Skip to content

Justin Gilbert told the coaches he wouldn't play for them.

The Browns Board
95 38 4.5k
  • @andeftw said:

    No sympathy for either of those players, but Gilbert was a Pettine pick. Where were these character red flags when he drafted the guy?

    I assumed we had a GM and a scouting staff and Pettine was the coach.

    Z

    Zombo said:

    I assumed we had a GM and a scouting staff and Pettine was the coach.

    Z

    A coach identifies a player he wants on the team who is projected to be a first round pick but doesn't take part in the pre-draft interviews? Not saying the blame is solely on Pettine, but he's got part of the responsibility. Manziel on the other hand is all on Haslam and the front office.

  • People forgot about all the red flags on Hall of Famer Randy Moss. Sometimes you get a Moss, sometimes a Gordon.

  • Zombo said:

    I assumed we had a GM and a scouting staff and Pettine was the coach.

    Z

    A coach identifies a player he wants on the team who is projected to be a first round pick but doesn't take part in the pre-draft interviews? Not saying the blame is solely on Pettine, but he's got part of the responsibility. Manziel on the other hand is all on Haslam and the front office.

    @andeftw said:

    A coach identifies a player he wants on the team who is projected to be a first round pick but doesn't take part in the pre-draft interviews? Not saying the blame is solely on Pettine, but he's got part of the responsibility. Manziel on the other hand is all on Haslam and the front office.

    Pettine says "I need a cover corner"

    Scouting dept. says " We have a great one for you. No red flags here. Loves the game"

    ... we are mad at Pettine for wanting a cover corner??

    Poor dude ended his career with three safeties and a 6th round rookie playing against Roethlisberger and Brown ... and hung in there for three quarters!

    Z

  • Keep Gilbert on and make him inactive every game

  • @walterwhite said:

    SC Cleveland™ ‏@SC_Cleveland 1m

    Browns team source says Justin Gilbert told coaches he wouldn't go into game today. #browns via @LaurenBrill5

    7 retweets8 likes

    I never like to see anybody lose their job - I have been there more than once, myself - but it sounds like there was/is a mutiny on the team.

    A HC coach should be able to support and - to a certain extent - shield his players from a dysfunctional owner (as an example)

    Reading Zombo's post about JFF being out the night before a game, the rumblings about Thomas and Mack wanting out and this report (assuming all are true) tells me the coach lost control.

    If the first line of coaching loses control, there is nothing else to control. The inmates will grown in number.............

    @chicopee-john said:

    I never like to see anybody lose their job - I have been there more than once, myself - but it sounds like there was/is a mutiny on the team.

    A HC coach should be able to support and - to a certain extent - shield his players from a dysfunctional owner (as an example)

    Reading Zombo's post about JFF being out the night before a game, the rumblings about Thomas and Mack wanting out and this report (assuming all are true) tells me the coach lost control.

    If the first line of coaching loses control, there is nothing else to control. The inmates will grown in number.............

    Yes, the ship has headed to the bottom of the great blue.

    @richiswhere said:

    Good post but I would like add maybe he never had the right type of control. Because if there are leeches on the team the HC should have every right to say "get them the hell out of here"

    This- you possibly think Pettine didn't want to cut Bowe, and Farmer wouldn't let him? I duly note Farmer was the first to go. So MHO is Farmer ranks first in the blame game in Jimmuh's mind?

    There was a lot of dead wood besides Gilbert I have to think Pettine would have unloaded, but Ray was loving his picks.

  • @andeftw said:

    A coach identifies a player he wants on the team who is projected to be a first round pick but doesn't take part in the pre-draft interviews? Not saying the blame is solely on Pettine, but he's got part of the responsibility. Manziel on the other hand is all on Haslam and the front office.

    Pettine says "I need a cover corner"

    Scouting dept. says " We have a great one for you. No red flags here. Loves the game"

    ... we are mad at Pettine for wanting a cover corner??

    Poor dude ended his career with three safeties and a 6th round rookie playing against Roethlisberger and Brown ... and hung in there for three quarters!

    Z

    Zombo said:

    Pettine says "I need a cover corner"

    Scouting dept. says " We have a great one for you. No red flags here. Loves the game"

    ... we are mad at Pettine for wanting a cover corner??

    Poor dude ended his career with three safeties and a 6th round rookie playing against Roethlisberger and Brown ... and hung in there for three quarters!

    Z

    Yeah- see my comments in the gameday thread. We lost because Davis played an incredibly shitty game, and you can't blame a depleted secondary for not being able to cover a 1,000+ yard receiver.

  • @andeftw said:

    A coach identifies a player he wants on the team who is projected to be a first round pick but doesn't take part in the pre-draft interviews? Not saying the blame is solely on Pettine, but he's got part of the responsibility. Manziel on the other hand is all on Haslam and the front office.

    Pettine says "I need a cover corner"

    Scouting dept. says " We have a great one for you. No red flags here. Loves the game"

    ... we are mad at Pettine for wanting a cover corner??

    Poor dude ended his career with three safeties and a 6th round rookie playing against Roethlisberger and Brown ... and hung in there for three quarters!

    Z

    Zombo said:

    Pettine says "I need a cover corner"

    Scouting dept. says " We have a great one for you. No red flags here. Loves the game"

    ... we are made at Pettine for wanting a cover corner??

    Poor dude ended his career with three safeties and a 6th round rookie playing against Roethlisberger and Brown ... and hung in there for three quarters!

    Z

    Maybe things work differently with the Browns, but with the Packers McCarthy also plays a role in the draft process. These character red flags should come up during pre-draft interviews. But then again Manziel had everybody fooled, so maybe I've got it all wrong.

    I like Pettine, would be happy to see him get another chance to prove himself. Plenty of things that went wrong with the organisation this year have nothing do with him. To me, the Gilbert thing blowing up is one of the few - and even then, it's not all on him.

  • @chicopee-john said:

    I never like to see anybody lose their job - I have been there more than once, myself - but it sounds like there was/is a mutiny on the team.

    A HC coach should be able to support and - to a certain extent - shield his players from a dysfunctional owner (as an example)

    Reading Zombo's post about JFF being out the night before a game, the rumblings about Thomas and Mack wanting out and this report (assuming all are true) tells me the coach lost control.

    If the first line of coaching loses control, there is nothing else to control. The inmates will grown in number.............

    Yes, the ship has headed to the bottom of the great blue.

    @richiswhere said:

    Good post but I would like add maybe he never had the right type of control. Because if there are leeches on the team the HC should have every right to say "get them the hell out of here"

    This- you possibly think Pettine didn't want to cut Bowe, and Farmer wouldn't let him? I duly note Farmer was the first to go. So MHO is Farmer ranks first in the blame game in Jimmuh's mind?

    There was a lot of dead wood besides Gilbert I have to think Pettine would have unloaded, but Ray was loving his picks.

    @hoorta said:

    This- you possibly think Pettine didn't want to cut Bowe, and Farmer wouldn't let him? I duly note Farmer was the first to go. So MHO is Farmer ranks first in the blame game in Jimmuh's mind?

    There was a lot of dead wood besides Gilbert I have to think Pettine would have unloaded, but Ray was loving his picks.

    It was pretty obvious that there were a few guys Pettine didn't want around. 😮

    As far as getting fired first or second it doesn't really matter cause the both lost.

  • Zombo said:

    Pettine says "I need a cover corner"

    Scouting dept. says " We have a great one for you. No red flags here. Loves the game"

    ... we are mad at Pettine for wanting a cover corner??

    Poor dude ended his career with three safeties and a 6th round rookie playing against Roethlisberger and Brown ... and hung in there for three quarters!

    Z

    Yeah- see my comments in the gameday thread. We lost because Davis played an incredibly shitty game, and you can't blame a depleted secondary for not being able to cover a 1,000+ yard receiver.

    @hoorta said:

    Yeah- see my comments in the gameday thread. We lost because Davis played an incredibly shitty game, and you can't blame a depleted secondary for not being able to cover a 1,000+ yard receiver.

    Never said anything close to that...

  • He's gay. Everybody in Cleveland knows this. Get over yourself Justine. If he really pulled this shit then a teammate should have punched him.

  • Gay gay? Or just gay?

    Z

  • Sorry but Pettine wasn't in charge of personnel decisions.

    He had input, sure - but the guy who's job description includes responsibility for personnel is the one who got rightly canned

  • And we know it wouldn't be Joe Thomas because when the fuck has he ever stood up for anybody. Certainly not when the Steelers were knocking guys out (Cribbs, MoMass maybe?)

    This team is full of marshmallows.

  • Gay gay? Or just gay?

    Z

    Zombo said:

    Gay gay? Or just gay?

    Z

    What's the difference?

  • Zombo said:

    Gay gay? Or just gay?

    Z

    What's the difference?

    @letsgojackets said:

    What's the difference?

    Is he just a pussy, or is he a pussy that is an actial homosexual? Makes no difference to me, but it does in an NFL locker room.

    Z

  • @letsgojackets said:

    What's the difference?

    Is he just a pussy, or is he a pussy that is an actial homosexual? Makes no difference to me, but it does in an NFL locker room.

    Z

    Zombo said:

    Is he just a pussy, or is he a pussy that is an actial homosexual? Makes no difference to me, but it does in an NFL locker room.

    Z

    No he's gay and he's not the only one on the team but he's being paid millions of dollars to tell his coach no? Fuck him.

  • I am almost embarresed. Think soon we are going to turn into philly fans. Boo the good things on life like Santa. ?

  • Pettine drafted Justin Gilbert and Haslam demanded Manziel. At least this explains why no Khalil Mack, wide receiver, QB. So goodbye to two Guys who made a ton of money and could retire if they were me.

    Since there are only 32 Head coaches and 32 General Managers in the world, there's no excuse for Haslam not to find capable replacements.

    I realize Pettine was a last minute hire because Joe Banner screwed Greg Sciano when he showed up for an interview. There's nothing like a dysfunctional owner running an even more dysfunctional team. Then drafting two of the most dysfunctional players to come along since Charles White!

    Good Luck Haslam! I will be holding my breath for anyone better than the last two idiots!

  • Zombo said:

    Pettine says "I need a cover corner"

    Scouting dept. says " We have a great one for you. No red flags here. Loves the game"

    ... we are made at Pettine for wanting a cover corner??

    Poor dude ended his career with three safeties and a 6th round rookie playing against Roethlisberger and Brown ... and hung in there for three quarters!

    Z

    Maybe things work differently with the Browns, but with the Packers McCarthy also plays a role in the draft process. These character red flags should come up during pre-draft interviews. But then again Manziel had everybody fooled, so maybe I've got it all wrong.

    I like Pettine, would be happy to see him get another chance to prove himself. Plenty of things that went wrong with the organisation this year have nothing do with him. To me, the Gilbert thing blowing up is one of the few - and even then, it's not all on him.

    @andeftw said:

    Maybe things work differently with the Browns, but with the Packers McCarthy also plays a role in the draft process. These character red flags should come up during pre-draft interviews. But then again Manziel had everybody fooled, so maybe I've got it all wrong.

    I like Pettine, would be happy to see him get another chance to prove himself. Plenty of things that went wrong with the organisation this year have nothing do with him. To me, the Gilbert thing blowing up is one of the few - and even then, it's not all on him.

    It was Pettine who wanted Gilbert!

  • @andeftw said:

    Maybe things work differently with the Browns, but with the Packers McCarthy also plays a role in the draft process. These character red flags should come up during pre-draft interviews. But then again Manziel had everybody fooled, so maybe I've got it all wrong.

    I like Pettine, would be happy to see him get another chance to prove himself. Plenty of things that went wrong with the organisation this year have nothing do with him. To me, the Gilbert thing blowing up is one of the few - and even then, it's not all on him.

    It was Pettine who wanted Gilbert!

    @opal312 said:

    It was Pettine who wanted Gilbert!

    based upon Farmers scouting.....

    Its not Pettines job to evaluate college talent.....just to communicate his needs so the GM can offer up options....