PFF's Ranking the NFL Top Ten QB's

[Flyin J]

haha Tannehill over Luck? Their "system" is flawed...

[The Gipper]

@canton-dawg said:

Agree or disagree?

1) Aaron Rodgers

2) Drew Brees

3) Ben Roethlesburger

4) Philip Rivers

Still needs to win something

5) Peyton Manning

6) Tom Brady

7) Tony Romo

Still mostly chokes

Matt Ryan

May be worst QB in his division....Cam Newton showing better, he is not on here. Winston will be better in time.

9) Russell Wilson

10) Ryan Tannehill

Tannehill lucky to break top half. I am not convinced that Josh McCown may not be better this year.

He may end up being the worst QB in Florida before the year is over.

No Andrew Luck?

Yea, Luck, Newton absolutely better than Tannehill....and maybe a half dozen others.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2015/08/25/ranking-the-nfls-top-10-qbs/

[Mudfly]

I would correct that this is one mans projection.... "using" PFF rankings...but not the actual PFF rankings from last season.....

which were.....

1) Aaron Rodgers
2) Drew Brees
3) Ben Roethlesburger
4) Tom Brady
5) Matt Ryan
6) Cam Newton
7) Tony Romo
Phillip Rivers
9) Andrew Luck
10) Peyton Manning...

[wargograw]

They allow Luck to be sloppy in Indy.

[Represent]

1. A Rodgers

2. Brady

3. P Manning

4. Andrew Luck

5. Big Ben

6. Drew Brees

7. Russel Wilson

8. E Manning

9. Matt Ryan

10. Carson Palmer

Current top ten imo

[Westside Steve]

I'm not sure that I wouldn't put Tom Brady at number one. I detect the faint aroma of sour grapes here.

WSS

[Mike H]

My top 10 for 2015-

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Drew Brees

3. Tom Brady

4. Peyton Manning

5. Andrew Luck

6. Big Ben

7. Russell Wilson

8. Phillip Rivers

9. Matt Ryan

10. Tony Romo

[Zombo]

1. Rodgers

2. Brady

3. Manning

4. Brees

5. Luck

6. Ben

7. Romo

8. Rivers

9. Wilson

10. Flacco

[The Gipper]

Top Ten:

1 Rodgers

2. Brady

3. Peyton

4. Brees

5. Roethisberger

6. Luck

7. Wilson

8. Flacco

9. Rivers

10. Newton

Next :

11. Eli

12. Kaepernick

13. Palmer

14. Foles

15. Romo

16. Ryan

17. Dalton

18. Carr

19. Tw-Tw-Twatwater

20. Alex Smith

21. Cutler

22. Bortles

23. Tannehill

24. Cassell

25. McCown

26. Hoyer

27. Bradford

28. Fitzpatrick

29. RGII

30. Winston

31. Mariota

....and I missed one.

I think, Stafford....who should go in between Foles and Romo.

[nickers]

Rodgers

Brady

Manning

Brees

Ben rape

Wilson

Eli

Flacco

Rivers

Tannehil

[Aggie Brown fan]

T1. Brady/Rodgers

3. Romo

4. Manning

5. Brees

6. Rapist

7. Flacco

8. Luck

9. Rivers

10. Ryan

Romo gets a bad rap, but he is a great qb. Eli, Rapist, and Wilson benefitted from great defenses. Rapist had a passer rating of 9, NINE, in his first Super Bowl win.

Peyton is a shell of what he once was, and Brees is also on the down slope.

[Tour2ma]

@wargograw said:

They allow Luck to be sloppy in Indy.

Not sure about "allow", but the Colts have put the team on their QB's back to a greater degree... have ask him to win with less support... than any other NFL club. Same was true of Manning in his early Indy days.

[The Gipper]

@aggie-brown-fan said:

T1. Brady/Rodgers

3. Romo

4. Manning

5. Brees

6. Rapist

7. Flacco

8. Luck

9. Rivers

10. Ryan

Romo gets a bad rap, but he is a great qb. Eli, Rapist, and Wilson benefitted from great defenses. Rapist had a passer rating of 9, NINE, in his first Super Bowl win.

Peyton is a shell of what he once was, and Brees is also on the down slope.

Not under any circumstance is Romo a "great QB". And he is not that much younger than Brees....only @15 months:

Brees born 1/15/79, Romo 4/21/80. He is older than Vick/BR/Eli/Rivers/Palmer.

[StinkHole]

@the-gipper said:

Top Ten:

1 Rodgers

2. Brady

3. Peyton

4. Brees

5. Roethisberger

6. Luck

7. Wilson

8. Flacco

9. Rivers

10. Newton

Next :

11. Eli

12. Kaepernick

13. Palmer

14. Foles

15. Romo

16. Ryan

17. Dalton

18. Carr

19. Tw-Tw-Twatwater

20. Alex Smith

21. Cutler

22. Bortles

23. Tannehill

24. Cassell

25. McCown

26. Hoyer

27. Bradford

28. Fitzpatrick

29. RGII

30. Winston

31. Mariota

....and I missed one.

I think, Stafford....who should go in between Foles and Romo.

I like Ben in the middle of the top 10 as well. The only thing I would change is switch Hoyer and McCown. From what I've been hearing, Hoyer has impressed in camp. Was named the starter.

[Aggie Brown fan]

@the-gipper said:

Not under any circumstance is Romo a "great QB". And he is not that much younger than Brees....only @15 months:

Brees born 1/15/79, Romo 4/21/80. He is older than Vick/BR/Eli/Rivers/Palmer.

Top 5 career passer rating leaders:

1. Rodgers

2. Romo

3. Manning

4. Young

5. Brady

Yeah, I would hate to be in that group. He's also 14th in career 4th quarter comebacks.

He lead the league in qbr last year and was a Dez Bryant "drop" away from playing Seattle in the nfc championship game. He did this with a back so bad he rarely practiced.

His back is much better this year, which is why I put him 3rd.

[The Gipper]

@stinkhole said:

I like Ben in the middle of the top 10 as well. The only thing I would change is switch Hoyer and McCown. From what I've been hearing, Hoyer has impressed in camp. Was named the starter.

When we get down that low it is quibbling. I thought about switching them....but felt it didn't matter.

[The Gipper]

@aggie-brown-fan said:

Top 5 career passer rating leaders:

1. Rodgers

2. Romo

3. Manning

4. Young

5. Brady

Yeah, I would hate to be in that group. He's also 14th in career 4th quarter comebacks.

He lead the league in qbr last year and was a Dez Bryant "drop" away from playing Seattle in the nfc championship game. He did this with a back so bad he rarely practiced.

His back is much better this year, which is why I put him 3rd.

Only a sychophant homer would put Romo up there.

[Aggie Brown fan]

Only a dumbass would say the number 2 all time passer rating qb isn't great. Give him a good defense and he wins a Super Bowl or 2. Don't listen to me, though. Listen to every analyst on TV that used to play qb. Dilfer, Young, Aikman, Marino, Esiason, Simms - they acknowledge how good Romo is.

[BrownsFan4Evr]

[The Gipper]

@aggie-brown-fan said:

Only a dumbass would say the number 2 all time passer rating qb isn't great. Give him a good defense and he wins a Super Bowl or 2. Don't listen to me, though. Listen to every analyst on TV that used to play qb. Dilfer, Young, Aikman, Marino, Esiason, Simms - they acknowledge how good Romo is.

Only a dumbass would put that much stock into passer rating. Chad Pennington and Jeff Garcia are also very high on that list. OK, I will give you that Romo is in a class with those two.

You used the term "great".....and that just does not apply to him. He is just "good". And Romo isn't as good as any of the names you just used....except Dilfer.