Is Tom Brady the greatest of all time?

[jeffinwv]

Is he the best quarterback ever?Ive never seen a guy who jusy keep goin and goin...the consistency and division titles and super bowls...

Hows he do it? Is is Coach B? Scheme?

I cant think of another QB from any era Id take over him

[Flyin J]

I can.....Peyton Manning.

[Kosar_For_President]

If he wins another yes. 2nd to Montana right now IMO.

[jeffinwv]

But has Manning never had to play with so many different receivers ? Troy Brown.no name guys..people like this...Brady make average receivers, stars Brady could take the Jets receivers and get em in the playoffs

[DieHardBrownsFan]

No.

[Kosar_For_President]

@diehardbrownsfan said:

No.

Explain....

[jeffinwv]

The only star WR Bradys had is Randy Moss.and only for one year ...and he set records with him.All these other QBS have had star WR...Montana ,Aikman and the rest...

He does more with less than anyone ever

[Browns149]

XxDaBuckeyexX said:

I can.....Peyton Manning.

Not even close. Manning had 2 hall of fame WR's Harrison and Wayne, for their enitre careers , Brady had Moss for 1year. Manning had an all pro RB, Edgerrin James, Brady had none.

Manning is a HOFer for sure, but Brady is better. 5 superbowl appearances, 3 wins, Manning 2 appearances and 1 win. Brady 18-7 in the playoffs. Manning 9-11

[USFBrown]

I'd say yes. Its already been pointed out that he does more with less than the other star HOF QBs. With Moss and Gronk he was on another level.

[tml1138]

Interestingly enough, Patriots were a running team last night against the Colts. Did Brady even throw one touchdown pass last night?

I guess they figured they'd exploit Colts run defense, or lack thereof. It worked.

[Browns149]

@tml1138 said:

Interestingly enough, Patriots were a running team last night against the Colts. Did Brady even throw one touchdown pass last night?

I guess they figured they'd exploit Colts run defense, or lack thereof. It worked.

No he didn't throw a TD last night.

It sure would be a refreshing change for a Browns team exploit another teams weaknesses. But you need a REAL headcoach and QB to do that. SIGH!!!!!!

[Tour2ma]

Best? No...

But as Bum Phillips once said about Earl Campbell:

"He may not be in a class by himself, but it does not take long to call the role."

[bbedward]

I would rather start a franchise with a young Tom Brady than anyone.

Guys a winner, it's tough to argue with his success.

[Suomi]

No.

[DieHardBrownsFan]

@kosar_for_president said:

Explain....

I think he is definitely one of the best, but find it hard to qualify 'best of all time'. Quarterbacks played in different era's, amount of games, less pussy rules then the quarterbacks have now. So I have favorites, but not any I would consider best.

[The Cysko Kid]

Tom Brady is the greatest of all time. Montana is his only competition. I feel lucky to see him and manning playing in the same era

[CLEVELANDwantsPLAYOFFS]

I feel like he's great (arm strength accuracy, awareness, etc) but the organization is to be given much credit for keeping the man with a GREAT O-Line year in and year out.

It all starts up front

[RoyceRolls]

I prefer manning, but it is very close. Everyone talks about Brady's SBs but he hasn't won anything since the league got wise to BBs cheating pattern. I'm not saying Brady doesn't have the skill to win but it's just interesting: cheating=3-0 no cheating=0-2

[hx214]

I don't know, I think Billy has a lot to do with his success.

remember the year he went down and Matt Cassel stepped in and was a super star, and now he is a third string behind Ponder and Freeman.

Not saying Brady is a slub, but if he played for another team, I doubt he would be as successful.

[Zombo]

Manning is the best I've ever seen, Brady hasn't passed Montana in my mind yet, but he is certainly in the same neighborhood.

I'm a stubborn Browns fan though, so ... Otto Graham is the greatest QB ever.

Zombo