PFF's Ranking the NFL Top Ten QB's
-
I would correct that this is one mans projection.... "using" PFF rankings...but not the actual PFF rankings from last season.....
which were.....
1) Aaron Rodgers
2) Drew Brees
3) Ben Roethlesburger
4) Tom Brady
5) Matt Ryan
6) Cam Newton
7) Tony Romo
Phillip Rivers
9) Andrew Luck
10) Peyton Manning... -
-
1. A Rodgers
2. Brady
3. P Manning
4. Andrew Luck
5. Big Ben
6. Drew Brees
7. Russel Wilson
8. E Manning
9. Matt Ryan
10. Carson Palmer
Current top ten imo
-
I'm not sure that I wouldn't put Tom Brady at number one. I detect the faint aroma of sour grapes here.
WSS
-
Top Ten:
1 Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Peyton
4. Brees
5. Roethisberger
6. Luck
7. Wilson
8. Flacco
9. Rivers
10. Newton
Next :
11. Eli
12. Kaepernick
13. Palmer
14. Foles
15. Romo
16. Ryan
17. Dalton
18. Carr
19. Tw-Tw-Twatwater
20. Alex Smith
21. Cutler
22. Bortles
23. Tannehill
24. Cassell
25. McCown
26. Hoyer
27. Bradford
28. Fitzpatrick
29. RGII
30. Winston
31. Mariota
....and I missed one.
I think, Stafford....who should go in between Foles and Romo.
-
T1. Brady/Rodgers
3. Romo
4. Manning
5. Brees
6. Rapist
7. Flacco
8. Luck
9. Rivers
10. Ryan
Romo gets a bad rap, but he is a great qb. Eli, Rapist, and Wilson benefitted from great defenses. Rapist had a passer rating of 9, NINE, in his first Super Bowl win.
Peyton is a shell of what he once was, and Brees is also on the down slope.
-
They allow Luck to be sloppy in Indy.
Not sure about "allow", but the Colts have put the team on their QB's back to a greater degree... have ask him to win with less support... than any other NFL club. Same was true of Manning in his early Indy days.
-
T1. Brady/Rodgers
3. Romo
4. Manning
5. Brees
6. Rapist
7. Flacco
8. Luck
9. Rivers
10. Ryan
Romo gets a bad rap, but he is a great qb. Eli, Rapist, and Wilson benefitted from great defenses. Rapist had a passer rating of 9, NINE, in his first Super Bowl win.
Peyton is a shell of what he once was, and Brees is also on the down slope.
T1. Brady/Rodgers
3. Romo
4. Manning
5. Brees
6. Rapist
7. Flacco
8. Luck
9. Rivers
10. Ryan
Romo gets a bad rap, but he is a great qb. Eli, Rapist, and Wilson benefitted from great defenses. Rapist had a passer rating of 9, NINE, in his first Super Bowl win.
Peyton is a shell of what he once was, and Brees is also on the down slope.
Not under any circumstance is Romo a "great QB". And he is not that much younger than Brees....only @15 months:
Brees born 1/15/79, Romo 4/21/80. He is older than Vick/BR/Eli/Rivers/Palmer.
-
Top Ten:
1 Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Peyton
4. Brees
5. Roethisberger
6. Luck
7. Wilson
8. Flacco
9. Rivers
10. Newton
Next :
11. Eli
12. Kaepernick
13. Palmer
14. Foles
15. Romo
16. Ryan
17. Dalton
18. Carr
19. Tw-Tw-Twatwater
20. Alex Smith
21. Cutler
22. Bortles
23. Tannehill
24. Cassell
25. McCown
26. Hoyer
27. Bradford
28. Fitzpatrick
29. RGII
30. Winston
31. Mariota
....and I missed one.
I think, Stafford....who should go in between Foles and Romo.
Top Ten:
1 Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Peyton
4. Brees
5. Roethisberger
6. Luck
7. Wilson
8. Flacco
9. Rivers
10. Newton
Next :
11. Eli
12. Kaepernick
13. Palmer
14. Foles
15. Romo
16. Ryan
17. Dalton
18. Carr
19. Tw-Tw-Twatwater
20. Alex Smith
21. Cutler
22. Bortles
23. Tannehill
24. Cassell
25. McCown
26. Hoyer
27. Bradford
28. Fitzpatrick
29. RGII
30. Winston
31. Mariota
....and I missed one.
I think, Stafford....who should go in between Foles and Romo.
I like Ben in the middle of the top 10 as well. The only thing I would change is switch Hoyer and McCown. From what I've been hearing, Hoyer has impressed in camp. Was named the starter.
-
T1. Brady/Rodgers
3. Romo
4. Manning
5. Brees
6. Rapist
7. Flacco
8. Luck
9. Rivers
10. Ryan
Romo gets a bad rap, but he is a great qb. Eli, Rapist, and Wilson benefitted from great defenses. Rapist had a passer rating of 9, NINE, in his first Super Bowl win.
Peyton is a shell of what he once was, and Brees is also on the down slope.
Not under any circumstance is Romo a "great QB". And he is not that much younger than Brees....only @15 months:
Brees born 1/15/79, Romo 4/21/80. He is older than Vick/BR/Eli/Rivers/Palmer.
Not under any circumstance is Romo a "great QB". And he is not that much younger than Brees....only @15 months:
Brees born 1/15/79, Romo 4/21/80. He is older than Vick/BR/Eli/Rivers/Palmer.
Top 5 career passer rating leaders:
1. Rodgers
2. Romo
3. Manning
4. Young
5. Brady
Yeah, I would hate to be in that group. He's also 14th in career 4th quarter comebacks.
He lead the league in qbr last year and was a Dez Bryant "drop" away from playing Seattle in the nfc championship game. He did this with a back so bad he rarely practiced.
His back is much better this year, which is why I put him 3rd.
-
Top Ten:
1 Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Peyton
4. Brees
5. Roethisberger
6. Luck
7. Wilson
8. Flacco
9. Rivers
10. Newton
Next :
11. Eli
12. Kaepernick
13. Palmer
14. Foles
15. Romo
16. Ryan
17. Dalton
18. Carr
19. Tw-Tw-Twatwater
20. Alex Smith
21. Cutler
22. Bortles
23. Tannehill
24. Cassell
25. McCown
26. Hoyer
27. Bradford
28. Fitzpatrick
29. RGII
30. Winston
31. Mariota
....and I missed one.
I think, Stafford....who should go in between Foles and Romo.
I like Ben in the middle of the top 10 as well. The only thing I would change is switch Hoyer and McCown. From what I've been hearing, Hoyer has impressed in camp. Was named the starter.
I like Ben in the middle of the top 10 as well. The only thing I would change is switch Hoyer and McCown. From what I've been hearing, Hoyer has impressed in camp. Was named the starter.
When we get down that low it is quibbling. I thought about switching them....but felt it didn't matter.
-
Not under any circumstance is Romo a "great QB". And he is not that much younger than Brees....only @15 months:
Brees born 1/15/79, Romo 4/21/80. He is older than Vick/BR/Eli/Rivers/Palmer.
Top 5 career passer rating leaders:
1. Rodgers
2. Romo
3. Manning
4. Young
5. Brady
Yeah, I would hate to be in that group. He's also 14th in career 4th quarter comebacks.
He lead the league in qbr last year and was a Dez Bryant "drop" away from playing Seattle in the nfc championship game. He did this with a back so bad he rarely practiced.
His back is much better this year, which is why I put him 3rd.
Top 5 career passer rating leaders:
1. Rodgers
2. Romo
3. Manning
4. Young
5. Brady
Yeah, I would hate to be in that group. He's also 14th in career 4th quarter comebacks.
He lead the league in qbr last year and was a Dez Bryant "drop" away from playing Seattle in the nfc championship game. He did this with a back so bad he rarely practiced.
His back is much better this year, which is why I put him 3rd.
Only a sychophant homer would put Romo up there.
-
Only a dumbass would say the number 2 all time passer rating qb isn't great. Give him a good defense and he wins a Super Bowl or 2. Don't listen to me, though. Listen to every analyst on TV that used to play qb. Dilfer, Young, Aikman, Marino, Esiason, Simms - they acknowledge how good Romo is.
-
-
Only a dumbass would say the number 2 all time passer rating qb isn't great. Give him a good defense and he wins a Super Bowl or 2. Don't listen to me, though. Listen to every analyst on TV that used to play qb. Dilfer, Young, Aikman, Marino, Esiason, Simms - they acknowledge how good Romo is.
Only a dumbass would say the number 2 all time passer rating qb isn't great. Give him a good defense and he wins a Super Bowl or 2. Don't listen to me, though. Listen to every analyst on TV that used to play qb. Dilfer, Young, Aikman, Marino, Esiason, Simms - they acknowledge how good Romo is.
Only a dumbass would put that much stock into passer rating. Chad Pennington and Jeff Garcia are also very high on that list. OK, I will give you that Romo is in a class with those two.
You used the term "great".....and that just does not apply to him. He is just "good". And Romo isn't as good as any of the names you just used....except Dilfer.
-
This Tony Romo:
-
Um, passer rating and qbr is how you judge qb's. Romo doesn't play defense.
Russell Wilson is a good kid and a good qb, and people like you will say he's a better qb than Romo because he "won" a Super Bowl.
The reality is football is a team game, and Wilson has benefitted from one of the greatest defenses in NFL history. He is nowhere near the qb that Romo is. Romo has suffered through horrible defenses and a non-existent running game for much of his career, but gets all the blame for every 8-8 season, when without him they would be 3-13 those seasons.
Last season, Dallas was 19th in team defense, and still were 1 play away from the nfc championship game. The only playoff teams with worse defenses were Arizona and Cincy.
Believe what you want to believe. You're far from the only person that thinks Romo's not good. When he retires, his numbers will be huge, but he will always be knocked for not winning the big one.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login