Africa - poor by choice
-
to refute intelligently with factual information to people who spout biased and unsubstantiated opinion is not pompous. It only comes across that way to the person who is exposed for their lack of knowledge on a subject.
I am sure since you are a programmer if a person came in and posted some code that they made up without any knowledge of what they were doing and passing it off as a working product you could and should expose them. Other people who dont have the benefit of your experience/education and knowledge in that field would benefit and not be taken in or duped into a flawed and false product.
-
come on Legacy you are being coy..... revenue generated from domestic corps that pay more taxes to our government system yearly than our sporadic aid programs.. when they actually do fund. Like I said between oil/chemical/mineral rights our companies own ahem robbed and process destroying their ecology because they obviously dont have a robust epa or any sort of legitimate oversight and sold to our economy and europe's... Not to mention people and employers who put money into mutual funds that profit from those investments.
so yes technically you nor I pay ANY money toward these aid packages because the gross revenue in taxes and earnings from the market well exceed any sort of organized disbursement to that continent.
Africa is not poor by choice, more exploited by first imperialistic europe and than now by advanced capitalism that can deploy technology and money to corrupt.. I mean support governments who grant us anything we want in exchange for living better than the indeginous peoples. Its like what the Catholics did in order to market I mean spread their business... I mean religion to less advanced cultures. Come in with superior arms and funds to build schools that only taught from the Bible to brainwash I mean teach reading and support only leaders who granted them sole rights to exploit.... I mean help their people. That is why Catholicism still has tons of money coming from the Third world where education has much lower standards.
Not poor by choice but by exploitation and manipulation.
come on Legacy you are being coy..... revenue generated from domestic corps that pay more taxes to our government system yearly than our sporadic aid programs.. when they actually do fund. Like I said between oil/chemical/mineral rights our companies own ahem robbed and process destroying their ecology because they obviously dont have a robust epa or any sort of legitimate oversight and sold to our economy and europe's... Not to mention people and employers who put money into mutual funds that profit from those investments.
so yes technically you nor I pay ANY money toward these aid packages because the gross revenue in taxes and earnings from the market well exceed any sort of organized disbursement to that continent.
Africa is not poor by choice, more exploited by first imperialistic europe and than now by advanced capitalism that can deploy technology and money to corrupt.. I mean support governments who grant us anything we want in exchange for living better than the indeginous peoples. Its like what the Catholics did in order to market I mean spread their business... I mean religion to less advanced cultures. Come in with superior arms and funds to build schools that only taught from the Bible to brainwash I mean teach reading and support only leaders who granted them sole rights to exploit.... I mean help their people. That is why Catholicism still has tons of money coming from the Third world where education has much lower standards.
Not poor by choice but by exploitation and manipulation.
No, I'm talking about paying for the resources we are apparently raping. Nothing is free & somebody is collecting a check for our alleged rape (lions & tigers & catholics, Oh my!)
.Are you (and PB&J, since he apparently agrees), calling for a PROHIBITION on purchasing goods from 3rd world nations? Because, I mean now we are at least collecting taxes on it, and some folks are getting paid for those goods/resources.
-
Your analogy is invalid. Self-serving in a huge way, but invalid.
A computer program can be written in fine ways, in different languages.
You simply diss any language you don't program in, as "not the right language"..
elitism. Self - centered, extremely bigoted to anything not buoying one's ego, based on uniqueness as
an end all boon to the same "self".
-
legacy you said apparantly..... there are probably thousands of investigative journalistic pieces written over the last 100 years along with historians writing from multiple countries on the subject of exploitation of the natural wealth of that continent.
the somebody collecting the check would be anyone that benefits from the returns in mutual funds invested in those projects along with the corps that are based in europe and the U.S.
some of you were talking about Aid packages like we the general tax payers were paying for it when really thay is false. We benefit from the raw materials and products immensly and give little to nothing in return. So this topic was flawed and intellectually dishonest.
Cal..... was that a response toward the pompous charge? that was an odd post and not even a response to your ability to bust a fraud who does not know how to code in any of the myriad languages availabe but tries to pass of information like he does.
-
"Apparently" was sarcasm.
My point, is that the US (& imperial Europe) is/was only taking advantage of the corruption & greed already present in the countries. Capitalism didn't invent greed, as many of you like to believe.
To start a slave trade, a chief/ruler/whatever has to be willing to trade his own people for guns & booze. We didn't steal people.
To continue the blood diamond trade, those in charge are willing to allow the bloodshed & tyranny continue in exchange for a case of 7.63 x 39mm rounds & a pack of smokes every day. Those who "employ" their own villages to mine for the things. We aren't stealing them.
Just because you wouldn't dig through dirt for $.20/day with your uncle standing over top of you with a machete & a rusty Kalashnikova rifle doesn't mean that continent isn't being reimbursed.
-
good god legacy you cant be serious. You think we are not stealing because corps and countries are able to bribe a select few into enslaving or abusing their population?
If a advanced culture arms 100 strong men with rusty ak-47 against spears in order to retain control and then brings in their own private military contractors what exactly do you think that is?
wow justifying ecological disasters that corp KNOWINGLY fully realize they are doing because the limited knowledge of organized resistance and or governmental operations is ok and not stealing....
blood diamonds.....ok Debeers is banned in the united states as a monopoly and currently operates a HUGE private militia all over Africa.....
so slavery was not wrong for countries because someone was able to bribe some of the indegenous population? I am the athiest and you are a christian right? where is your moral compass?
-
good god legacy you cant be serious. You think we are not stealing because corps and countries are able to bribe a select few into enslaving or abusing their population?
If a advanced culture arms 100 strong men with rusty ak-47 against spears in order to retain control and then brings in their own private military contractors what exactly do you think that is?
wow justifying ecological disasters that corp KNOWINGLY fully realize they are doing because the limited knowledge of organized resistance and or governmental operations is ok and not stealing....
blood diamonds.....ok Debeers is banned in the united states as a monopoly and currently operates a HUGE private militia all over Africa.....
so slavery was not wrong for countries because someone was able to bribe some of the indegenous population? I am the athiest and you are a christian right? where is your moral compass?
good god legacy you cant be serious. You think we are not stealing because corps and countries are able to bribe a select few into enslaving or abusing their population?
So now world socialism is the goal?
You'll have a problem getting your fellow lefties to move into mud huts but maybe Obammy can give a speech...?
WSS
-
Sev, the FREAKIN POINT is...
that Africa is destitute in many countries, many, many areas....
and government dole "enslaves" people to dependency.
It has nothing to do with other countries going in there and
getting natural resources out of there, which they have done, you think that
is not by "permission" by whoever is the "government" now?
It has nothing to do with the slave trade. Did you know that
it was corrupt AFRICAN BLACKS who also were bringing AFRICAN BLACKS to
other countries to be slaves? Intertribe fighting and oppression has been
going on for how long now?
The Peace Corps has been working to teach a lot of the poor
to garden and farm for themselves. In some areas, that works.
But all too often, government dole breeds depency and sloth.
The African governments should have kicked out the diamond traders and foreign
natural resource groups who treated their poverty stricken "employees" so poorly
long ago.
but as usual in this world, those in power live and eat like kings, while their populace
suffers from poverty in the worst degree.
But poverty and infighting goes on, and so does the dependency of the poor Africans
who have not much choice, unless they can have gov's who will protect their FREEDOM
and can get some land and equipment to do their own farming.
Until then, whining that American farmers get assistance is ridiculous, depending on the weather,
a whole LOT of farmers could be wiped out by too much debt and no income, causing them to
not be able to fund the huge amount of $$$$ the next year to farm.
Weather affects food production. The system has checks and balances in it to perpetuate
the ability to farm.
It has nothing to do with keeping Africans poor.
Always the victimizing of themselves, and the rest of us and our country is the "bad guy".
Every freakin time ???
-
wss where you turned to the conclusion that systematic socialism is what I was proposing is extremely offbase,
Cal in that last post you where talking a awful lot about what governments in that continent should do and their responsibility for their people......
here is the problem.... if said government which i will refer to as X was developed and organized by colonialism and then with the subsequent world transition to capitalism is given option A which usually is we will help you initially if you give us all rights and access to your rescources you will be granted freedom and support.
well like the trickle down theory that fails to take into account human corruption those influences know factually that they can corrupt those individuals and do so. Its not rocket science and people dont often like to hear they benefit from less than moral actions such as what is used in Africa.
Diamonds.... oil... and tons of other minerals are extracted from that continent and we do prop up corps and policies that in fact do basically steal and poison from the local populace.
I do blame personal and governmental responsibility on the locals, I am realistice enough to understand the allure of money and support and how it affects a majority of people.
Its not our fault directly.... more indirectly and honestly ignorance by the out of sight out of mind principle. The aid packages that is talked about in the news is just marketing window dressing so our population thinks we are helping. Ultimately it is each countries and population responsibility, I just happen to hold the opinion that outside influeces now are too strong and ingrained generationally for the corruption to realistically change. Look at our own system which is completely corrupted and hijacked by money and special interest.
We dont exactly act or do much because we have our basic needs and entertainment value met.
-
Now you've aggravated me SEV. Very nice post...
Can't disagree, except the last line. Pres Bush invested more billions of $$$$$ to fight aids than ever before in our history...
but the $$$$ goes to? Depends on the governments. Corruption? Greed?
Sadly, seems to be any direction you can shake a stick.
-
Great Post Cal. Every word true. African countries are corrupt and aids infested. I guess that must be our fault. Everything it seems, is our fault. I have a suggestion to the liberals, if you don't like it here get the FOOK OUT! Move to Africa. Maybe Nigeria or Kenya. Help the poor people.
-
good god legacy you cant be serious. You think we are not stealing because corps and countries are able to bribe a select few into enslaving or abusing their population?
If a advanced culture arms 100 strong men with rusty ak-47 against spears in order to retain control and then brings in their own private military contractors what exactly do you think that is?
wow justifying ecological disasters that corp KNOWINGLY fully realize they are doing because the limited knowledge of organized resistance and or governmental operations is ok and not stealing....
blood diamonds.....ok Debeers is banned in the united states as a monopoly and currently operates a HUGE private militia all over Africa.....
so slavery was not wrong for countries because someone was able to bribe some of the indegenous population? I am the athiest and you are a christian right? where is your moral compass?
so slavery was not wrong for countries because someone was able to bribe some of the indegenous population? I am the athiest and you are a christian right? where is your moral compass?
I'm not saying it's right (nor did I ever hint at the notion that it would be). But you are way off base regarding the impetus of the slave trade. It had nothing to do with bribes. Rulers of indigenous tribes had goods we wanted (people), and we had goods they wanted (rum - which is why the triangle makes a pitstop in the West Indies, & guns). I think I learned about the barter system in 4th grade.
What I am saying, is that it's not our responsibility, as a nation, to "bring up the guy behind you." You and I as individuals can choose not to support companies that participate in any behavior we deem unfit for whatever reason. That would be where my moral compass comes in to play. I don't get to dictate what my moral compass should make you do - that's called fascism.
We've seen what playing World Police accomplishes (middle east). There are economic reasons for our presence there, and we are witnessing countries that stand up, and say they don't want to participate in the group back-scratch. But guess what? you can't cry foul when we stop paying for your drinks. The middle east's eternal routine of selling us oil for the price they set but bitching about the West being the cause for their poplulation's poverty is the same thing as the hot girl's fat friend who will drink all night on your tab, but then C-blocks you when it's time to cash in. Every once in a while, you've got to either accidentally push the tub-face down some stairs, or send in a super-drunk wingman (Israel) to distract her.
-
I wont get into a debate over African tribal slave trade because that is not the context of this post.
I dont want us to act as the world police either... Obviously I have a rabid hate for the neocons just because of their proactive interventionist theories.
However our nation has for the last 80 years wanted to be the leader and actively marketed and spread democracy and other moral principles. IF we are marketing the kool aid than maybe we should be leading by example.
IF its not ok to poison our own people and steal from them what makes it right for our corps under our laws to do so overseas? Humans are still humans regardless of what country they happen to inhabit. We are profiting immensly from their rescources while they live in squalid conditions and envirementally poisonous land.
I realize that life is basically a competition with winners and losers, but our wealthy country does not have to turn a blind eye like we do to how and where we benefit from.
-
I wont get into a debate over African tribal slave trade because that is not the context of this post.
I dont want us to act as the world police either... Obviously I have a rabid hate for the neocons just because of their proactive interventionist theories.
However our nation has for the last 80 years wanted to be the leader and actively marketed and spread democracy and other moral principles. IF we are marketing the kool aid than maybe we should be leading by example.
IF its not ok to poison our own people and steal from them what makes it right for our corps under our laws to do so overseas? Humans are still humans regardless of what country they happen to inhabit. We are profiting immensly from their rescources while they live in squalid conditions and envirementally poisonous land.
I realize that life is basically a competition with winners and losers, but our wealthy country does not have to turn a blind eye like we do to how and where we benefit from.
I wont get into a debate over African tribal slave trade because that is not the context of this post.
Well no, obviously not anymore, after I corrected you on the matter.
I dont want us to act as the world police either... Obviously I have a rabid hate for the neocons just because of their proactive interventionist theories.
However our nation has for the last 80 years wanted to be the leader and actively marketed and spread democracy and other moral principles. IF we are marketing the kool aid than maybe we should be leading by example.
IF its not ok to poison our own people and steal from them what makes it right for our corps under our laws to do so overseas? Humans are still humans regardless of what country they happen to inhabit. We are profiting immensly from their rescources while they live in squalid conditions and envirementally poisonous land.
I realize that life is basically a competition with winners and losers, but our wealthy country does not have to turn a blind eye like we do to how and where we benefit from.
Since we are on the subject of "stealing" natural resources, I'll refute your claim that it doesn't happen here in our country:
How many ballin' ass coal miners do you know? Have you ever been to a coal-mining town? Steve Jobs sure as shit isn't opening any apple-douche stores in Appalachia. Sure, there are some bigwigs in each town employed by various facets of the industry (research, mining, transport, etc.) Shouldn't those workers digging the shit out of the ground get paid like saudi princes?? Not unless you want to pay several thousand dollars a week heating/cooling your home. Man, we suck.
Loggers? Pretty dangerous work, those guys make decent livings, but are relatively poor when compared to other regions of the country. Maybe I haven't looked hard enough, but I haven't seen anybody chroming out their Stihl Farm boss' at the local small engine repair shop. That's not fair, right?
Daschle, Geitner & the gang command a pretty absurd salary relative to the work they perform, and owe more in taxes than 90% of the country makes in a year. Convince me they aren't stealing from our country, our people. I'll save you the trouble - you cant.
-
you corrected nothing nor proved anything dealing with slave trade origins of tribal groups versus european slave trade. Look up the definition of Bribe before you post again and how it related to giving something for an expected return. You are trying to move into a sematics argument.
A common defense when someone is wrong or put in a position where they can no longer defend a flawed claim is to change the focus of the subject. We were talking about AFrica nor did I ever make the claim that theft of rescources here in the states does not happen. It does not happen no where even close to what we are factually doing in other continents.
Yes I have been to coal mining towns in WV and south eastern ohio.
First for you to compare U.S. workers in either the loggin industry or Coal mining industry is laughable. Obviously you have never been to any region of Africa. The poverty level and education/understanding of an average worker versus other oppurtunities that are available in each respective country is no where near comparable.
We have lawyers and NGO's along with official agencies along with competent medical facilities versus well NOTHING in most of those countries. The EPA when it does work along with state agencies are 1,000,000 more organized and backed up socially and structually than any African country has.
Legacy the people of those countries are being abused just like they would be anywhere there is not sufficient oversight. It happens here still but there are too many spotlights that can illuminate and prosecute those problems. Most African nations are like when were expanding West as a naion.... fairly lawless and corrurtable.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login