • Game 3, Game 6, and Game 8 are currently tied. Games 2, 4,5,7 are blowouts so far.

  • I am giving this thread about another hour of so. Get your votes in.

  • Winners:

    Game 1: 2004 Patriots over 2007 Patriots

    Game 2: 1992 Cowboys over 1998 Broncos

    Game 3: 1989 49ers over 1991 Redskins

    Game 4: 1976 Raiders over 1986 Giants

    Game 5: 1962 Packers over 1963 Bears

    Game 6: 1958 Colts over 1953 Lions

    Game 7. 1950 Browns over 1949 Eagles

    Game 8: 1942 Redskins over 1941 Bears

  • Second Round Matchups:

    Game 9:

    1984 49ers

    vs

    2004 Patriots

    Joe Montana/Bill Walsh vs. Tom Brady/Bill Belichick

    Game 10:

    1972 Dolphins

    vs.

    1992 Cowboys

    Shula vs. Jimmy Johnson, Griese vs. Marino, Warfield vs. Irvin, Smith vs. Csonka/Kiick

    Game 11

    1923 Bulldogs

    vs.

    1989 49ers

    George Seifert/Montana vs. Guy Chamberlain/Pete Henry

    Game 12

    1966 Packers

    vs.

    1976 Raiders

    Lombardi vs. Madden, Starr vs. Stabler, Taylor/Hornung. Willie Wood vs. Wille Brown.

    Game 13

    1978 Steelers

    vs.

    1962 Packers

    Noll vs. Lombardi, Starr vs. Bradshaw, Harris vs. Taylor, Lambert vs. Nitschke, Joe Greene vs. Henry Jordan/Willie Davis

    Game 14

    1985 Bears

    vs

    1958 Colts

    Ditka vs. Ewbank, Unitas vs. McMahon, Payton vs. Ameche, Berry vs. Gault, Perry vs. Lipscomb, Hampton vs. Marchetti

    Game 15

    1950 Browns

    vs

    1929 Packers

    Otto Graham, Motley, Groza et al vs. Johnny Blood McNally

    Game 16

    1948 Browns

    vs

    1942 Redskins

    Ray Flaherty vs. Paul Brown. Sammy Baugh vs. Otto Graham

    Give your choices on the games in this round.

  • Second Round Matchups:



    Game 9:



    1984 49ers


    vs


    2004 Patriots



    Joe Montana/Bill Walsh vs. Tom Brady/Bill Belichick




    Game 10:



    1972 Dolphins


    vs.


    1992 Cowboys



    Shula vs. Jimmy Johnson, Griese vs. Marino, Warfield vs. Irvin, Smith vs. Csonka/Kiick



    Game 11



    1923 Bulldogs


    vs.


    1989 49ers



    George Seifert/Montana vs. Guy Chamberlain/Pete Henry



    Game 12



    1966 Packers


    vs.


    1976 Raiders



    Lombardi vs. Madden, Starr vs. Stabler, Taylor/Hornung. Willie Wood vs. Wille Brown.



    Game 13



    1978 Steelers


    vs.


    1962 Packers



    Noll vs. Lombardi, Starr vs. Bradshaw, Harris vs. Taylor, Lambert vs. Nitschke, Joe Greene vs. Henry Jordan/Willie Davis




    Game 14



    1985 Bears


    vs


    1958 Colts



    Ditka vs. Ewbank, Unitas vs. McMahon, Payton vs. Ameche, Berry vs. Gault, Perry vs. Lipscomb, Hampton vs. Marchetti




    Game 15



    1950 Browns


    vs


    1929 Packers



    Otto Graham, Motley, Groza et al vs. Johnny Blood McNally



    Game 16



    1948 Browns


    vs


    1942 Redskins

  • Well damn, I was too late.

    Woulda thrown in my vote for the 91 Skins (probably unsurprisingly). That team had everything - dominating defense, juggernaut O. IMO the best team ever. But alas, I'm too late.

    As for round 2:

    Game 9:

    1984 49ers

    vs

    2004 Patriots

    Game 10:

    1972 Dolphins

    vs.

    1992 Cowboys

    Game 11

    1923 Bulldogs

    vs.

    1989 49ers

    Game 12

    1966 Packers

    vs.

    1976 Raiders

    Game 13

    1978 Steelers

    vs.

    1962 Packers

    Game 14

    1985 Bears

    vs

    1958 Colts

    Game 15

    1950 Browns

    vs

    1929 Packers

    Game 16

    1948 Browns

    vs

    1942 Redskins

  • Second Round Matchups:

    Game 9:

    1984 49ers

    vs

    2004 Patriots

    Joe Montana/Bill Walsh vs. Tom Brady/Bill Belichick

    Game 10:

    1972 Dolphins

    vs.

    1992 Cowboys

    Shula vs. Jimmy Johnson, Griese vs. Marino, Warfield vs. Irvin, Smith vs. Csonka/Kiick

    Game 11

    1923 Bulldogs

    vs.

    1989 49ers

    George Seifert/Montana vs. Guy Chamberlain/Pete Henry

    Game 12

    1966 Packers

    vs.

    1976 Raiders

    Lombardi vs. Madden, Starr vs. Stabler, Taylor/Hornung. Willie Wood vs. Wille Brown.

    Game 13

    1978 Steelers

    vs.

    1962 Packers

    Noll vs. Lombardi, Starr vs. Bradshaw, Harris vs. Taylor, Lambert vs. Nitschke, Joe Greene vs. Henry Jordan/Willie Davis

    Game 14

    1985 Bears

    vs

    1958 Colts

    Ditka vs. Ewbank, Unitas vs. McMahon, Payton vs. Ameche, Berry vs. Gault, Perry vs. Lipscomb, Hampton vs. Marchetti

    Game 15

    1950 Browns

    vs

    1929 Packers

    Otto Graham, Motley, Groza et al vs. Johnny Blood McNally

    Game 16

    1948 Browns

    vs

    1942 Redskins

  • @josephsuxdick said:

    Hate to tell ya, Gimp, but ESPN did this years ago with "Dream Bowl" running all the greatest teams and match-ups through the computer no less.

    Guess who won?

    Don't know, don't care. This is for patrons of this board to make their choices. Why didn't you make your choices?

  • Closeout on Round 2 will be this afternoon.